×

Image sourced from eBay listings

Best Modern Horizons 3 Commander MTG Cards Under $25 (2026 Budget Guide)

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Modern Horizons 3 offers compelling Commander staples that remain accessible under $25, with cards like The Reaver Cleaver selling for $24.94 and Lazotep Quarry [Foil] at $22.89, indicating strong collector interest even at this price tier. These budget-friendly picks provide immediate impact for existing decks or serve as solid building blocks for new Commander creations.

Last week someone paid $24.94 for a single The Reaver Cleaver card on eBay. That sale tells us something specific about where this market is heading: even with the higher-profile chase cards from Modern Horizons 3 commanding significant premiums, there’s a robust secondary market for powerful, well-designed cards that fit directly into popular formats like Commander. For under $25, collectors can still acquire potent spells and utility lands that offer immediate gameplay benefits and potential for future value appreciation. This guide highlights ten such picks, drawing on verified eBay sold comps to identify cards that punch above their weight class and represent smart acquisitions for any Commander player on a budget.

In This Article

• The Under-$25 Picks

• How Far Does $100 Stretch?

• What to SKIP at This Price Point

• Pro Tip: Navigating Foil Premiums

• Frequently Asked Questions

The Under-$25 Picks

Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices. All figures as of October 2026.

1. The Reaver Cleaver (217)

The Reaver Cleaver, priced at a market value of $24.94, stands out as a top-tier artifact for Commander players looking to maximize value from sacrifice-based strategies. This equipment piece grants a significant advantage by providing a treasure token whenever an artifact or creature is sacrificed. In Commander, where artifact synergies are rampant and creature sacrifice is a common theme, The Reaver Cleaver can rapidly accelerate your mana base and fuel explosive turns. Its ability to draw a card upon attacking with the equipped creature further enhances its value, turning each combat step into a potential resource advantage. For collectors and players alike, this card represents a powerful tool that can elevate decks focused on goblins, artifacts, or even graveyard-centric strategies.

Buy The Reaver Cleaver on TCGPlayer Buy The Reaver Cleaver on eBay

2. Lazotep Quarry [Foil] (79)

At $22.89, Lazotep Quarry [Foil] offers a glimpse into the utility of conditional fast lands in the Modern Horizons 3 Commander set. This dual-land, producing Blue and Black mana, enters the battlefield untapped if you reveal another land card with the same name from your hand or if you already control a land with the same name. This mechanic allows for crucial early-game mana development, enabling faster plays and more consistent turns. While the conditionality might seem restrictive, in Commander, where players often hold multiple land drops or have specific sequencing in mind, Lazotep Quarry can be a vital piece of mana fixing. Its foil treatment adds a desirable aesthetic for collectors who appreciate premium card finishes.

Buy Lazotep Quarry [Foil] on TCGPlayer Buy Lazotep Quarry [Foil] on eBay

3. Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth [Foil] (409)

Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth [Foil] commands a price of $20.08 and is an absolute must-have for any Commander player building around Green mana or powerful land synergies. This legendary land uniquely turns all lands into Forests in addition to their other types. The implications for mana fixing and enabling Green-specific spells and abilities are profound. It ensures that any land can tap for Green, making ramp spells incredibly reliable and making Green-based mana dorks even more potent. For decks that rely heavily on land drops, such as those with landfall triggers or devoted to mana ramp, Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth provides unparalleled consistency. The foil version adds significant aesthetic appeal for collectors.

Buy Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth [Foil] on TCGPlayer Buy Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth [Foil] on eBay

4. Eldritch Immunity [Foil] (33)

Priced at $19.50, Eldritch Immunity [Foil] offers a powerful defensive option for creature-centric Commander decks. This enchantment provides two crucial layers of protection: creatures you control can’t be destroyed, and they gain hexproof. In a format where targeted removal and board wipes are commonplace, having creatures that are immune to destruction and cannot be targeted by opponents’ spells is an enormous advantage. This card can effectively shield your most important threats, ensuring your game plan can proceed without interruption. For players who value resilience and wish to protect their commander and key creatures, Eldritch Immunity is an invaluable addition, with the foil treatment enhancing its collectible status.

Buy Eldritch Immunity [Foil] on TCGPlayer Buy Eldritch Immunity [Foil] on eBay

5. Akroma’s Will [Foil] (165)

With a market price of $18.88, Akroma’s Will [Foil] is a potent game-ending instant that can swing combat in your favor or provide crucial board protection. When cast, it grants all creatures you control +6/+6, flying, vigilance, and indestructible. If you control a white creature, it additionally grants them protection from all colors. This single card can turn an otherwise losing board state into a decisive victory. In Commander, where creature combat is frequent, the massive stat boost and layered protection make Akroma’s Will an overwhelming force. Its ability to function as both an offensive finisher and a defensive trump card makes it highly sought after. The foil version appeals to collectors seeking premium copies.

Buy Akroma’s Will [Foil] on TCGPlayer Buy Akroma’s Will [Foil] on eBay

6. Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth (409)

The non-foil version of Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth, priced at $17.46, offers nearly all the benefits of its foil counterpart at a more accessible price point. This legendary land’s ability to make all lands Forests is a game-changer for Green-based Commander decks. It significantly boosts mana consistency, allowing players to reliably cast their Green spells and activate abilities. Furthermore, it synergizes powerfully with cards that care about land types, such as those with landfall triggers or those that specifically benefit from having Forests. For Commander players who prioritize functionality and strategic advantage over cosmetic upgrades, the regular Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth is an exceptional value, providing a core piece of mana fixing for a wide array of decks.

Buy Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth on TCGPlayer Buy Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth on eBay

7. Horizon of Progress [Foil] (78)

Horizon of Progress [Foil], available for $17.28, is a valuable addition for players seeking to optimize their early game mana development, particularly in Green-based strategies. This land enters the battlefield untapped if you control two or fewer other lands, making it an ideal pick for the first or second land drop. It then taps for Green mana, or colorless mana. This conditional nature allows for faster ramp and deployment of early-game threats, crucial for establishing a board presence in Commander. Its efficiency in accelerating your mana curve can give you a significant tempo advantage over opponents. The foil finish makes it an attractive piece for collectors who value aesthetically pleasing cards.

Buy Horizon of Progress [Foil] on TCGPlayer Buy Horizon of Progress [Foil] on eBay

8. Goldspan Dragon [Foil] (212)

Goldspan Dragon [Foil], currently priced at $17.24, is a formidable creature that excels in aggressive and value-oriented Commander decks. This dragon not only serves as a significant aerial threat with its flying and 4/4 stats, but it also generates a Treasure token whenever it attacks. This treasure token can be sacrificed for one mana of any color, effectively reducing the cost of your next spell or activating abilities. This creates a potent engine for explosive turns, allowing you to cast multiple spells in a single turn or power out even larger threats. The synergy with treasure-based strategies, coupled with its raw power, makes Goldspan Dragon a highly desirable card. Its foil treatment adds to its appeal for collectors.

Buy Goldspan Dragon [Foil] on TCGPlayer Buy Goldspan Dragon [Foil] on eBay

9. Selvala, Heart of the Wilds [Foil] (246)

Selvala, Heart of the Wilds [Foil], available for $17.13, is a premier mana acceleration and combo enabler for Commander decks that focus on playing large creatures. Her ability allows you to tap her to add mana equal to the greatest power among creatures you control. This can lead to explosive mana generation, enabling you to cast multiple spells or activate powerful abilities on the same turn. She is particularly potent in decks that can consistently deploy creatures with high power, such as those with Eldrazi, large beasts, or creatures that gain power throughout the game. The foil version makes it an attractive pickup for those who appreciate the premium finish.

Buy Selvala, Heart of the Wilds [Foil] on TCGPlayer Buy Selvala, Heart of the Wilds [Foil] on eBay

10. Akroma’s Will (165)

The non-foil version of Akroma’s Will, priced at $16.28, offers the same devastating combat-enhancing effects as its foil counterpart at a more budget-friendly price. This instant-speed spell can single-handedly win games by granting creatures +6/+6, flying, vigilance, and indestructible, with an additional layer of protection from all colors if you control a white creature. Its ability to close out games or protect your board from removal makes it one of the most impactful cards in the Commander format. For players looking for a powerful, game-winning spell without the premium price tag of the foil, the regular Akroma’s Will is an exceptional choice, providing immense value and strategic depth.

Buy Akroma’s Will on TCGPlayer Buy Akroma’s Will on eBay

How Far Does $100 Stretch?

If you’re looking to maximize your acquisition of Modern Horizons 3 Commander cards within a $100 budget, you can assemble a formidable collection of synergistic pieces. By focusing on the most impactful cards under the $25 ceiling, you can acquire a significant number of powerful staples.

Starting with Akroma’s Will at $16.28, you have a premier game-ender. Adding Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth for $17.46 provides essential mana fixing and utility for Green-based decks. The Reaver Cleaver at $24.94 is a high-value artifact synergy piece that can generate explosive turns. Lazotep Quarry [Foil] at $22.89 offers valuable early-game mana consistency for Blue/Black decks. Finally, to round out a diverse collection, Goldspan Dragon [Foil] at $17.24 brings a potent threat and treasure generation.

This selection of five cards comes to a total of $96.85. With the remaining $3.15, you could look to pick up additional utility lands or other synergistic pieces that complement these core cards, effectively building a strong foundation for multiple Commander decks. The selected cards offer immediate impact across different archetypes, demonstrating the depth of value available in Modern Horizons 3 even at lower price points.

What to SKIP at This Price Point

While Modern Horizons 3 offers many budget-friendly gems, some cards might appear attractive but represent poor value propositions within the $25 tier. It’s crucial to discern cards that offer genuine impact from those that are merely overhyped or have limited applications.

For instance, cards with niche abilities that only fit into a very specific, rarely played commander archetype might seem like a bargain. If a card’s primary function is to enable a combo that requires several other specific pieces, or if its power level is heavily dependent on conditions that are difficult to meet consistently in a multiplayer format, it’s often best to pass, even at a low price. The key is to prioritize cards that offer broad utility, synergistic power, or immediate board presence across a wider range of Commander decks. Cards like The Reaver Cleaver at $24.94 are high-value because they slot into many strategies, while cards with very narrow applications, even if under $25, might leave you with a card that sees minimal play. Always consider the overall impact and versatility before committing to a purchase, especially when building a collection.

Pro Tip: When considering foil versions of these budget picks, evaluate if the price premium justifies the aesthetic upgrade. For example, Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth [Foil] at $20.08 is nearly $3 more than its non-foil counterpart ($17.46). If your primary goal is to improve deck performance, the non-foil version offers nearly identical gameplay utility at a lower cost. However, if you are a collector who prioritizes the visual appeal and long-term potential for foil appreciation, the extra investment might be worthwhile. Always weigh the cost against the benefit for your specific needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth worth buying in its non-foil version?

Yes, the non-foil Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth at $17.46 is an excellent buy for Commander players. It provides the essential land-typing ability for Green-based strategies, enabling mana ramp and spell casting consistency. While the foil version at $20.08 offers aesthetic appeal, the gameplay impact remains identical, making the non-foil version a highly cost-effective choice for enhancing deck performance without overspending.

Are foils of these Modern Horizons 3 Commander cards a good investment?

For cards priced under $25, foil versions can be a worthwhile investment if you are a collector or anticipate future price appreciation. For example, Lazotep Quarry [Foil] at $22.89 offers a premium finish. However, if your primary goal is to improve deck functionality, the non-foil versions are often more cost-effective and provide the same gameplay benefits. Always compare the price difference and consider your collection goals.

Which of these cards has the most potential for gameplay impact in Commander?

Akroma’s Will, in both its foil ($18.88) and non-foil ($16.28) versions, offers the most immediate and explosive gameplay impact. Its ability to grant a massive power and toughness boost along with critical keywords like flying and indestructible can instantly close out games. The Reaver Cleaver at $24.94 is also incredibly impactful in artifact and sacrifice-themed decks, generating significant card advantage and treasure tokens.

How do these prices compare to other recent Commander sets?

The prices for these Modern Horizons 3 Commander cards are competitive within the current market for premium Commander staples. Cards like Yavimaya, Cradle of Growth and Akroma’s Will are powerful enough to see play in competitive Commander environments, and their accessibility under $25 makes them fantastic budget options compared to similarly powerful cards from other recent sets that might command higher prices.

For more insights into building powerful and cost-effective Commander decks, explore our guides on the Best Foundations Jumpstart MTG Cards Under $25 (2026 Budget Guide) and delve into the nuances of grading with our analysis on Badgermole Cub #167 MTG Avatar the Last Airbender: Should You Grade It? PSA 10 ROI 2026. Discover how to maximize your collection’s value and make informed decisions for your Magic: The Gathering investments.

Data: PriceCharting · eBay sold listings. Analysis: What The Slab. How we get our numbers.

Price data, not financial advice. Past sales don't predict future value. We may earn a commission on eBay, TCGplayer and Amazon links.