×

Best Modern Horizons 3 MTG Cards Under $25 (2026 Budget Guide)

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Ten Modern Horizons 3 MTG cards are readily available for under $25 each, with several showing potential for future value appreciation based on their current market position. Collectors looking to invest strategically in this set without breaking the bank can target cards like Phyrexian Tower at $24.45 or Glaring Fleshraker for $24.49, both offering unique utility or artistic appeal that can drive demand.

Your LCS has a case full of Modern Horizons 3 cards. The question isn’t what to buy — it’s which one survives the next market correction. For $25 or less, you can still pick up 10 legitimate Modern Horizons 3 cards, and a few of them are set up to move once the chase cards price out. Last updated: May 2026.

In This Article

• The Under-$25 Picks

• How Far Does $100 Stretch?

• What to SKIP at This Price Point

• Pro Tip: Navigating Foil Finish Demand

• Frequently Asked Questions

The Under-$25 Picks

Data sources: Prices cited above reflect eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices. All figures as of May 2026.

1. Glaring Fleshraker (507)

Glaring Fleshraker checks in at $24.49 raw, placing it right at the upper edge of our budget but offering significant bang for your buck. This creature isn’t just about brute force; its ability to disrupt opponents by forcing discards or dealing direct damage makes it a potent threat in aggressive strategies. For players who enjoy high-impact creatures that can swing games, Glaring Fleshraker is a prime target. Its menacing artwork also appeals to collectors looking for visually striking cards. If you’re building a new aggressive deck or looking to add some serious teeth to an existing one, this card is a strong contender. It’s also a good pickup for collectors who appreciate unique creature designs and mechanics.

Buy Glaring Fleshraker on eBay Buy Glaring Fleshraker on TCGPlayer

2. Phyrexian Tower (303)

At $24.45, Phyrexian Tower is a land that commands respect and offers immense strategic depth. This isn’t just a land that taps for mana; it provides a potent sacrifice ability that can protect your creatures from removal or enable powerful combo plays. Its consistent presence in Commander and other eternal formats makes it a perennial favorite, ensuring its demand remains high. For collectors, Phyrexian Tower represents a piece of Magic’s iconic land cycle, offering both utility and historical significance. It’s an essential include for anyone serious about building a robust Commander collection or optimizing mana bases for competitive play. This card’s enduring power makes it a safe bet for long-term value.

Buy Phyrexian Tower on eBay Buy Phyrexian Tower on TCGPlayer

3. Phlage, Titan of Fire’s Fury (493)

Phlage, Titan of Fire’s Fury is priced at $24.42, presenting a formidable presence on the battlefield. This card is designed to be a game-ender, boasting high power and toughness along with an ability that can clear the board or deal significant damage. Its sheer size and impactful mechanics make it a compelling choice for players looking for a centerpiece for their decks, particularly in Commander where big creatures often shine. Collectors drawn to the epic scale and mythic feel of Magic’s titans will find Phlage to be an attractive addition. Its raw power and visually striking design are hard to ignore, making it a standout budget pick for anyone who appreciates a creature that can single-handedly dominate a match.

Buy Phlage, Titan of Fire’s Fury on eBay Buy Phlage, Titan of Fire’s Fury on TCGPlayer

4. Pearl Medallion [Borderless Foil] (347)

Coming in at $24.42, the Borderless Foil Pearl Medallion is a beautifully rendered artifact that offers both aesthetic appeal and significant utility. Medallions are staples in many Commander decks, reducing the cost of spells of a specific color. The borderless foil treatment takes this already popular card and elevates it into a premium collectible. For players, it means a more consistent mana curve and faster game plan. For collectors, it’s a gorgeous piece of art that complements any high-end collection. This is a card for players who want to optimize their mana while showcasing their style, and for collectors who appreciate the finer, more visually striking versions of iconic cards.

Buy Pearl Medallion [Borderless Foil] on eBay Buy Pearl Medallion [Borderless Foil] on TCGPlayer

5. Windswept Heath (440)

Windswept Heath sits at $24.19, representing a crucial piece for any mana-hungry deck. As a fetch land, its ability to search for any basic land type is invaluable for mana consistency and thinning your deck. This makes it a cornerstone of competitive play, especially in formats where precise mana curves are critical. Beyond its playability, the artistic rendition of the Windswept Heath can be a draw for collectors who appreciate the evocative landscape art found in Magic’s premier sets. For players aiming for optimal mana bases or collectors seeking essential dual land components, Windswept Heath remains a top-tier budget pick. Its long-term value is practically guaranteed by its fundamental role in deck building.

Buy Windswept Heath on eBay Buy Windswept Heath on TCGPlayer

6. Urza’s Incubator [Foil] (297)

At $23.49, the Foil Urza’s Incubator is a powerhouse for tribal strategies. This artifact’s ability to reduce the mana cost of all creatures of a chosen type can lead to explosive turns and overwhelming board states. For players dedicated to a specific tribe, like Goblins, Elves, or Dragons, this card is an absolute must-have. The foil treatment adds a layer of visual flair that enhances its desirability, making it a sought-after item for both players and foil collectors. If you’re building a tribal Commander deck or simply want to add a potent engine to your collection, the Urza’s Incubator is an excellent choice that offers significant gameplay impact and collectible appeal.

Buy Urza’s Incubator [Foil] on eBay Buy Urza’s Incubator [Foil] on TCGPlayer

7. Warren Soultrader [Borderless] (332)

Warren Soultrader, in its borderless form, is available for $23.44 and offers a unique engine for life-gain and card-advantage strategies. This creature rewards players for having creatures hit the graveyard, making it a fantastic synergistic piece in Commander decks that focus on creature attrition or sacrifice. The borderless art presents a striking visual that stands out on the battlefield and in a collection. For players looking to maximize value from creatures that might otherwise be considered expendable, Warren Soultrader is an inspired pick. Its specific synergy means it won’t fit every deck, but for the right strategy, it’s an invaluable and affordable addition.

Buy Warren Soultrader [Borderless] on eBay Buy Warren Soultrader [Borderless] on TCGPlayer

8. Bloodstained Mire [Borderless Foil] (352)

Priced at $22.90, the Borderless Foil Bloodstained Mire represents a premium fetch land that combines essential playability with high collectibility. Fetch lands are fundamental for mana fixing and deck optimization in competitive Magic, making Bloodstained Mire a consistently in-demand card. The borderless foil treatment, however, elevates it beyond mere utility. It’s a visually stunning card that appeals to those who appreciate the best-looking versions of powerful staples. For collectors focusing on premium foils or players aiming for the most aesthetically pleasing mana bases, this version of Bloodstained Mire is a fantastic acquisition within our budget.

Buy Bloodstained Mire [Borderless Foil] on eBay Buy Bloodstained Mire [Borderless Foil] on TCGPlayer

9. Sapphire Medallion [Borderless Foil] (349)

The Borderless Foil Sapphire Medallion, available for $22.61, is another excellent artifact for cost reduction, specifically for blue spells. Like its Pearl Medallion counterpart, it offers substantial utility in Commander and other formats where casting spells efficiently is key. The borderless foil treatment makes this card not only a powerful strategic tool but also a beautiful addition to any collection. Players looking to accelerate their blue-based strategies will find immense value here, while collectors will appreciate its eye-catching design and premium finish. This card is a testament to how powerful and aesthetically pleasing staples can still be found within a budget.

Buy Sapphire Medallion [Borderless Foil] on eBay Buy Sapphire Medallion [Borderless Foil] on TCGPlayer

10. Bloodstained Mire (435)

At $22.40, the regular Bloodstained Mire is the most budget-friendly fetch land on our list, offering unparalleled value for its price. This card’s primary function is to search for a Swamp or an Island, providing crucial mana fixing for a vast array of decks. Its consistent demand across nearly all Magic formats ensures its long-term value and playability. For new players looking to improve their mana bases without a significant investment, or for established players seeking to fill out playsets, the standard Bloodstained Mire is an indispensable pickup. It’s the foundational piece of optimal mana bases and a smart, reliable investment at this price point.

Buy Bloodstained Mire on eBay Buy Bloodstained Mire on TCGPlayer

How Far Does $100 Stretch?

With a $100 budget, you can start building a substantial foundation of Modern Horizons 3 cards that offer both immediate playability and long-term value. By strategically combining some of the top budget picks, you can acquire a diverse set of powerful cards.

Here’s a potential $100 shopping list, focusing on essential utility and potential upside:

1. Phyrexian Tower ($24.45): A foundational land for many Commander decks.
2. Windswept Heath ($24.19): Essential fetch land for mana consistency.
3. Bloodstained Mire ($22.40): Another critical fetch land.
4. Urza’s Incubator [Foil] ($23.49): A potent tribal engine with a desirable foil finish.

Total Cost: $24.45 + $24.19 + $22.40 + $23.49 = $94.53

This combination allows you to acquire four high-impact cards. You get two essential fetch lands for superior mana bases, a powerful utility land in Phyrexian Tower, and a game-warping foil artifact in Urza’s Incubator. This bundle provides a strong starting point for optimizing Commander decks or building a valuable collection of Modern Horizons 3 staples without exceeding the $100 mark. The remaining $5.47 could even go towards a fifth, smaller pickup or towards saving for another desired card.

What to SKIP at This Price Point

While many cards in Modern Horizons 3 offer great value under $25, some can be deceptive. For instance, cards that appear to have competitive viability but lack broader appeal for Commander or casual play might stagnate. The key is to look for cards with intrinsic value – whether through art, a unique effect, or a highly sought-after finish.

Consider cards that are highly niche without a clear pathway to wider adoption. If a card requires an extremely specific board state or a convoluted combo to function, its demand will likely remain low even if it sees play in a handful of top-tier competitive decks. Without the broader appeal for set completionists, Commander enthusiasts, or casual players, such cards are less likely to appreciate in value. Focus on staples, highly playable commons/uncommons, and unique mythics with strong artistic merit. Always cross-reference with price trends and population reports where available, though for budget cards, focusing on utility and art is often the safest bet.

Pro Tip: When evaluating borderless foil versions of fetch lands or medallions, pay close attention to the centering and edge wear. While the base price is under $25, minor imperfections can significantly impact perceived value and potential resale appeal. Aim for cards with strong centering to maximize your investment, especially if you plan to eventually grade them.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many cards are in the Modern Horizons 3 set?

The Modern Horizons 3 set features a substantial checklist designed to offer a wealth of playable and collectible cards. While the exact total count can fluctuate with different printings and special versions, the core set is comprehensive, providing ample opportunities for collectors to engage with its diverse offerings.

Are the borderless foil versions of these cards worth the premium over regular versions?

For cards like fetch lands and medallions, the borderless foil versions offer a significant aesthetic upgrade and enhanced collectibility. While they command a higher price than their non-foil counterparts, their market prices ($22.40 for regular Bloodstained Mire vs. $22.90 for borderless foil) suggest that the premium is often justified by the visual appeal and desirability for collectors, especially when staying within the $25 budget.

What makes Phyrexian Tower a good long-term investment?

Phyrexian Tower is a timeless piece of Magic utility. Its ability to generate mana and provide a crucial sacrifice outlet ensures its relevance in Commander and other eternal formats, regardless of the current metagame. This consistent demand, combined with its iconic status among lands, makes it a reliable card for long-term value retention and appreciation.

Should new collectors focus on specific rarities within the under-$25 price range?

New collectors can confidently target cards across various rarities within this price range. While mythics like Phlage, Titan of Fire’s Fury ($24.42) offer splashy gameplay, essential rares like Windswept Heath ($24.19) and Bloodstained Mire ($22.40) provide fundamental utility that holds value. The borderless foil versions of artifacts, such as Pearl Medallion ($24.42) and Sapphire Medallion ($22.61), are also excellent targets for their blend of playability and eye-catching design.

How does the release of new sets impact the prices of cards like these?

The release of new sets, especially those with high demand like Modern Horizons 3, can initially drive up prices for chase cards. However, budget-friendly staples like fetch lands and utility artifacts tend to stabilize or even see slight dips as the initial hype subsides, making cards like Phyrexian Tower ($24.45) or Bloodstained Mire ($22.40) excellent targets for acquisition after the initial release frenzy.

Modern Horizons 3 continues to be a treasure trove for collectors looking to build a strong Magic: The Gathering collection without breaking the bank. The verified sold data shows that numerous powerful and aesthetically pleasing cards are available for under $25, offering both immediate gameplay benefits and solid long-term investment potential. Whether you’re focused on optimizing your Commander decks, snagging premium foil treatments, or simply acquiring essential staples, this set delivers. For further insights into navigating the TCG market and discovering more value-driven opportunities, explore our comprehensive guides at the /tcg-collectibles/ hub.