×

Image sourced from eBay listings

Best Bloomburrow Commander MTG Cards Under $25 (2026 Budget Guide)

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Bloomburrow Commander MTG cards under $25 offer surprising value and playability for budget-conscious builders in 2026, with top picks like Marrow-Gnawer [Borderless Foil] at $24.30 and Luminous Broodmoth [Borderless Foil] at $20.30 providing powerful abilities and desirable aesthetics without breaking the bank. Savvy collectors can assemble a potent Commander deck or enhance their collection by strategically targeting these affordable gems, leveraging market data to identify cards with both immediate impact and potential for future growth.

Across the top 10 Bloomburrow Commander MTG cards, the average PSA 10 premium over raw is not applicable as no PSA 10 data was provided. That gap is where grading ROI lives. For $25 or less, collectors can still acquire 10 legitimate Bloomburrow Commander cards, with several positioned to appreciate as the more expensive chase cards eventually see their prices climb. Last updated: June 2026.

In This Article

• The Under-$25 Picks: A Ranked Breakdown

• Deep Dive: Your Top Budget Bloomburrow Commander Card Picks

• How Far Does $100 Stretch? Building a Budget Bloomburrow Commander Deck

• What to Skip at This Price Point: Avoiding Common Pitfalls

• Pro Tip: Maximizing Your Bloomburrow Commander Budget

• Frequently Asked Questions

The Under-$25 Picks: A Ranked Breakdown

Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices. All figures as of June 2026.

Deep Dive: Your Top Budget Bloomburrow Commander Card Picks

Here’s a closer look at why these affordable Bloomburrow Commander cards are worth your attention in 2026.

1. Marrow-Gnawer [Borderless Foil] (79)

At $24.30, Marrow-Gnawer in its borderless foil treatment is the most expensive card on this list, but its impact on a Commander game plan is undeniable. This card is the undisputed king of Rat tribal and a phenomenal engine for Aristocrats or sacrifice-based strategies. Its ability to turn any creature into a Rat token, and then buff them all, creates explosive turns and swarms of blockers or attackers. For collectors, the borderless foil offers a premium look that elevates its desirability. Given its unique niche and powerful effect, Marrow-Gnawer is a prime candidate for anyone looking to build a strong, thematic Commander deck. It’s a must-have for dedicated tribal players and a solid pickup for anyone seeking a high-impact commander that won’t drain their wallet. Consider this the centerpiece of any budget Rat Commander deck.

Buy Marrow-Gnawer on eBay Buy Marrow-Gnawer on TCGPlayer

2. Luminous Broodmoth [Borderless Foil] (74)

This $20.30 borderless foil version of Luminous Broodmoth is a true powerhouse for graveyard-centric strategies. Its ability to grant flying to any creature that dies, and then return it with a +1/+1 counter, is a game-changing recursion engine. It synergizes incredibly well with creatures that have enter-the-battlefield or leave-the-battlefield effects, turning your creatures into repeatable value engines. The borderless foil treatment adds significant aesthetic appeal, making it a sought-after piece for collectors who appreciate both art and function. Luminous Broodmoth is an auto-include in many Commander decks that want to benefit from creatures hitting the graveyard and returning to the battlefield. Its raw power level and the visual appeal of the foil make this a top-tier budget pick for players aiming to disrupt opponents and build a resilient board state.

Buy Luminous Broodmoth on TCGPlayer Buy Luminous Broodmoth on eBay

3. The Gitrog Monster [Borderless Foil] (88)

Clocking in at $16.99, the borderless foil version of The Gitrog Monster is a fantastic pick for land-based Commander strategies. This iconic creature thrives on sacrificing lands and drawing cards, creating a powerful engine that can quickly out-tempo opponents. Its ability to provide card advantage and grow in power by leveraging lands makes it a central piece for decks focused on land recursion, landfall triggers, or simply maximizing land drops. The borderless foil treatment adds a premium feel, enhancing its appeal for collectors who appreciate unique art treatments. For players looking to build around a land-heavy Commander, The Gitrog Monster is an excellent centerpiece that offers both strategic depth and a visually striking presentation. Its raw power and synergy potential make it a standout budget choice for land-focused enthusiasts.

Buy The Gitrog Monster on eBay Buy The Gitrog Monster on TCGPlayer

4. Luminous Broodmoth (74)

The non-foil version of Luminous Broodmoth, priced at $15.94, offers almost all the power of its foil counterpart at a more accessible price point. This card is a linchpin for any Commander deck that wants to exploit creature death and recursion. The flying granting ability combined with the +1/+1 counter and reanimation effect is potent, especially when paired with creatures that have death triggers or enter-the-battlefield effects. It provides immense value and resilience, making your creatures incredibly difficult to remove permanently. For players focused on gameplay over aesthetics, or those building multiple decks that benefit from this effect, this version is a superb choice. It’s a widely recognized staple that significantly boosts the survivability and value of your creature board.

Buy Luminous Broodmoth on TCGPlayer Buy Luminous Broodmoth on eBay

5. Derevi, Empyrial Tactician [Borderless Foil] (87)

At $14.99, Derevi, Empyrial Tactician in its borderless foil iteration represents a strong pickup for players interested in multi-color Commander strategies that leverage untapping permanents. Derevi is incredibly versatile, capable of functioning as a commander that can generate mana, tap down opposing permanents, or untap your own for repeated value. The ability to trigger off combat damage makes her a threat that demands an answer. The borderless foil treatment provides a premium look for a card that is a commander staple in many circles. For collectors and players alike, this version offers a fantastic balance of iconic status and budget-friendly acquisition. Its ability to enable persistent advantage makes it a prime candidate for those seeking a Commander that can consistently impact the game.

Buy Derevi, Empyrial Tactician on eBay Buy Derevi, Empyrial Tactician on TCGPlayer

6. Teferi, Time Raveler (92)

Teferi, Time Raveler, available for $13.48, is a control player’s dream and a powerful addition to any Commander deck that wants to lock down opponents or protect its own plays. Its ability to stop opponents from casting spells during your turn and to allow you to cast instants at sorcery speed is fundamentally disruptive. This card warps the tempo of games, forcing opponents to play on your terms. While not a foil or borderless variant, its raw playability and meta-defining impact make it an essential pick for anyone serious about competitive or optimized Commander play. The price point makes this potent planeswalker surprisingly accessible for a card that has seen significant play in competitive formats. It’s a strategic powerhouse for controlling the game.

Buy Teferi, Time Raveler on TCGPlayer Buy Teferi, Time Raveler on eBay

7. Ink-Eyes, Servant of Oni (77)

This classic Ninja tribal payoff, Ink-Eyes, Servant of Oni, comes in at $12.81. It’s a creature that brings a significant threat and utility to the board when it successfully deals combat damage to a player. Its ability to look at the top of your library and put a Ninja card directly into play can create explosive turns, especially in Commander where you can cheat out powerful, high-cost creatures. For collectors, Ink-Eyes has a unique aesthetic and a long history in Magic, making it a sought-after card for those who appreciate its flavor and iconic status. This price point makes it an excellent budget choice for anyone looking to build a Ninja-themed Commander deck or incorporate a powerful top-end threat into a Dimir (Blue-Black) strategy.

Buy Ink-Eyes, Servant of Oni on eBay Buy Ink-Eyes, Servant of Oni on TCGPlayer

8. Baleful Strix (86)

Priced at $12.32, Baleful Strix is a remarkably efficient creature that consistently provides value. Upon entering the battlefield, it replaces itself with a card draw, and as a 1/1 flyer with deathtouch, it can effectively trade with or deter many early-game threats. This makes it a staple in any Commander deck that plays Dimir (Blue-Black) colors and wants to maintain card advantage and board presence. Its low mana cost and immediate value ensure it’s always a good play, whether you’re looking to develop your board or cycle through your deck. For budget players, Baleful Strix is an essential card that punches well above its weight class, offering consistent, reliable performance at a great price.

Buy Baleful Strix on TCGPlayer Buy Baleful Strix on eBay

9. Karn, The Great Creator [Borderless Foil] (73)

At $11.76, Karn, The Great Creator in its borderless foil form offers significant utility and a desirable aesthetic. Karn’s ability to shut down opponents’ artifact abilities and allow you to retrieve any artifact card from your graveyard or sideboard into your hand makes him incredibly versatile, especially in artifact-heavy metas or dedicated artifact decks. The borderless foil version adds a premium visual appeal that many collectors seek. This price point makes a powerful planeswalker with broad applications surprisingly accessible. For players looking to build around artifacts, control the artifact-heavy game, or simply add a potent planeswalker to their collection without a hefty investment, Karn presents a compelling option.

Buy Karn, The Great Creator on eBay Buy Karn, The Great Creator on TCGPlayer

10. Derevi, Empyrial Tactician (87)

The regular version of Derevi, Empyrial Tactician, at $11.23, offers the same game-warping abilities as its borderless foil counterpart but at a more budget-friendly entry price. Derevi is a commander that can fuel numerous powerful synergies, particularly those involving untapping permanents. Her ability to generate mana, tap down opponents’ creatures or lands, or untap your own utility permanents makes her a flexible and potent choice for Commander decks. This version is perfect for players who prioritize functionality and strategic depth over the premium aesthetics of foil treatments. If you want to build an Animar-style deck, a stax strategy, or anything that benefits from repeatable untap effects, Derevi is an outstanding commander at this price.

Buy Derevi, Empyrial Tactician on TCGPlayer Buy Derevi, Empyrial Tactician on eBay

How Far Does $100 Stretch?

With a budget of $100, you can assemble a formidable Commander core or significantly enhance several decks. Based on the current market prices, you could realistically acquire around 4-5 of the top-tier cards listed here. For instance, a potential $100 build might look like this:

1. Marrow-Gnawer [Borderless Foil] ($24.30): The ultimate Rat commander.
2. Luminous Broodmoth [Borderless Foil] ($20.30): A top-tier recursion engine.
3. The Gitrog Monster [Borderless Foil] ($16.99): A powerhouse for land-based strategies.
4. Teferi, Time Raveler ($13.48): Essential control piece.
5. Baleful Strix ($12.32): Efficient card draw and board presence.

This combination alone would cost $87.49, leaving you with nearly $12.50 for additional utility pieces or to upgrade a card to a different printing if desired. This illustrates how accessible high-impact cards are within the Bloomburrow Commander set for collectors on a budget. You’re not just buying single cards; you’re investing in strategic engines and centerpiece commanders that can define your gameplay experience. This approach allows for a high-quality, budget-conscious collection without compromising on power or collectibility.

What to Skip at This Price Point: Avoiding Common Pitfalls

While many cards in the Bloomburrow Commander set are priced reasonably, some might appear as bargains but offer less return on investment within this $25 budget tier. It’s crucial to identify which cards might be over-hyped or have limited upside at these specific price points. For instance, cards that lack unique art treatments (like borderless or foil), or those that are widely available with high print runs and no distinct scarcity, might be tempting but offer less long-term value.

Consider a card that might be priced around $10 but has seen a significant surge in playability across multiple formats, leading to a flood of available copies. If the data shows a very low multiplier for PSA 10 grades (e.g., a $10 raw card only jumps to $12-$15 in PSA 10), then the grading ROI is minimal, and the card might already be fully priced into its perceived value. These cards, while playable, may not offer the same collection growth potential or immediate impact as those with unique art, special treatments, or a more defined role in the commander meta. Always cross-reference price with desirability for both gameplay and collecting.

Pro Tip: Maximizing Your Bloomburrow Commander Budget

Pro Tip: When hunting for budget gems, pay close attention to the interplay between borderless treatments and Commander staple status. Cards like Marrow-Gnawer and The Gitrog Monster at their borderless foil prices represent excellent value because they combine high-demand Commander roles with premium art that appeals to collectors. If you’re able to find these in non-foil or regular art variants for even less, it’s a bonus, but the borderless versions offer a tangible upside both aesthetically and potentially in long-term collectibility if scarcity tightens. Prioritize cards that are both powerful in-game and visually appealing to maximize your investment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Bloomburrow Commander worth collecting on a budget in 2026?

Yes, Bloomburrow Commander offers excellent value for budget collectors in 2026. Cards like Marrow-Gnawer [Borderless Foil] at $24.30 and Luminous Broodmoth at $15.94 provide significant gameplay impact and desirable aesthetics without exceeding the $25 limit. This accessibility allows for building powerful Commander decks or acquiring valuable additions to one’s collection.

Which Bloomburrow Commander cards offer the best ROI for grading under $25?

While no PSA 10 data was provided, cards with significant commander playability and premium treatments like borderless foils (e.g., Marrow-Gnawer at $24.30, Luminous Broodmoth [Borderless Foil] at $20.30) generally have better potential for grading ROI. The appeal of special art and strong mechanics can drive demand for higher-graded copies.

How can I build a strong Commander deck with only $100 from Bloomburrow Commander cards?

With a $100 budget, you can acquire approximately 4-5 of the top cards listed, such as Marrow-Gnawer ($24.30), Luminous Broodmoth [Borderless Foil] ($20.30), The Gitrog Monster [Borderless Foil] ($16.99), Teferi, Time Raveler ($13.48), and Baleful Strix ($12.32). This combination provides a potent commander and several powerful utility pieces.

Are non-foil versions of cards like Luminous Broodmoth still good budget picks?

Absolutely. The regular version of Luminous Broodmoth at $15.94 offers nearly the same gameplay impact as its foil counterpart at a lower cost. For players prioritizing functionality and deck building, these non-foil versions are superb value, providing a crucial graveyard recursion engine for any Commander strategy.

Should I focus on borderless foils or regular versions for Bloomburrow Commander on a budget?

It depends on your priorities. Borderless foils like Marrow-Gnawer ($24.30) offer enhanced aesthetics and potential collectibility, making them great for both play and investment. Regular versions, like Derevi, Empyrial Tactician ($11.23), provide the same powerful abilities at a lower price, making them ideal for players solely focused on in-game performance and maximizing card count.

The Bloomburrow Commander set presents a fantastic opportunity for collectors and players to acquire impactful cards without a substantial financial outlay. By focusing on the data-driven picks highlighted in this guide, you can build a powerful Commander presence, enhance your collection, or simply enjoy the strategic depth these cards bring to the game, all while staying well within a $25 budget per card.

To explore more budget-friendly options and investment strategies in the TCG space, dive into our comprehensive TCG Collectibles hub.