×

Image sourced from eBay listings

Best Duskmourn House of Horror MTG Cards Under $25 (2026 Budget Guide)

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The best budget picks from Duskmourn House of Horror under $25 offer a surprising amount of value, with cards like the Overlord of the Balemurk available for under $25 and showing strong collector interest. Focusing on these accessible yet impactful cards allows collectors to build a meaningful collection from the set without breaking the bank.

Everyone’s hyping the top card in Duskmourn House of Horror. The smarter play is the one ranked #4 on this list.

For $25 or less, you can still pick up 10 legitimate Duskmourn House of Horror cards—and a few of them are set up to move once the chase cards price out. Last updated: October 2026. While the most sought-after cards from the set might command higher prices, a deep dive into verified eBay sold comps and PriceCharting data reveals that significant value and collecting potential still exist within the under-$25 tier. This guide highlights the savvy picks that offer art, playability, or speculative upside, ensuring that even budget-conscious collectors can secure compelling additions to their MTG collections.

In This Article

• The Under-$25 Picks: A Ranked Table

• Deep Dive into the Top Picks

• 1. Overlord of the Balemurk (377)
• 1. Overlord of the Balemurk [Foil] (113)
• 1. Kaito, Bane Of Nightmares [Borderless Foil] (354)
• 1. Valgavoth, Terror Eater [Foil] (120)
• 1. Enduring Vitality (381)
• 1. Overlord of the Balemurk (113)
• 1. Abhorrent Oculus [Borderless Foil] (344)
• 1. Valgavoth, Terror Eater (352)
• 1. Kaito, Bane of Nightmares (328)
• 1. Enduring Vitality [Foil] (176)

• How Far Does $100 Stretch in Duskmourn House of Horror?

• What to Skip at This Price Point

• Frequently Asked Questions

The Under-$25 Picks

| # | Card | Market | PSA 10 | Multiplier | Why It’s Worth It

• Card Name

• Market

• PSA 1B (Raw)

• PSA 10 Median

• Multiplier

• Why It’s Worth It

• Overlord of the Balemurk

• $24.35

• —

• 2.4x

• A formidable creature with a potent ability that can dictate the tempo of the game, making it a desirable centerpiece for certain strategies. Its imposing presence and the raw power it offers at this price point make it a strong value proposition for players looking to add a impactful creature to their decks without spending top dollar. The visual appeal of the artwork also contributes to its collectibility, especially for those drawn to darker, more monstrous designs.

• Overlord of the Balemurk [Foil]

• $21.79

• —

• 3.0x

• The foiled version of the Overlord of the Balemurk offers an enhanced aesthetic appeal, making it a more attractive pickup for collectors who appreciate the shimmer and shine of premium printings. While the raw price is slightly higher than its non-foil counterpart, the increased rarity and visual flair can justify the small premium for those seeking to add a touch of sparkle to their collection or to a creature-based strategy. The foil treatment can often command a higher resale value over time, especially if the card sees significant play or becomes a sought-after piece for its art.

• Kaito, Bane Of Nightmares [Borderless Foil]

• $21.35

• —

• N/A

• This unique printing of Kaito, Bane of Nightmares features a borderless design, enhancing the card’s artwork and presenting it in a more visually striking format. The foil treatment further elevates its premium feel. For collectors who prioritize aesthetics and unique printings, this card offers a compelling option. Its potential playability in various formats, combined with its distinctive art and foil finish, makes it a solid candidate for a budget pick that can also serve as a display piece.

• Valgavoth, Terror Eater [Foil]

• $20.73

• —

• N/A

• The foiled iteration of Valgavoth, Terror Eater, provides an immediate upgrade in visual appeal, making it a standout card for collectors. The creature’s aggressive stats and potential to disrupt opponent strategies can also translate to table presence. For those building a collection centered around strong creatures with exciting artwork, this foil version offers a significant aesthetic and potential power boost for a modest investment. The foil effect on a creature designed to evoke terror makes for a particularly striking combination.

• Enduring Vitality

• $20.50

• —

• N/A

• Enduring Vitality, priced at $20.50, represents a significant card for players seeking to enhance their creature-based strategies. Its ability to bolster creatures and provide lasting benefits can be a game-changer in various Magic formats. The raw power and utility it offers at this price point make it an attractive pickup for anyone looking to optimize their deck’s resilience and offensive capabilities. Collectors drawn to cards with mechanics that support sustained board presence will find this a valuable addition.

• Overlord of the Balemurk

• $20.29

• —

• 2.5x

• This version of the Overlord of the Balemurk offers an even more accessible entry point into acquiring this powerful creature. At $20.29, it remains a highly efficient pickup for players looking to leverage its abilities in their decks. The significant presence and impactful mechanics it brings to the table at this price make it a cornerstone for budget-friendly Commander or other constructed formats. Its relatively low market price compared to its potential power makes it an excellent target for smart collectors.

• Abhorrent Oculus [Borderless Foil]

• $19.99

• —

• N/A

• The borderless foil version of Abhorrent Oculus presents a visually stunning piece for collectors. Its unique art and foil treatment make it stand out, offering a premium feel without the highest price tag. For players and collectors who value striking artwork and special printings, this card is a prime candidate. Its aggressive stats and potential utility in certain game states further enhance its desirability, making it a well-rounded budget acquisition.

• Valgavoth, Terror Eater

• $19.92

• —

• N/A

• Valgavoth, Terror Eater, lands just under the $20 mark, presenting a formidable creature that can significantly impact games. Its raw power and aggressive design make it an appealing addition to any collection, particularly for those who enjoy playing creature-heavy strategies or appreciate cards with a menacing aesthetic. The solid stats and potential for board dominance at this price make it a smart buy for players looking to enhance their decks without overspending.

• Kaito, Bane of Nightmares

• $19.64

• —

• N/A

• Kaito, Bane of Nightmares, at $19.64, offers a compelling strategic option for players. As a character card, it holds inherent appeal for collectors who follow narrative elements within Magic: The Gathering. Its abilities likely support nuanced gameplay, making it a valuable asset for those who enjoy intricate deck building and tactical execution. The accessibility of this card at its current market price makes it an excellent opportunity to acquire a named character with potentially significant in-game impact.

• Enduring Vitality [Foil]

• $19.24

• —

• N/A

• The foiled version of Enduring Vitality provides an elevated aesthetic experience for collectors, making it a more visually appealing choice. Priced at $19.24, it offers a fantastic opportunity to acquire a premium version of a card that can provide substantial strategic advantages. The foil treatment enhances its collectible nature, making it an attractive pick for those who appreciate the added shimmer and potential long-term value that foils can sometimes command. This is a smart buy for players and collectors alike.

Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices. All figures as of October 2026.

1. Overlord of the Balemurk (377)

The Overlord of the Balemurk, card number 377 from Duskmourn House of Horror, currently holds a market price of $24.35. This creature is a significant threat on the board, capable of dictating the pace of the game with its impactful abilities. For collectors looking for a powerful creature to anchor their strategy without venturing into triple-digit territory, this card represents an excellent value. Its imposing artwork and mechanical prowess make it a desirable piece for anyone building a strong creature-focused collection. The sheer presence of the Overlord makes it a standout pick for those who value both in-game utility and a strong visual appeal. This card is a prime candidate for players who want to add a serious threat to their Commander decks or any format where big creatures shine.

Buy Overlord of the Balemurk on TCGPlayer Buy Overlord of the Balemurk on eBay

2. Overlord of the Balemurk [Foil] (113)

For those who prefer their threats to have a bit more glimmer, the foil version of the Overlord of the Balemurk (card #113) is available for $21.79. This price point makes the premium version of this potent creature surprisingly accessible. The foil treatment not only enhances the card’s visual appeal but also adds a layer of rarity that can be attractive to collectors. If you’re aiming to add a creature with both significant in-game impact and a flashy presentation, this foil Overlord is an ideal pick. It’s a strong choice for players looking to elevate their board presence with a creature that looks as menacing as it plays.

Buy Overlord of the Balemurk [Foil] on TCGPlayer Buy Overlord of the Balemurk [Foil] on eBay

3. Kaito, Bane Of Nightmares [Borderless Foil] (354)

Kaito, Bane of Nightmares, in its borderless foil printing (card #354), comes in at $21.35. This special version offers an expanded artistic canvas and a premium foil finish, making it a highly desirable card for collectors who appreciate unique and aesthetically striking printings. The borderless nature allows the incredible artwork to dominate the card, while the foil adds that extra layer of premium appeal. For anyone looking to acquire a character card with a distinctive look, this is an excellent opportunity. It’s a pick that appeals to both players who want a unique card and collectors who value art and special editions.

Buy Kaito, Bane Of Nightmares [Borderless Foil] on TCGPlayer Buy Kaito, Bane Of Nightmares [Borderless Foil] on eBay

4. Valgavoth, Terror Eater [Foil] (120)

The foiled Valgavoth, Terror Eater, card number 120, is priced at $20.73. This creature is designed to be a dominant force, and the foil treatment amplifies its intimidating presence. For collectors and players who enjoy aggressive strategies and visually impactful monsters, this card is a must-consider. The combination of its aggressive stats, potential to overwhelm opponents, and the eye-catching foil finish makes it a strong value pick. It’s a card that promises to be a conversation starter on the table and a valuable addition to a collection aiming for powerful, well-presented creatures.

Buy Valgavoth, Terror Eater [Foil] on TCGPlayer Buy Valgavoth, Terror Eater [Foil] on eBay

5. Enduring Vitality (381)

Enduring Vitality, identified as card #381, currently sits at a market price of $20.50. This card offers a significant boost to creature-based strategies, providing ongoing benefits that can be crucial for maintaining board control and pressuring opponents. For players looking to build a resilient and powerful board state, Enduring Vitality is a prime candidate. Its utility in bolstering creatures and potentially enabling longer games makes it a smart acquisition for budget-conscious players aiming to optimize their deck’s performance. The strong mechanical impact at this price makes it a compelling pickup for any serious player.

Buy Enduring Vitality on TCGPlayer Buy Enduring Vitality on eBay

6. Overlord of the Balemurk (113)

This particular listing for the Overlord of the Balemurk, card #113, is priced at $20.29. This offers an even more budget-friendly way to acquire this impactful creature compared to the #377 version. For collectors and players looking to get their hands on this powerful card without stretching their budget, this is an excellent opportunity. The Overlord of the Balemurk’s ability to dominate the board makes it a strategic asset, and securing it at this lower price point maximizes value. It’s a prime example of how discerning budget collectors can still acquire top-tier cards.

Buy Overlord of the Balemurk on TCGPlayer Buy Overlord of the Balemurk on eBay

7. Abhorrent Oculus [Borderless Foil] (344)

The Abhorrent Oculus in its borderless foil printing, card #344, is available for $19.99. This card represents a fantastic fusion of striking artwork and premium presentation, all while staying comfortably within our $25 budget. The borderless design ensures that the card’s unique art is fully showcased, and the foil finish adds a desirable premium quality. For collectors who prioritize visual flair and unique printings, this is an exceptional choice. Its potential utility on the battlefield further enhances its appeal, making it a well-rounded and accessible addition to any collection.

Buy Abhorrent Oculus [Borderless Foil] on TCGPlayer Buy Abhorrent Oculus [Borderless Foil] on eBay

8. Valgavoth, Terror Eater (352)

Valgavoth, Terror Eater, card #352, is priced at $19.92, making it another excellent budget-friendly option for those seeking a powerful creature. This card’s design is focused on delivering a significant impact on the game, with impressive stats and a menacing presence. For players who want to add a creature that can both intimidate opponents and perform strongly on the battlefield, Valgavoth is a solid choice. Its accessibility at this price point makes it a valuable pick for building a strong, thematic collection or enhancing existing decks without significant investment.

Buy Valgavoth, Terror Eater on TCGPlayer Buy Valgavoth, Terror Eater on eBay

9. Kaito, Bane of Nightmares (328)

Kaito, Bane of Nightmares, card #328, is available for $19.64. As a named character, Kaito possesses inherent collectibility, appealing to those who follow the lore and narrative of Magic: The Gathering. The mechanics associated with Kaito likely offer interesting strategic depth, making this card a valuable pickup for players who enjoy tactical gameplay. Acquiring a character card with potentially significant in-game applications at this accessible price point is a smart move for any collector or player looking to add unique pieces to their portfolio. This card balances narrative appeal with potential playability.

Buy Kaito, Bane of Nightmares on TCGPlayer Buy Kaito, Bane of Nightmares on eBay

10. Enduring Vitality [Foil] (176)

The foil version of Enduring Vitality, card #176, rounds out our list at $19.24. This offers collectors and players a premium version of a strategically important card at a highly attractive price. The foil treatment not only enhances the visual appeal but also increases its collectible factor. For those looking to invest in cards that offer both in-game utility and aesthetic value, this foiled Enduring Vitality is an exceptional choice. It provides a strong foundation for any collection aiming for impactful cards with a touch of added rarity and visual flair.

Buy Enduring Vitality [Foil] on TCGPlayer Buy Enduring Vitality [Foil] on eBay

How Far Does $100 Stretch in Duskmourn House of Horror?

With a $100 budget, savvy collectors can acquire a solid foundation of desirable cards from Duskmourn House of Horror, focusing on the most impactful and collectible pieces under the $25 ceiling. By strategically picking from our list, you can amass a significant collection.

Let’s consider a sample $100 bundle using the most compelling options:

1. Overlord of the Balemurk (377) at $24.35. This provides the highest-priced, yet arguably most impactful, creature.
2. Overlord of the Balemurk [Foil] (113) at $21.79. Adding the foil version of the Overlord gives a premium aesthetic and collector appeal.
3. Kaito, Bane Of Nightmares [Borderless Foil] (354) at $21.35. This unique printing offers strong visual appeal and character recognition.
4. Valgavoth, Terror Eater [Foil] (120) at $20.73. A high-impact creature with a striking foil treatment.

These four cards alone total $88.22, leaving $11.78 to potentially grab another desirable common or uncommon, or perhaps even snag another budget-friendly rare if prices dip slightly. This demonstrates that a $100 investment can secure a diverse range of high-value cards, from impactful creatures to visually stunning special printings, providing excellent collection depth from Duskmourn House of Horror. For collectors interested in building a diverse portfolio, this approach maximizes acquisition while adhering to a strict budget.

What to Skip at This Price Point

While the focus is on the best budget picks, it’s also prudent to identify potential pitfalls within the sub-$25 market. Generally, when examining cards at this price tier, we advise caution with any card where the raw price is only marginally lower than what a PSA 10 graded version might command, especially if the grading fee itself eats into the potential profit. For instance, if a card is $20 raw and a PSA 10 graded version is only $25-$30, and factoring in a $59.99 grading fee (standard service), the margin for profit or even recouping costs becomes negligible.

Another area to be wary of is cards that have a very low “multiplier” (the ratio between raw price and potential PSA 10 value) that is not reflected in the data provided. While our current list shows cards where the raw price is the primary driver, in other sets or for cards not listed, a low multiplier can signal that the market has already priced in the scarcity of high-grade copies, or that the card is too readily available in lower conditions. Always cross-reference potential investments with grading ROI calculators, understanding that for cards under $25, the primary driver for collection should be personal enjoyment, playability, or the unique aesthetic of special printings rather than aggressive grading speculation.

Pro Tip: Keep an eye on the Overlord of the Balemurk, card #113 (foil). Its current price of $21.79 represents a strong value for a creature that is both playable and visually striking. If demand for this card remains consistent, or if it sees increased play in competitive or casual settings, its price could see a steady climb. Buying into this card now, especially the foil version, could position you well for future value appreciation as the set continues to mature in the collector market.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Duskmourn House of Horror a good set for budget collectors in 2026?

Yes, Duskmourn House of Horror offers several compelling options for budget collectors in 2026. As demonstrated, cards like the Overlord of the Balemurk (raw $24.35) and Valgavoth, Terror Eater [Foil] (raw $20.73) provide significant value and collector appeal well under the $25 mark. These picks offer a mix of playability, striking artwork, and potential for future appreciation, making the set accessible for those on a tighter budget.

Which foil cards from Duskmourn House of Horror offer the best value under $25?

Several foil cards provide excellent value under $25. The Overlord of the Balemurk [Foil] at $21.79 and Valgavoth, Terror Eater [Foil] at $20.73 are strong contenders, offering impressive creature power with the added appeal of foil treatments. Additionally, Kaito, Bane Of Nightmares [Borderless Foil] ($21.35) and Abhorrent Oculus [Borderless Foil] ($19.99) are excellent choices for collectors prioritizing unique art and premium finishes.

How does the raw price of Overlord of the Balemurk compare to its foil version?

The raw version of Overlord of the Balemurk (card #377) is priced at $24.35, while the foil version (card #113) is available for $21.79, and another listing for the same card (#113) is at $20.29. This pricing dynamic indicates that sometimes the foil version can be found for less than or around the same price as a non-foil version of the same card, offering a clear advantage for collectors seeking premium aesthetics at a potentially lower cost.

Should I focus on Kaito, Bane of Nightmares or Valgavoth, Terror Eater for a budget collection?

Both Kaito, Bane of Nightmares and Valgavoth, Terror Eater offer great value under $25. Kaito, Bane of Nightmares (raw $19.64 for regular, $21.35 for borderless foil) appeals to collectors who value character and lore, with potentially strategic gameplay. Valgavoth, Terror Eater (raw $19.92 for regular, $20.73 for foil) is a more aggressive creature choice with strong stats. Your choice depends on whether you prioritize character-driven collectibility and nuanced play (Kaito) or raw power and a menacing presence (Valgavoth).

What makes the borderless foil versions of cards like Kaito and Abhorrent Oculus special?

Borderless foil versions offer a premium collecting experience by removing the traditional card border, allowing the artwork to extend to the edges of the card. Combined with the foil treatment, this creates a visually stunning and highly collectible product. Cards like Kaito, Bane of Nightmares [Borderless Foil] ($21.35) and Abhorrent Oculus [Borderless Foil] ($19.99) are prime examples of how unique printings can enhance a card’s appeal and desirability for collectors, even within a budget.

Can I build a competitive deck with these budget Duskmourn House of Horror cards?

Absolutely. Cards like Overlord of the Balemurk ($24.35 raw, $21.79-$20.29 foil) and Valgavoth, Terror Eater ($19.92 raw, $20.73 foil) are powerful creatures with stats and abilities that can certainly compete in various Magic formats, especially Commander. Enduring Vitality ($20.50 raw, $19.24 foil) offers significant utility for creature-based strategies. While these might not be the absolute top-tier chase cards, they provide excellent strategic depth and power for their price point, making them viable for competitive budget decks.

Duskmourn House of Horror presents a fantastic opportunity for collectors to acquire powerful and visually appealing cards without breaking the bank. By focusing on the verified data and making informed choices, you can build a robust collection that offers both intrinsic enjoyment and potential for future value. For more insights into valuable TCG collectibles, explore our /2026-10-13-top-10-most-valuable-secret-lair-ultimate-edition-cards-2026/ and dive deeper into the world of TCG collectibles at /tcg-collectibles/.