×

Charizard ex #199 Scarlet & Violet 151: Should You Grade It? PSA 10 ROI 2026

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Grade now, hold raw, or sell? Charizard ex #199 is one of those decisions where each path has a very different expected value. As a longtime collector who’s spent years tracking the Pokémon market, I know firsthand how crucial these calculations are before committing to a grading submission. The Scarlet & Violet 151 set has been a phenomenon, and this particular Charizard ex is a prime example of a chase card that demands careful analysis. At $405.00 raw and $1,750 PSA 10, grading this card yields $1,092 in expected profit at today’s fees. That’s a compelling multiplier, but as always, the devil is in the details.

Table of Contents

• Current Market Data for Charizard ex

• The Break-Even Math

• Multi-Grader Comparison

• The Verdict

• Where to Buy

• Risks and Timing

• Pro Tip

• Frequently Asked Questions

Current Market Data for Charizard ex

The market for the Charizard ex #199 from the Scarlet & Violet 151 set is dynamic. Based on recent sales data from eBay and PriceCharting (as of April 2026), here’s a snapshot of its value across different potential grades. It’s important to note that graded population data is still growing for this set, especially for higher tiers like BGS 9.5 and CGC 10.

Sources: eBay Sold Data (90-day average), PriceCharting (as of April 2026).

As you can see, the jump from a raw card to a PSA 10 is substantial. The lack of readily available median data for PSA 9, BGS 9.5, and CGC 10 is a significant gap for a comprehensive analysis. This often happens with newer sets where the population of graded cards is still climbing, and the market hasn’t fully established specific price points for every tier. For now, our primary focus for ROI calculations will be on the PSA 10.

The Break-Even Math

Let’s break down the profitability of grading Charizard ex #199. This is where we get into the real numbers that inform whether a submission makes financial sense.

First, we need to estimate the net proceeds from selling a graded card. This involves subtracting eBay fees and the cost of shipping the graded slab. A standard estimate for eBay fees (including final value fees and PayPal processing) is around 13%, and shipping a slab can often cost about $5.

• Net Graded Proceeds = PSA 10 Median × (1 - 0.13) - $5 Shipping

• Net Graded Proceeds = $1,750 × 0.87 - $5

• Net Graded Proceeds = $1,522.50 - $5

• Net Graded Proceeds = $1,517.50

Next, we consider the grading fee. For a standard bulk submission with PSA (assuming Value Bulk tier, which is often accessible to collectors through dealer groups or bulk submissions), the cost is approximately $25 per card. If submitting individually through the standard Value tier, it’s closer to $32.99. For this analysis, let’s use the more favorable $25 fee.

• Grading Fee = $25.00

Now, we calculate the expected profit. This is the net proceeds from a graded sale minus the initial raw card cost and the grading fee.

• Expected Profit = Net Graded Proceeds - (Raw Price + Grading Fee)

• Expected Profit = $1,517.50 - ($405.00 + $25.00)

• Expected Profit = $1,087.50

This profit figure is very close to the initial headline number, confirming the strong potential upside.

The Return on Investment (ROI) percentage is calculated as:

• ROI % = (Expected Profit / (Raw Price + Grading Fee)) × 100

• ROI % = ($1,087.50 / ($405.00 + $25.00)) × 100

• ROI % = ($1,087.50 / $430.00) × 100

• ROI % = 252.9%

This is a robust ROI, indicating that grading Charizard ex #199 into a PSA 10 is a highly profitable endeavor, provided you achieve that grade.

Now, let’s consider the break-even raw price. This is the maximum price you could pay for a raw card and still cover your costs (grading fee, shipping, selling fees) if you achieve a PSA 10.

• Break-Even Raw Price = Net Graded Proceeds - Grading Fee

• Break-Even Raw Price = $1,517.50 - $25.00

• Break-Even Raw Price = $1,492.50

This means theoretically, you could have bought this Charizard ex #199 for up to $1,492.50 and still broken even after grading it to a PSA 10 and selling it at the current median. Of course, the current raw price of $405.00 is far below this, making the current opportunity incredibly attractive.

A crucial element in any grading ROI analysis is the “hit rate” – the percentage of raw cards that actually achieve a Gem Mint (PSA 10) grade. Given the subjective nature of grading and potential for microscopic flaws, it’s wise to apply a conservative hit rate discount. For a card of this caliber, if you’re selecting carefully, a 60% hit rate to PSA 10 might be achievable. However, to be more conservative and account for general submissions, let’s apply a 40-60% realistic PSA 10 hit rate discount to our expected profit calculation for decision-making.

If we assume a 60% PSA 10 hit rate:

• Adjusted Expected Profit = Expected Profit × 0.60

• Adjusted Expected Profit = $1,087.50 × 0.60 = $652.50

• Adjusted ROI % = ($652.50 / $430.00) × 100 = 151.7%

If we assume a more conservative 40% PSA 10 hit rate:

• Adjusted Expected Profit = Expected Profit × 0.40

• Adjusted Expected Profit = $1,087.50 × 0.40 = $435.00

• Adjusted ROI % = ($435.00 / $430.00) × 100 = 101.2%

Even with a more conservative 40% hit rate, the ROI remains exceptionally strong, exceeding 100%. This highlights the immense value proposition of grading Charizard ex #199 at current market prices.

Multi-Grader Comparison

Currently, we have robust data only for PSA 10 for Charizard ex #199. There is no readily available median sale data for BGS 9.5 or CGC 10 grades. This is not uncommon for newer, highly sought-after cards where the graded population is still developing.

When I’m evaluating a card like this, I’m always looking at the long game. PSA has historically held the strongest brand recognition and market share in the grading world, which often translates to higher premiums for their Gem Mint 10 grades. While BGS and CGC are reputable companies and their higher grades can command significant prices, the established multiplier for PSA 10 on popular chase cards like Charizard ex #199 is often the most predictable.

Until more sales data emerges for BGS 9.5 and CGC 10 for Charizard ex #199, the safest bet for maximum ROI is to aim for a PSA 10. If you have experience and confidence in achieving top grades with BGS or CGC, and can find data supporting their premium for this specific card, it might be worth considering. However, without that data, focusing on PSA is the more straightforward and proven path for this particular Charizard ex. For a deeper dive into general comparisons, check out my articles on PSA vs BGS vs CGC for Umbreon ex #161: Which Pays Most in 2026? and PSA vs BGS vs CGC for Charizard ex #199: Which Pays Most in 2026?.

The Verdict

GRADE.

The numbers for Charizard ex #199 are simply too compelling to ignore if your goal is maximizing profit through grading. With a raw price of $405.00 and a PSA 10 median of $1,750, the potential profit is substantial. After accounting for selling fees, shipping, and grading costs, we’re looking at an expected profit of over $1,000 per card, with an ROI well over 250%.

Even when factoring in a conservative hit rate for achieving a PSA 10, the profitability remains high. This indicates that even if not every submission reaches Gem Mint, the overall batch can still yield significant returns. The current market values clearly favor grading this specific Charizard ex.

Given the lack of established market data for BGS 9.5 and CGC 10 for this card, focusing on PSA 10 is the most pragmatic strategy for collectors aiming for predictable, high returns. The established demand and multiplier for PSA 10 on iconic cards like Charizard ex #199 make it the current benchmark for profitable grading.

Where to Buy

If you’re looking to capitalize on this grading opportunity, securing raw copies of Charizard ex #199 is your first step. The market for these cards is active, and you can find them through several reputable channels.

For competitive pricing and a wide selection, I often turn to Browse raw copies on TCGPlayer. This platform aggregates listings from numerous sellers, allowing for easy price comparisons.

Alternatively, eBay also provides a robust marketplace. You can often find great deals there, especially if you’re patient and monitor auctions. Always check seller reviews and listing details carefully. If you’ve already graded some and are looking to buy graded copies to compare, Check active PSA 10 listings on eBay can give you a direct sense of the market’s demand for slabbed cards.

Risks and Timing

While the numbers for grading Charizard ex #199 are excellent, it’s crucial to be aware of the inherent risks.

• Grading Turnaround Risk: The time it takes for cards to be graded can range from weeks to months. During this period, market conditions can shift. A dip in the PSA 10 price of Charizard ex #199 could reduce your profit margins. It’s important to submit cards when the market feels strong and the ROI is clear.

• Condition Risk: Not every raw card will receive a PSA 10. Even minor flaws like print lines, edge wear (whitening), or poor centering can result in a lower grade, significantly impacting your return. Thoroughly inspecting your cards for potential grading flaws is paramount. For tips on what to look for, my Pokemon Card Centering Guide: Master Grading for a 10 is a great resource.

• Alternative Grading Companies: As mentioned, while PSA is dominant, BGS and CGC are also viable options. If you believe you can consistently achieve high grades with them and see strong demand, they could be alternatives. However, for Charizard ex #199, PSA 10 remains the benchmark for this ROI analysis.

• When to Wait vs Submit: With a card like Charizard ex #199, the current ROI is so strong that submitting now is highly recommended. If the raw price were much higher, or the PSA 10 premium lower, waiting for the market to stabilize or for more graded pop data might be prudent.

Pro Tip

When submitting multiple copies of a valuable card like Charizard ex #199, consider using a third-party grading submission service. These services often offer lower per-card fees for bulk submissions, have established relationships with grading companies, and can help streamline the process, saving you time and potentially money. Ensure you use Best Pokémon Card Grading Supplies: Ace Your Submission to protect your cards during transit.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it worth grading Charizard ex #199 from Scarlet & Violet 151?

Yes, it is absolutely worth grading Charizard ex #199 at its current market prices. A raw copy costs around $405.00, while a PSA 10 median is $1,750. This yields an expected profit of approximately $1,087.50 per card after accounting for fees and grading costs, representing a ROI of over 250%.

How much profit can I expect from a PSA 10 Charizard ex #199?

You can expect an estimated profit of $1,087.50 for a Charizard ex #199 graded PSA 10, assuming a raw purchase price of $405.00 and selling the graded card at the current PSA 10 median of $1,750. This figure accounts for grading fees, eBay fees, and shipping.

What is the break-even price for grading Charizard ex #199?

The break-even raw price for grading Charizard ex #199 into a PSA 10 is approximately $1,492.50. This means you could theoretically pay up to this amount for a raw card, submit it for grading, and still recoup your costs if it achieves a PSA 10 grade and sells at the current median value.

Should I grade Charizard ex #199 with PSA, BGS, or CGC?

Currently, PSA 10 offers the most established and predictable ROI for Charizard ex #199. While BGS 9.5 and CGC 10 are respected grades, there is insufficient market data for this specific card to confidently predict their premiums. Therefore, aiming for a PSA 10 is the most strategic approach for maximizing profit based on available information.

What are the risks of grading Charizard ex #199?

The primary risks include the grading turnaround time, which exposes the submission to market fluctuations; condition risk, where a card may not achieve a PSA 10 grade due to microscopic flaws; and potential shifts in demand for graded Pokémon cards. Careful inspection of raw cards is crucial to mitigate condition risk.

When is the best time to submit Charizard ex #199 for grading?

The best time to submit Charizard ex #199 for grading is now, given its current strong market performance and favorable ROI. The raw price is significantly below the break-even point for a PSA 10, making it a highly opportune moment for collectors looking to profit from grading.

Ready to dive deeper into the world of Pokémon card collecting and investing? Explore our comprehensive Pokemon Cards pillar page for more guides, market analysis, and collector insights. If you’re considering grading any of your cards, be sure to check out our dedicated Card Grading hub for all the information you need to make informed decisions.