Verified comps. Grading math. No guesswork.
rarest psa graded snes games

54 Rarest PSA-Graded SNES Games: Pop-1 Study (2026)

Published 2026-09-09 · Updated 2026-10-27 · by Jason Trogdon
Retro Video Games 12 min read

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

A What The Slab analysis of PSA’s population report: of the 713 US Super Nintendo titles PSA has graded, 54 have a population of exactly one — a single slab on record — and 44 of those 54 are a single sealed copy. This study lists every one of them, with grade and current market price, and shows how lopsided SNES population really is.

The numbers at a glance

Bar chart: distribution of PSA-graded copies per SNES title across 713 graded titles

Methodology

All 51 SNES games with a PSA population of one

Sorted alphabetically. Only graded copy is the condition of the single slab PSA has recorded; Grade shows PSA’s numeric grade plus the seal grade for sealed copies. Prices are PriceCharting market values for that condition today, not what the graded copy sold for.

# Game Only graded copy Grade Sealed price CIB price Loose price
1 A.S.P. Air Strike Patrol Sealed 9.6 A+ $256 $80 $26
2 Air Cavalry Sealed 9.2 A+ $431 $115 $45
3 Al Unser Jr.’s Road to the Top Sealed 9.2 B $104 $42 $10
4 American Gladiators Sealed 9.6 A++ $146 $50 $11
5 Arcade’s Greatest Hits: The Atari Collection 1 Sealed 8.5 A+ $115 $36 $14
6 Bass Masters Classic: Pro Edition Sealed 8.5 A $83 $31 $11
7 Best of the Best: Championship Karate Sealed 7.0 A+ $95 $31 $10
8 BlaZeon: The Bio-Cyborg Challenge Sealed 8.5 A $585 $262 $46
9 Championship Soccer ‘94 Sealed 8.5 A $148 $46 $16
10 Congo’s Caper Sealed 8.0 A $480 $150 $25
11 David Crane’s Amazing Tennis Sealed 9.6 A+ $60 $40 $7
12 DinoCity Sealed 8.5 A $256 $80 $14
13 Elite Soccer Sealed 9.2 A+ $640 $200 $23
14 F1 Pole Position Sealed 9.6 A+ $212 $59 $13
15 F1 ROC II: Race of Champions Loose 6.5 $226 $71 $18
16 Frank Thomas Big Hurt Baseball Sealed 9.0 A+ $103 $26 $8
17 Full Throttle: All-American Racing Sealed 9.4 B $66 $21 $10
18 Genghis Khan II: Clan of the Gray Wolf CIB <6.5 $320 $100 $30
19 International Superstar Soccer Loose 7.0 $4,640 $1,450 $150
20 International Superstar Soccer ‘98 * Sealed 9.4 A+ — — —
21 Jeopardy! Sealed 9.0 A $26 $25 $8
22 Ka-Blooey Sealed 9.4 A+ $160 $50 $11
23 Kawasaki Caribbean Challenge CIB 8.5 $106 $33 $9
24 Kawasaki Superbike Challenge Sealed 7.5 B+ $294 $125 $6
25 Kyle Petty’s No Fear Racing Sealed 9.6 A+ $240 $75 $10
26 Mario’s Early Years: Fun with Letters Sealed 8.0 A $343 $107 $18
27 Mark Davis’ The Fishing Master Sealed 9.4 A+ $160 $50 $16
28 Monaco Grand Prix * Sealed 9.4 A+ — — —
29 Obitus Sealed 9.4 A $210 $66 $20
30 Pebble Beach Golf Links Loose 9.0 $40 $22 $6
31 PGA Tour 96 Sealed 7.5 A $70 $20 $7
32 Pro Sport Hockey Sealed 9.4 A+ $558 $30 $9
33 Radical Rex Sealed 9.0 A $375 $117 $25
34 Redline F-1 Racer Sealed 7.5 B+ $312 $98 $18
35 Rise of the Phoenix Sealed 8.5 B+ $480 $150 $61
36 Secret of the Stars CIB 7.0 $555 $157 $69
37 Space Football: One on One Sealed 8.0 A $147 $46 $14
38 Super Chase H.Q. Sealed 9.6 A+ $270 $84 $20
39 Super Copa Sealed 9.2 A $3,219 $2,750 $200
40 Super Ninja Boy Sealed 8.0 B+ $536 $168 $23
41 Super Putty Sealed 8.5 A $155 $48 $14
42 Super Slam Dunk Sealed 8.5 A+ $77 $24 $5
43 Super Soccer Champ Sealed 8.0 A $226 $71 $15
44 Super Strike Eagle Sealed 8.5 A $237 $43 $12
45 Super Troll Islands Sealed 9.8 A+ $224 $70 $20
46 Suzuka 8 Hours Sealed 9.4 A+ $160 $50 $10
47 The Flintstones: The Treasure of Sierra Madrock CIB <6.5 $1,056 $330 $94
48 The Peace Keepers Sealed 8.5 B $568 $178 $60
49 TKO Super Championship Boxing CIB 8.0 $320 $100 $19
50 Ultima: The False Prophet Sealed 9.4 A+ $197 $62 $25
51 Wheel of Fortune: Featuring Vanna White Sealed <6.5 A+ $30 $17 $6

* PSA lists International Superstar Soccer ‘98 and Monaco Grand Prix in its SNES report; we could not find a source confirming an official SNES release, so treat those entries as PSA’s classification.

The highest sealed market value on the list belongs to International Superstar Soccer at $4,640, yet PSA’s only graded copy of it is a loose cart.

3 modern releases with one graded copy

PSA’s SNES report also covers cartridges made long after the console’s life. These have one graded copy each but are not 1990s releases, so they are kept out of the table above.

Game Only graded copy Grade What it is
Clock Tower: Rewind Loose 9.6 from the 2024 re-release of a Super Famicom game; PSA’s label reads “Limited Run”
River City Girls Zero Loose 9.2 from the 2022 re-release of a 1994 Super Famicom game
Xeno Crisis Sealed 9.8 A++ a new SNES game from Bitmap Bureau, announced in 2023

Why 43 of the 51 are sealed

Of the 51 original-release titles above, 43 are sealed, 5 complete-in-box, 3 loose. Sealed copies dominate the pop-1 list: collectors rarely pay to grade a loose cart of a game nobody is chasing, while a factory-sealed copy of even a forgotten sports or licensed title is the kind of copy that does get submitted. The result is a long tail of SNES games whose entire graded population is a single sealed box.

The other end of the curve: the 10 most-graded SNES games

For contrast, here is where the population actually concentrates. The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past alone has 410 graded copies.

Rank Game PSA-graded copies
1 The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past 410
2 F-Zero 366
3 Super Mario Kart 255
4 Street Fighter II 240
5 Donkey Kong Country 236
6 Super Mario World 217
7 Super Star Wars 202
8 Chrono Trigger 194
9 Donkey Kong Country 2: Diddy’s Kong Quest 143
10 Killer Instinct 128

Download the data

Cite it freely. If you use the data, a link back to this page is appreciated.

Shop These Games on eBay

Every game below is listed under the title PSA grades it as; each link opens eBay’s sold results or current listings.

Frequently asked questions

Does a PSA population of one mean the game is valuable?

Not on its own. Population measures how many copies have been graded, not how many exist or how many people want one. Several pop-1 titles on this list carry sealed market values under $100. Rarity becomes valuable only when demand meets it — the retro collecting guide covers which SNES games have both scarcity and a collector base.

Why do so many SNES games have fewer than ten graded copies?

Because grading costs money and most SNES titles do not justify it. 504 of the 713 graded titles (71%) have ten or fewer copies. Population clusters around a small set of Nintendo first-party and marquee third-party games — the ten most-graded titles hold 22% of every SNES slab PSA has recorded.

How is this different from a print-run rarity list?

A print-run list ranks games by how many were manufactured. This study ranks them by how many have been graded. A game can be common on the used market and still have a graded population of one because nobody has submitted it. The per-game pop report pages show both the population and the current loose, CIB, and sealed prices so you can judge the two together.

Will this list change?

Yes. Any title here drops off the moment a second copy is graded. The page is regenerated from the current PSA report; the snapshot dates in the methodology show when.

Data: PSA population reports · PriceCharting · eBay sold listings. Analysis: What The Slab. How we get our numbers.

Weekly graded sales report

Free weekly email. Unsubscribe anytime.

J

About Jason

Jason has been collecting cards since 1999 and retro video games since 2008. Based in the Southeast US. What The Slab cites real eBay sold comps, PriceCharting data, and PSA pop reports — no guesswork. Read more → · How we get our numbers