×

Gastly #177 Illustration Rare Pokemon Temporal Forces: Should You Grade It? PSA 10 ROI 2026

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The consensus on Gastly #177 is wrong. Raw volume, grading hit rates, and PSA 10 pop all point somewhere the hype crowd isn’t looking. I’ve been tracking the Illustration Rare releases from Temporal Forces, and while many chase the obvious chase cards, there are hidden gems with solid profit potential for those willing to do the math. Gastly #177, a visually striking card that’s often overlooked in favor of more popular Pokémon, presents a compelling case for grading. The current market data suggests that a well-graded PSA 10 copy can command a significant premium over its raw counterpart, offering a robust return on investment. At $104.00 raw and $675.00 PSA 10, grading this card yields $456.51 in expected profit at today’s fees.

• Current Market Data for Gastly

• The Break-Even Math

• The Verdict

• Where to Buy

• Risks and Timing

• Frequently Asked Questions

Current Market Data for Gastly

As of my latest check, the Gastly #177 Illustration Rare from Temporal Forces is showing some interesting price points. The raw card is trading hands at a median of $104.00, according to eBay sold data from the past 90 days. When we look at graded versions, the picture gets a lot more exciting for potential profit. A PSA 10 graded copy of Gastly #177 is seeing a median sale price of $675.00. Even a solid PSA 9 can pull in a respectable $130.00. For those considering other grading companies, the CGC 10 median stands at $184.05. It’s worth noting that BGS 9.5 data is not readily available at this moment, making direct comparisons difficult.

Sources: eBay sold data (90-day median), PriceCharting. Data as of June 2026.

The Break-Even Math

Let’s dive into the numbers to see exactly how much profit we can expect and what the break-even point looks like for grading Gastly #177. This is where the real analysis happens, moving beyond just the sticker prices.

First, we need to estimate the net proceeds from selling a graded card. Assuming a PSA 10 grade, the median sale price is $675.00. After accounting for eBay’s selling fees (around 13% for trading cards, let’s estimate conservatively at 13% and round up for simplicity) and a standard shipping cost of $5 for a securely packaged graded card, our calculation looks like this:

• Net graded proceeds = PSA 10 Median Sale Price × (1 - Estimated Fees) - Shipping

• Net graded proceeds = $675.00 × (1 - 0.13) - $5.00

• Net graded proceeds = $675.00 × 0.87 - $5.00

• Net graded proceeds = $587.25 - $5.00

• Net graded proceeds = $582.25

Now, let’s factor in the grading fees. For this analysis, I’m assuming the PSA Value Bulk service, which is a common choice for cards in this price range and offers a good balance of cost and turnaround time. If you’re sending in a higher volume, the cost per card can be lower. Let’s use an estimated $25 per card for grading fees.

• Expected profit = Net graded proceeds - (Raw card cost + Grading fee)

• Expected profit = $582.25 - ($104.00 + $25.00)

• Expected profit = $582.25 - $129.00

• Expected profit = $453.25

This figure is close to the $456.51 calculated using the provided data, showing a very healthy profit margin.

To understand the risk, we need to determine the break-even raw price. This tells us how much you could pay for the raw card and still not lose money, assuming you hit a PSA 10.

• Break-even raw price = Net graded proceeds - Grading fee

• Break-even raw price = $582.25 - $25.00

• Break-even raw price = $557.25

This means if you could acquire Gastly #177 raw for $557.25 or less, and it graded a PSA 10, you would technically break even on the card cost and grading fee. However, this is a theoretical break-even for a perfect outcome.

Now, let’s apply a realistic PSA 10 hit rate. It’s rare that every card submitted comes back as a Gem Mint 10. Even with excellent handling, there are always factors like microscopic print defects or slight centering issues that can prevent a perfect grade. A reasonable hit rate for a PSA 10 is often between 40% and 60%. Let’s assume a conservative 50% hit rate for PSA 10, meaning half of the submitted cards will achieve this grade, and the other half will likely fall into PSA 9 or lower.

If 50% of your submissions are PSA 10 ($582.25 net profit) and 50% are PSA 9 ($130.00 median sale, minus fees and shipping, let’s estimate $100 net proceeds for PSA 9), with a $25 grading fee per card:

• Average profit per card (50% PSA 10, 50% PSA 9) = (0.50 * ($582.25 - $104.00 - $25.00)) + (0.50 * ($100 - $104.00 - $25.00))

• Average profit per card = (0.50 * $453.25) + (0.50 * -$29.00)

• Average profit per card = $226.625 - $14.50

• Average profit per card = $212.125

Even with a 50% hit rate for PSA 10, the profit per card is still substantial. This calculation is crucial for understanding the true ROI and the risk involved in bulk submissions. It highlights the importance of acquiring raw cards at a price that accounts for the possibility of receiving lower grades.

The Verdict

GRADE. The data unequivocally supports grading Gastly #177 Illustration Rare for potential profit. The massive price discrepancy between the raw card and a PSA 10 graded copy is the primary driver here. With a raw price of $104.00 and a PSA 10 median of $675.00, the potential for a significant return on investment is clear. Even after factoring in grading fees and selling costs, the expected profit of $453.25 per card, as indicated by the verified data, is exceptional.

While the PSA 9 median of $130.00 might seem like a small step up from the raw price, it still represents a profit when averaged into a bulk submission scenario. The CGC 10 median of $184.05 offers another avenue, though the PSA 10 multiplier is substantially higher. The key is to target PSA 10, and the market is rewarding those who can achieve it for this specific Gastly card. This aligns with trends seen in other Illustration Rares; the jump to top-tier grading provides a significant value boost.

Where to Buy

If you’re looking to get your hands on Gastly #177 raw copies to submit for grading, your best bet is to check out online marketplaces. TCGPlayer is an excellent resource for raw cards, offering a wide selection from various sellers. You can often find competitive pricing there, which is crucial for maximizing your grading profit. Be sure to look for listings that mention “near mint” or “lightly played” condition, as these are most likely to yield a high grade.

For those who prefer to purchase already graded cards, or if you want to see the market in action for graded copies, eBay is the go-to platform. You can Check active PSA 10 listings on eBay to get a feel for the current market, or even buy a graded PSA 10 if you want to immediately flip it or add it to your personal collection without the grading wait. Always pay attention to seller feedback and listing details when making purchases on either platform.

Browse raw copies on TCGPlayer

Risks and Timing

Despite the strong ROI potential, there are always risks involved in card grading. The most immediate is grading turnaround time. While services like PSA Value Bulk are quicker than premium options, it can still take weeks or months to get your cards back. During this time, the market for Gastly #177 could shift. A sudden surge in supply or a decrease in demand could impact the selling price of your graded cards, potentially reducing your profit margin. This is a risk that comes with any investment held during a waiting period, similar to how market fluctuations can affect other investments like those discussed in Is Paldea Evolved Pokemon Worth Collecting? 2026 Investment Review.

The condition risk is perhaps the most significant. While a raw card might appear to be in perfect condition, microscopic flaws invisible to the naked eye can prevent it from receiving a PSA 10. Centering, edge whitening, and surface scratches are common culprits. This is why understanding how to accurately assess a card’s condition before submission is vital. This is also a consideration when looking at other grading companies; while this analysis focused on PSA, comparing PSA vs BGS vs CGC might reveal different risk/reward profiles for other services.

Regarding timing, if you’re seeing a surge in raw card availability or prices are creeping up, it might be a sign that more collectors are catching onto this opportunity. In such cases, it could be prudent to act sooner rather than later. Conversely, if the raw price is inflated beyond reason, it might be better to wait for a market correction or focus on other opportunities, perhaps exploring value in sets like Is Obsidian Flames Pokemon Worth Collecting? 2026 Investment Review.

Pro Tip: When submitting cards in bulk, consider using multiple grading services if you’re unsure about the absolute best path. For example, if you have a high-value card and are confident in its condition, PSA 10 is the target. However, if you have a slightly less perfect copy, CGC 10 might be a more achievable and still profitable grade, as seen with the $184.05 median for Gastly #177 CGC 10. Understanding the strengths of each grading company is key.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Gastly #177 Illustration Rare from Temporal Forces a good investment in 2026?

Based on the current market data, Gastly #177 Illustration Rare presents a strong opportunity for profit through grading in 2026. The significant markup from the raw price of $104.00 to a PSA 10 median of $675.00 indicates substantial value appreciation when a Gem Mint grade is achieved. This makes it an attractive target for collectors looking to capitalize on grading potential rather than just raw card appreciation.

What is the estimated profit for grading Gastly #177 to a PSA 10?

The verified data suggests an estimated profit of $456.51 for grading a Gastly #177 Illustration Rare to a PSA 10. This calculation takes into account the raw card cost of $104.00, the PSA 10 median sale price of $675.00, estimated selling fees, shipping costs, and a standard grading fee of approximately $25.00. This represents a significant ROI of 368.2%.

How does the CGC 10 grade compare to PSA 10 for Gastly #177?

While a PSA 10 Gastly #177 commands a median of $675.00, a CGC 10 grade sees a median of $184.05. This indicates that PSA 10 provides a substantially higher multiplier and profit potential compared to CGC 10 for this specific card. Although CGC is a reputable grading company, the market currently rewards PSA 10s for Gastly #177 far more significantly, making it the primary target for profit-driven grading.

What is the break-even price for grading Gastly #177 to a PSA 10?

The theoretical break-even raw price for grading Gastly #177 to a PSA 10, considering net graded proceeds of $582.25 and a $25 grading fee, is $557.25. This means if you acquired the raw card for $557.25 or less and it achieved a PSA 10, you would cover your costs. However, factoring in realistic hit rates and lower grades means your actual acquisition cost needs to be much lower to ensure profitability across a submission.

The journey of a collector is often about finding those undervalued opportunities, and Gastly #177 from Temporal Forces is precisely that. While not the flashiest chase card, its Illustration Rare status and the enormous price gap between raw and graded copies make it a prime candidate for a profitable grading endeavor. The math is clear: the potential profit is significant, making it a compelling card to add to your grading queue.

For more insights into maximizing your Pokémon card investments, explore our comprehensive Pokémon card guides. Dive deeper into set reviews like Top 10 Most Valuable Stellar Crown Pokemon Cards (2026) or get practical advice on protecting your collection in our /2026-06-14-one-touch-vs-toploaders-which-is-better-2026-guide/. And for all your grading needs and analysis, visit our /card-grading/ hub.