Top 10 Most Valuable 2021 Topps Wwe Women's Division Autographs Sports Cards (2026)

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The top 10 most valuable 2021 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs cards range from $194.94 to $449.45 in raw sales as of June 2026. Indi Hartwell’s Black autograph variant leads the market, significantly outperforming other key autographs from the set.

Collectors keep asking about the 2021 Topps WWE Women’s Division autographs. My honest take, based on 90-day sold data: most of you are chasing the wrong cards. While there’s a clear hierarchy forming around established stars and rarer parallels, the true value lies in understanding the subtle market shifts and investing in cards that show sustained demand. The raw market for these autographs sees Indi Hartwell’s Black variant commanding the highest price at $449.45, followed closely by Liv Morgan’s Gold auto at $254.00. However, the sheer volume of Stephanie McMahon cards within the top 10, appearing four times, suggests a strong, albeit fragmented, interest in her autographs across various parallels, with her Blue variant hitting $236.25. This isn’t a set where one single card dominates; rather, it’s a collection of potent autograph offerings that, when viewed together, paint a clear picture of the current collector sentiment for this niche within the wrestling card market.

In This Article

• The Top 10 2021 Topps Wwe Women’s Division Autographs Market Data

• Understanding the Top Autographs

• Indi Hartwell: The Undisputed Leader

• Liv Morgan: A Strong Contender

• Stephanie McMahon: A Multi-Faceted Draw

• Charlotte Flair: Veteran Presence

• Gigi Dolin & Alexa Bliss: Rising Stars

• The Grading ROI Play: Maximizing Your Investment

• Buying Strategy for 2026

• FAQ

The Top 10 2021 Topps Wwe Women’s Division Autographs Market Data

Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices. All figures as of June 2026.

Understanding the Top Autographs

The 2021 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set offers a fascinating snapshot of fan favorites and rising stars, each with their own unique market appeal. As of June 2026, the data clearly indicates a hierarchy, but it’s not as straightforward as one might assume. While certain stars like Indi Hartwell and Liv Morgan command the top prices, the presence of multiple Stephanie McMahon parallels within the top 10 signifies the enduring legacy and collector interest in “The Billion Dollar Princess.” This set, released in a period of significant growth for women’s wrestling cards, tapped into a burgeoning market, and these autographs represent some of the earliest and most sought-after pieces from that era.

The raw prices listed are based on recent eBay sold data, which is crucial for understanding the immediate market sentiment. It’s important to note that PSA 10 data is not readily available for these specific cards, meaning the raw price is the primary indicator of value. This scarcity of graded data for top-tier examples can sometimes inflate raw prices, as collectors are eager to secure the best available versions before the grading market catches up. Furthermore, the grading ROI column being empty suggests that while these cards are valuable raw, their potential for appreciation through grading is yet to be fully established or publicly documented across a significant number of sales. This presents an opportunity for those looking to acquire cards at a lower entry point with the potential for future upside if they can secure high-grade examples.

The composition of the top 10 also highlights the importance of parallels. Variants like the Black, Gold, Blue, Orange, Purple, and Green editions all contribute to a card’s scarcity and, consequently, its market value. For instance, Indi Hartwell’s Black auto is the clear leader, demonstrating that even within a single wrestler’s autograph offerings, the specific parallel can make a substantial difference in price. This is a common theme in modern trading cards: limited print runs and distinct color variations drive desirability and value. As we delve deeper into each card, we’ll examine the specific factors contributing to their ranking and what they might signify for collectors in 2026. Understanding these nuances is key to making informed decisions in this dynamic market.

1. Indi Hartwell [Black]

The undisputed king of the 2021 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs in raw market value is Indi Hartwell’s Black parallel. Commanding an impressive $449.45, this card represents the pinnacle of the set’s current valuation. Hartwell, a prominent figure in NXT during this period, has cultivated a dedicated fanbase, and this autograph serves as a tangible piece of her rise. The Black parallel is often one of the more elusive variants within a Topps set, contributing significantly to its desirability. Its scarcity, combined with Hartwell’s growing popularity, has created a potent combination that drives its premium price.

For collectors looking to acquire this card, the raw price suggests a significant investment. The absence of PSA 10 data means that acquiring a raw copy at this price point comes with the inherent risk and potential reward of grading. If a gem mint grade can be achieved, the multiplier effect could be substantial, though without established comps, it’s a speculative play. Currently, there are no readily available PSA 10 median prices, making the raw market the only indicator of its current worth. This makes it a card for those who believe strongly in Hartwell’s long-term potential and the enduring appeal of her early Topps autographs.

Buy Indi Hartwell [Black] (A-IH) on eBay (active listings) Check Indi Hartwell [Black] (A-IH) sold comps on eBay

2. Liv Morgan [Gold]

Following Indi Hartwell is Liv Morgan’s Gold parallel autograph, a strong second at $254.00 raw. Liv Morgan is a fan-favorite with a career trajectory that has seen her connect deeply with the WWE Universe. Her autograph cards, especially those from significant early sets like this one, are always in demand. The Gold parallel is typically a highly sought-after variant due to its distinct visual appeal and often more limited print run compared to base or other color parallels. This combination of a popular wrestler and a desirable parallel naturally elevates its market value.

The $254.00 raw price for Liv Morgan’s Gold auto places it in a significant tier within the set. Like Indi Hartwell’s card, there is no available PSA 10 median price, emphasizing the current market’s focus on raw sales. For collectors considering this card, it represents a more accessible entry point than the top-ranked Hartwell autograph, yet still signifies a valuable piece of wrestling memorabilia. Its position in the top 10 indicates a solid demand that is likely to be sustained, given Morgan’s continued prominence in WWE. A collector buying this raw would be making a calculated bet on both Liv Morgan’s star power and the appreciation of Gold parallels in general.

Buy Liv Morgan [Gold] (A-LM) on eBay (active listings) Check Liv Morgan [Gold] (A-LM) sold comps on eBay

3. Stephanie McMahon [Blue]

Stephanie McMahon’s presence in the top 10 is a testament to her iconic status in the wrestling world. Her Blue parallel autograph ranks third overall in raw value, fetching $236.25. McMahon, a pivotal figure in WWE’s history and management, has a unique appeal that extends beyond in-ring performance. Her autographs are often highly prized by collectors who value her business acumen and long-standing influence. The Blue parallel, a common but visually appealing variant, signifies a solid entry point into owning her signature from this set.

The $236.25 raw price positions Stephanie McMahon’s Blue auto as a significant contender. As with the cards above it, there are no PSA 10 median prices available, reinforcing the current reliance on raw sales data. This card offers collectors an opportunity to invest in a true legend of the industry. Given McMahon’s role and historical significance, her autographs are likely to maintain their value and potentially appreciate over time, especially from a set as specific as the 2021 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs. The Blue variant offers a balance of accessibility and clear collector demand.

Buy Stephanie McMahon [Blue] (A-ST) on eBay (active listings) Check Stephanie McMahon [Blue] (A-ST) sold comps on eBay

4. Stephanie McMahon [Orange]

Continuing the strong showing for Stephanie McMahon, her Orange parallel autograph secures the fourth spot with a raw price of $236.25. Wait, no, the data shows $229.38 for the Orange parallel. This slight difference from the Blue variant highlights how even subtle variations in color and perceived scarcity can impact market price. The Orange parallel provides another distinct aesthetic, often associated with limited print runs or specific insert themes within Topps products. For collectors focused on completing a set of Stephanie McMahon autographs or acquiring a piece of her legacy, this variant is a key target.

At $229.38 raw, this Orange auto is a premium card. The lack of PSA 10 data means collectors are primarily looking at current raw market trends. Stephanie McMahon’s enduring legacy and her position within the WWE hierarchy ensure a consistent baseline of collector interest. This Orange parallel represents a strong investment opportunity for those who recognize her long-term value as a collector’s item. It sits just below the Blue variant, indicating a marginal preference for that color, but remains a highly valuable autograph within the 2021 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set, appealing to collectors who value her historical significance.

Buy Stephanie McMahon [Orange] (A-ST) on eBay (active listings) Check Stephanie McMahon [Orange] (A-ST) sold comps on eBay

5. Stephanie McMahon [Purple]

Stephanie McMahon’s Purple parallel autograph claims the fifth position, with a raw price of $205.51. This further solidifies her status as one of the most consistently valuable signers from this set. The Purple variant offers a different color scheme, potentially appealing to collectors who prefer its aesthetic or are trying to acquire a full spectrum of her autographs from the release. The consistent demand across multiple parallels for Stephanie McMahon underscores her broad appeal, transcending typical wrestler-card collecting and entering the realm of sports memorabilia.

The $205.51 raw value for the Purple auto places it firmly in the upper echelon of this set. Once again, the absence of graded data points towards the raw market dictating current values. For collectors, this represents a chance to own a piece of wrestling history signed by a true icon. The descending price from the Blue and Orange variants suggests a slight dip in demand or perhaps a slightly higher print run for the Purple, but it remains a highly significant card. Its presence in the top five reinforces the idea that Stephanie McMahon autographs are a cornerstone of the 2021 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs market.

Buy Stephanie McMahon [Purple] (A-ST) on eBay (active listings) Check Stephanie McMahon [Purple] (A-ST) sold comps on eBay

6. Charlotte Flair [Black]

Charlotte Flair, a dominant force in women’s wrestling for years, makes her debut on the list at sixth place with her Black parallel autograph, valued at $202.98 raw. “The Queen” is known for her numerous championship reigns and her undeniable charisma, making her autographs highly collectible. The Black parallel often signifies a more limited print run, increasing its rarity and desirability among collectors. Her inclusion here is expected, given her status as one of the most recognizable and accomplished female athletes in WWE history.

The $202.98 raw price for Charlotte Flair’s Black auto positions her just below Stephanie McMahon’s Purple variant. The lack of PSA 10 data again directs our focus to raw sales. For collectors, this card represents a significant piece from a current top-tier performer. Charlotte Flair’s career is far from over, suggesting potential for her memorabilia to continue appreciating. The Black parallel offers a strong combination of a prominent wrestler and a potentially scarce variant, making it an attractive acquisition for fans and investors alike within the 2021 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set.

Buy Charlotte Flair [Black] (A-CF) on eBay (active listings) Check Charlotte Flair [Black] (A-CF) sold comps on eBay

7. Gigi Dolin [Black]

Gigi Dolin’s Black parallel autograph enters the top 10 at seventh place with a raw value of $199.99. Dolin, a rising star in NXT and a prominent member of the women’s division, represents the future of WWE. Autographs from promising talents like her, especially from early sets, are often sought after by collectors looking to get in on the ground floor of a potential superstar’s collecting market. The Black parallel, often associated with scarcity, further enhances its appeal.

At $199.99 raw, Gigi Dolin’s Black auto shows a strong early market presence. The absence of graded data means collectors are evaluating her raw autograph’s current worth. This card signifies the growing appeal of newer talent within the wrestling card collecting space. For those interested in the modern era of WWE and its burgeoning stars, Dolin’s signature represents a key piece. Her placement in the top 10, just shy of $200, indicates significant collector interest and potential for future growth as her career progresses.

Buy Gigi Dolin [Black] (A-GD) on eBay (active listings) Check Gigi Dolin [Black] (A-GD) sold comps on eBay

8. Stephanie McMahon [Green]

Remarkably, Stephanie McMahon makes her fourth appearance in the top 10 with her Green parallel autograph, valued at $196.75 raw. This illustrates the sheer depth of collector interest in her signature from this specific set. The Green variant adds another distinct color option for collectors aiming for variety or completion. Its position at eighth place, while lower than her other top-tier parallels, still firmly anchors her within the most valuable cards of the 2021 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs release.

The $196.75 raw price for Stephanie McMahon’s Green auto signifies consistent demand across her parallels. The lack of PSA 10 data means raw sales are the primary benchmark for value. For collectors interested in Stephanie McMahon, this Green parallel offers yet another avenue to acquire her autograph. It’s a strong testament to her brand’s enduring appeal and the strategic importance of parallel variations in driving collector engagement. This card, like her others on this list, represents a solid, albeit potentially less premium, investment in a wrestling icon’s memorabilia.

Buy Stephanie McMahon [Green] (A-ST) on eBay (active listings) Check Stephanie McMahon [Green] (A-ST) sold comps on eBay

9. Alexa Bliss [Black]

Alexa Bliss, a highly popular and charismatic performer, debuts at ninth place with her Black parallel autograph, valued at $194.95 raw. Bliss has a significant following, known for her captivating in-ring persona and her strong connection with fans across social media. Her autographs are consistently in demand, and the Black parallel, often denoting scarcity, makes this card particularly appealing. Her inclusion in the top 10 underscores her enduring popularity and marketability within the wrestling community.

The $194.95 raw price for Alexa Bliss’s Black auto places her at the lower end of the top 10, but still firmly within the most valuable cards of the set. The absence of graded data emphasizes the current raw market’s influence. For collectors, this represents a chance to own the autograph of a major star with a proven track record of fan engagement. The Black parallel offers a combination of a beloved wrestler and a potentially limited variant, making it an attractive option for those looking to invest in a card with strong current demand.

Buy Alexa Bliss [Black] (A-AB) on eBay (active listings) Check Alexa Bliss [Black] (A-AB) sold comps on eBay

10. Alexa Bliss [Gold]

Rounding out the top 10 is Alexa Bliss’s Gold parallel autograph, with a raw price of $194.94, negligibly trailing her Black parallel. This near-identical pricing indicates that both the Black and Gold variants are experiencing very similar levels of demand and market valuation within the 2021 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set. The Gold parallel is typically another desirable variant, often associated with limited print runs and a visually striking appearance, further solidifying Alexa Bliss’s status as a top-tier autograph in this release.

The $194.94 raw value for Alexa Bliss’s Gold auto mirrors her Black variant’s market position, signifying consistent collector interest in her autograph. The lack of PSA 10 data continues to highlight the current reliance on raw sales for valuation. For collectors, this Gold parallel presents a valuable opportunity to acquire a sought-after signature from a high-profile WWE superstar. Its presence at the tail end of the top 10, alongside its Black counterpart, firmly establishes Alexa Bliss as a key player in the market for this set, appealing to fans and investors alike.

Buy Alexa Bliss [Gold] (A-AB) on eBay (active listings) Check Alexa Bliss [Gold] (A-AB) sold comps on eBay

The Grading ROI Play

While the majority of these top 10 cards lack specific PSA 10 data, understanding the potential for Grading Return on Investment (ROI) is crucial for any collector looking to maximize value. Let’s hypothetically consider the Raw price as the acquisition cost, and assume a grading fee of $20 per card.

The top performer here, Indi Hartwell’s Black autograph at $449.45 raw, presents a significant opportunity if a PSA 10 can be achieved. To break even on this card alone, a collector would need to sell it for approximately $469.45 ($449.45 + $20 grading fee). However, the true ROI comes from the multiplier a PSA 10 grade provides over the raw price. Without established PSA 10 comps, this is speculative, but historically, top-tier autographs in gem condition can fetch significantly higher prices than their raw counterparts. A strong case could be made for this card if a collector can source a visually perfect example.

Similarly, Liv Morgan’s Gold autograph at $254.00 raw would require a sale price of approximately $274.00 ($254.00 + $20 grading fee) to break even. The potential here is for a higher multiplier than the Hartwell card, given Morgan’s broader mainstream appeal, if a PSA 10 can be obtained. The numerous Stephanie McMahon cards offer varying degrees of investment. For her Blue auto at $236.25, a break-even point of $256.25 is needed. The risk is that with multiple parallels of the same star, the market might become diluted, reducing the premium for any single graded example. However, her iconic status could still support a significant premium for a PSA 10.

For cards like Charlotte Flair’s Black auto ($202.98 raw), breaking even would require a sale of $222.98. Given Flair’s established championship pedigree and consistent performance, a gem-mint grade could command a considerable premium, potentially justifying the grading cost. The key takeaway for ROI is that while raw prices give us a baseline, the true value often materializes through the grading process. Collectors should focus on cards with strong wrestler appeal and desirable parallels, carefully assessing the risk versus reward of submitting them for grading, especially in the absence of established graded market data.

Pro Tip: When dealing with autographs from a relatively recent set like the 2021 Topps WWE Women’s Division series, and especially when PSA 10 data is scarce, pay close attention to the centering and corner condition of raw cards. These are often the most significant factors influencing a PSA 10 grade and, therefore, the ultimate ROI. Look for cards that are as close to mathematically perfect as possible before submitting.

Buying Strategy for 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the 2021 Topps Wwe Women’s Division Autographs set worth collecting in 2026?

Yes, the 2021 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set is worth collecting in 2026, especially if you focus on the top-tier cards like Indi Hartwell’s Black auto (valued at $449.45 raw) and Liv Morgan’s Gold auto ($254.00 raw). These cards represent significant demand and have established themselves as valuable pieces of modern wrestling memorabilia.

What is the most valuable 2021 Topps Wwe Women’s Division Autographs card?

As of June 2026, the most valuable card from the 2021 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set is the Indi Hartwell [Black] variant, which commanded a raw price of $449.45. This card leads the market due to a combination of Indi Hartwell’s popularity and the perceived scarcity of the Black parallel.

How do Stephanie McMahon’s multiple autographs affect her card values?

Stephanie McMahon appears multiple times in the top 10 with different parallels (Blue, Orange, Purple, Green), ranging from $236.25 down to $196.75 raw. While having multiple cards increases her overall presence, it can also mean each individual parallel might not reach the same peak value as a single, ultra-rare variant of another wrestler. However, her iconic status ensures sustained demand across all her offerings in this set.

Should I grade these 2021 Topps Wwe Women’s Division Autographs cards in 2026?

Grading these cards in 2026 is a strategic decision. With limited PSA 10 data available, the potential for a significant grading ROI exists if you can secure a gem-mint grade. Cards like Indi Hartwell [Black] and Liv Morgan [Gold] offer higher potential for value appreciation if graded, but it carries more risk without established graded market prices. Focus on visually perfect examples for the best chance at a high grade.

The 2021 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set continues to be a compelling segment of the modern wrestling card market. The data from June 2026 shows a clear hierarchy driven by wrestler popularity and parallel scarcity, with Indi Hartwell’s Black autograph leading the pack at $449.45 raw. For collectors and investors, understanding these market dynamics is key to making informed acquisitions. Whether you’re looking to complete a collection, invest in rising stars, or acquire pieces of wrestling history from established icons like Stephanie McMahon and Charlotte Flair, this set offers diverse opportunities.

For those looking to delve deeper into the world of sports card collecting and investment strategies, consider exploring our guides on Fanatics vs Topps What Changed for Collectors (2026 Guide). Understanding the broader market trends and how different manufacturers and eras are valued can provide crucial context for your collecting decisions across all sports cards.