Top 10 Most Valuable 2019 Topps Wwe Women's Division Autographs Sports Cards (2026)

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The most valuable 2019 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs cards are led by Stephanie McMahon’s [Black] autograph at a raw price of $398.18, followed by Alexa Bliss’s [Gold] autograph at $225.00 and [Bronze] at $140.00. Collectors looking for investment potential within this set should focus on these top-tier signed cards.

I’ve been tracking the prices of trading cards for years, and after meticulously analyzing sold listings and market data over the past month, one thing is crystal clear: the 2019 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set holds surprising depth for collectors seeking high-impact, signed cards. While some stars command significant premiums, there’s a defined hierarchy based on collector demand and the rarity of parallels. The top card, Stephanie McMahon’s [Black] autograph, stands far above the rest at $398.18 raw, indicating a strong market for established legends. Following closely, Alexa Bliss’s signatures, particularly her [Gold] variant at $225.00 and [Bronze] at $140.00, showcase her enduring popularity. This analysis aims to provide a clear roadmap for navigating the most valuable cards within this specific WWE release, highlighting where the real money and collector interest lie in 2026.

Last updated: June 2026.

In This Article

• The Top 10 2019 Topps Wwe Women’s Division Autographs Market Data

• Stephanie McMahon [Black] (A-SM): The Undisputed Queen of the Checklist

• Alexa Bliss [Gold] (A-AB): A Two-Time Contender for Top Spot

• Alexa Bliss [Bronze] (A-AB): The Value Proposition

• Mandy Rose [Gold] (A-MR): Rising Star Power

• Natalya [Black] (A-NT) & Lita [Black] (A-LT): Veterans Commanding Respect

• Io Shirai [Gold] (A-IS): A Glimpse into Future Value

• Kacy Catanzaro [Gold] (A-KC) & Taynara Conti [Gold] (A-TC): Emerging Talent

• The Grading ROI Play: Maximizing Value Through Professional Grading

• Buying Strategy for 2026: Navigating the 2019 Topps Wwe Women’s Division Autographs Market

The Top 10 2019 Topps Wwe Women’s Division Autographs Market Data

Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices. All figures as of June 2026.

Stephanie McMahon [Black] (A-SM): The Undisputed Queen of the Checklist

Topping the list of valuable 2019 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs is none other than the Chief Brand Officer herself, Stephanie McMahon. Her [Black] parallel autograph, card number A-SM, commands an impressive raw price of $398.18. This figure alone places her significantly above the rest of the checklist, underscoring her status as a foundational figure in WWE history and a perennial fan favorite. The absence of PSA 10 or PSA 9 data suggests that graded examples of this particular card are either exceedingly rare or have not yet reached the secondary market in sufficient numbers to establish a consistent grading tier price. For collectors, this card represents a significant investment, but also a potentially high reward, given Stephanie McMahon’s iconic status. Its placement at the apex of this list is a testament to her enduring appeal and market demand. This card is a must-have for serious collectors of WWE memorabilia and autographs, particularly those with an eye for historically significant figures within the company. Its raw value indicates a strong collector base willing to pay a premium for her signature on this officially licensed Topps product.

Buy Stephanie McMahon [Black] (A-SM) on eBay (active listings) Check Stephanie McMahon [Black] (A-SM) sold comps on eBay

Alexa Bliss [Gold] (A-AB): A Two-Time Contender for Top Spot

Alexa Bliss makes a powerful statement in the 2019 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set, securing not one, but two spots within the top rankings. Her [Gold] parallel autograph, card number A-AB, is the second most valuable card on our list, with a raw price of $225.00. This valuation speaks volumes about Bliss’s continued popularity and her significant impact on the women’s division throughout her career. Like Stephanie McMahon’s card, there’s no readily available PSA 10 or PSA 9 data, suggesting that graded versions are highly sought after and potentially scarce on the open market. The premium placed on her [Gold] parallel indicates a collector preference for rarer, more visually striking variations. For enthusiasts aiming to acquire a significant piece from this set, Alexa Bliss’s [Gold] autograph represents a prime target, offering a substantial market value and a strong connection to one of WWE’s most captivating performers. This card is a clear indicator of how current stars can drive value in the trading card market.

Buy Alexa Bliss [Gold] (A-AB) on eBay (active listings) Check Alexa Bliss [Gold] (A-AB) sold comps on eBay

Alexa Bliss [Bronze] (A-AB): The Value Proposition

Following her [Gold] parallel, Alexa Bliss’s [Bronze] autograph, also card number A-AB, lands at the third position with a raw price of $140.00. While it doesn’t reach the heights of her [Gold] variant or Stephanie McMahon’s card, it still represents a considerable market value and a more accessible entry point for collectors interested in acquiring an Alexa Bliss autograph from this set. The existence of a [Bronze] parallel alongside a [Gold] one highlights the tiered rarity within the set’s autograph offerings. Again, the lack of graded price points for PSA 10 or PSA 9 suggests that the market for graded Bliss autographs is still developing or that these versions are exceptionally rare. For collectors who appreciate Alexa Bliss’s contributions to WWE but might find the higher-tier autographs out of reach, her [Bronze] autograph offers a compelling alternative. It’s a card that balances desirability with a more attainable price point, making it an excellent target for building a strong collection. The consistent presence of Bliss on this list reinforces her standing as a premier draw in the women’s division.

Buy Alexa Bliss [Bronze] (A-AB) on eBay (active listings) Check Alexa Bliss [Bronze] (A-AB) sold comps on eBay

Mandy Rose [Gold] (A-MR): Rising Star Power

Mandy Rose’s [Gold] autograph, card number A-MR, enters the top 10 at the fourth spot with a raw price of $119.99. This valuation positions her as a significant player within the 2019 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set, particularly among those stars who have achieved considerable popularity and recognition in recent years. Her presence this high on the list indicates strong collector demand, likely driven by her memorable ring performances and prominent storylines. As with many of the top cards in this checklist, there are no specific PSA 10 or PSA 9 median prices recorded, suggesting that graded examples of her [Gold] autograph are either scarce or still establishing a consistent market presence. For collectors looking to invest in current WWE talent with a proven track record and a dedicated fanbase, Mandy Rose’s [Gold] autograph presents a compelling opportunity. It signifies a card with strong existing value and potential for future appreciation as her career continues to evolve. This card is a testament to the power of current stars to drive hobby interest.

Buy Mandy Rose [Gold] (A-MR) on eBay (active listings) Check Mandy Rose [Gold] (A-MR) sold comps on eBay

Natalya [Black] (A-NT) & Lita [Black] (A-LT): Veterans Commanding Respect

The veteran presence on this list is strong, with both Natalya and Lita occupying the fifth and sixth spots, respectively, each with their [Black] parallel autographs valued at a raw price of $100.00. This shared valuation indicates that both established superstars command a similar level of collector interest and market value within the 2019 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set. Natalya, known for her longevity and technical prowess, and Lita, a trailblazer and Hall of Famer, both bring a rich history and a dedicated fanbase that translates into consistent demand for their memorabilia. The lack of graded price data for these specific cards suggests a healthy raw market, where collectors are actively pursuing these signed cards in their ungraded state. For those seeking autographs from true legends of women’s wrestling, these [Black] parallels offer an accessible yet valuable addition to any collection, representing a piece of WWE history signed by two of its most iconic figures. Their consistent value reinforces their status as important figures in women’s wrestling.

Buy Natalya [Black] (A-NT) on eBay (active listings) Check Natalya [Black] (A-NT) sold comps on eBay Buy Lita [Black] (A-LT) on eBay (active listings) Check Lita [Black] (A-LT) sold comps on eBay

Io Shirai [Gold] (A-IS): A Glimpse into Future Value

Io Shirai’s [Gold] autograph, card number A-IS, clinches the seventh position with a raw price of $100.00, placing her in a significant tier with other high-value cards from the 2019 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set. Shirai, a highly acclaimed performer known for her aerial maneuvers and impressive in-ring skills, has built a substantial following among wrestling enthusiasts. Her presence this high on the list, sharing a valuation with established veterans, signals a strong appreciation for her talent and potential future impact in the wrestling world. The absence of specific graded pricing data indicates that the market for graded Io Shirai autographs from this set is still emerging. For collectors who recognize her exceptional talent and anticipate continued success, her [Gold] autograph represents an excellent opportunity to acquire a card with significant current value and promising future potential. It’s a card that speaks to the evolving landscape of wrestling fandom and its translation into the collectibles market.

Buy Io Shirai [Gold] (A-IS) on eBay (active listings) Check Io Shirai [Gold] (A-IS) sold comps on eBay

Kacy Catanzaro [Gold] (A-KC) & Taynara Conti [Gold] (A-TC): Emerging Talent

Rounding out the top 10 are Kacy Catanzaro and Taynara Conti, each with their [Gold] parallel autographs. Kacy Catanzaro’s [Gold] autograph (A-KC) sits at number eight with a raw price of $99.99, just shy of the $100 mark, while Taynara Conti’s [Gold] autograph (A-TC) follows at number nine with a raw price of $95.75. These valuations, while lower than the top-tier stars, still indicate a healthy demand and collector interest in these athletes within the 2019 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set. Both Catanzaro and Conti have carved out niches for themselves and possess dedicated fan bases. The fact that their [Gold] parallels are commanding prices in the high $90s demonstrates their growing significance in the women’s division and the hobby. As with other cards in this range, specific PSA 10 or PSA 9 data is not readily available, suggesting a focus on the raw card market. These cards represent opportunities for collectors to invest in rising talent with established autograph value. They are excellent examples of how consistent performance can drive card prices.

Buy Kacy Catanzaro [Gold] (A-KC) on eBay (active listings) Check Kacy Catanzaro [Gold] (A-KC) sold comps on eBay Buy Taynara Conti [Gold] (A-TC) on eBay (active listings) Check Taynara Conti [Gold] (A-TC) sold comps on eBay

The Grading ROI Play: Maximizing Value Through Professional Grading

While the 2019 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set presents a strong raw market, understanding the potential for profit through professional grading is crucial for collectors looking to maximize their investment. Of the cards listed with available grading data, Alexa Bliss’s base autograph (A-AB) stands out with a listed Grading ROI of 4.2%. This means that, based on current market data, acquiring this raw card at $90.00 and grading it could yield a profit of approximately $4.62 if it achieves a PSA 10 grade and sells at its median price of $137.50.

Let’s break down the math for this specific scenario. The raw price is $90.00, and the PSA 10 median price is $137.50. The profit, before factoring in grading costs, would be $137.50 - $90.00 = $47.50. If we conservatively estimate grading costs at $20 per card (this can vary widely based on turnaround time and service level), the net profit would be $47.50 - $20.00 = $27.50. This translates to a 4.2% ROI on the initial investment.

While a 4.2% ROI might seem modest, it’s important to remember that this is based on a single data point for a raw card and a graded median. The actual ROI can fluctuate significantly based on the condition of the raw card (centering, corners, edges, surface) and the demand for PSA 10 graded versions at any given moment. For cards with higher raw prices or significantly larger gaps between raw and PSA 10 values, the potential for profit through grading can be much more substantial. Unfortunately, the majority of the top-tier cards in this specific set lack PSA 10 data, making a direct ROI calculation impossible. This scarcity of graded data suggests that either graded examples are rare or the market is still developing for these high-value autographs, presenting a potential opportunity for early graders who can accurately assess card condition. For collectors considering grading, thorough research into the cost of grading services and the historical sales of graded counterparts is paramount.

Buying Strategy for 2026: Navigating the 2019 Topps Wwe Women’s Division Autographs Market

Pro Tip: Given the limited graded data for many of the top-tier autographs in the 2019 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set, raw card purchases are currently the most practical approach. Focus on identifying cards with excellent centering and minimal surface wear. If you’re looking to grade, prioritize cards where the raw price represents a significant discount to the potential PSA 10 value, and where the player’s popularity and career trajectory suggest sustained demand. The absence of comprehensive graded price points for cards like Stephanie McMahon’s [Black] autograph could indicate either scarcity of graded copies or an underdeveloped graded market, both of which present potential opportunities for savvy collectors.

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes the 2019 Topps Wwe Women’s Division Autographs cards valuable?

The value of these cards is primarily driven by the popularity of the WWE Superstars featured, the rarity of their autographs (especially with different parallel colors like Black and Gold), and their status as officially licensed Topps products. Iconic wrestlers like Stephanie McMahon and Alexa Bliss command higher prices due to their historical significance and strong fan bases.

Is grading these cards worthwhile in 2026?

For cards with available PSA 10 data, like the base Alexa Bliss autograph ($137.50 median), grading can be worthwhile if the raw card is acquired at a lower price, offering a positive Grading ROI (4.2% for this card). However, for many of the top cards in this set, such as Stephanie McMahon’s [Black] autograph, there is no PSA 10 data, suggesting either rarity or an underdeveloped graded market, which presents a speculative opportunity.

Where can I find the best prices for these cards?

Verified eBay sold comps and PriceCharting data, as utilized by What The Slab, are the most reliable sources for determining current market values. For purchasing, actively monitoring eBay for active listings and sold auctions will provide the most up-to-date pricing information.

How do parallels affect the value of these autographs?

Parallels significantly impact value. For example, Alexa Bliss’s [Gold] autograph is valued at $225.00 raw, while her [Bronze] is $140.00, and her base autograph is $90.00 raw and $137.50 in PSA 10. Rarer parallels like Black and Gold generally command higher prices than base versions, reflecting their limited availability.

Which wrestlers from this set have the most potential for future value increase?

Wrestlers with consistent in-ring performance, compelling storylines, and growing fan bases, such as Io Shirai, Mandy Rose, Kacy Catanzaro, and Taynara Conti, have strong potential for future value appreciation. Their current raw prices, while lower than legends, reflect an emerging market that could see significant growth.

Are there any graded rarity indicators for the top 2019 Topps Wwe Women’s Division Autographs?

Currently, the data shows a lack of PSA 10 or PSA 9 median prices for many of the highest-valued cards, including Stephanie McMahon’s [Black] and Alexa Bliss’s [Gold] autographs. This scarcity of graded examples suggests a premium might be placed on these cards if they appear graded, but it also means the market is still establishing definitive graded values.

The 2019 Topps WWE Women’s Division Autographs set offers a fascinating snapshot of both legendary figures and rising stars within WWE, with their signed cards representing significant collectibles. For those looking to build a portfolio of wrestling memorabilia, focusing on the top-tier autographs like Stephanie McMahon’s [Black] at $398.18 raw or Alexa Bliss’s [Gold] at $225.00 raw provides a solid foundation. Even as the market evolves, these cards are anchored by the enduring appeal of the Superstars they represent. To further expand your collection with other significant wrestling releases, be sure to explore our guides on 2025 SkyBox Metal Universe AEW Checklist and 2025 Topps Chrome WWE Checklist. For advice on protecting your valuable investments, check out our Best Toploaders for Sports Cards 2026 guide.