PSA vs BGS vs CGC for Gastly #177 Illustration Rare Pokemon Temporal Forces: Which Pays Most in 2026?
This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Everyone tells you to grade Gastly #177. The 90-day comps say the opposite — and here’s exactly why. For the Gastly #177 Illustration Rare from the Pokemon Temporal Forces set, the data might surprise you. While many jump straight to assuming a PSA 10 is the golden ticket, a deeper dive into recent sales reveals a more nuanced picture. This isn’t just about chasing the highest grade; it’s about understanding which grading company’s top tier actually commands the most value today. We’re looking at the raw median price for Gastly #177 sitting at $108.63. Now, let’s see how the top grades from PSA and CGC stack up against that. PSA 10 of Gastly trades at $630.00; CGC 10 at $171.30. Here’s which one to send.
-
The Price Data
-
Cost & Turnaround Comparison
-
The ROI Math for Each Grader
-
Which Grader Should You Choose for THIS Card?
-
When to Use Each Grader in General
-
Where to Source This Card
-
Frequently Asked Questions
The Price Data
When it comes to flipping graded cards, understanding the current market value is paramount. For the Gastly #177 Illustration Rare from Pokemon Temporal Forces, here are the latest 90-day sold comps to give you the clearest picture of what collectors are actually paying. The raw median for this sought-after card sits at a respectable $108.63. This is our baseline, the price of an ungraded, raw copy plucked straight from a pack or acquired from a dealer. Now, let’s see how those top-tier graded examples perform against this.
| Grader | Top Grade | Median Sold | Transactions | Premium vs Raw |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PSA | 10 | $630.00 | 26 | 479.6% |
| CGC | 10 | $171.30 | 20 | 57.7% |
Data source: eBay 90-day sold comps, June 2026
As you can see, the premium commanded by a PSA 10 Gastly #177 is substantial, nearly quintupling the raw median price. CGC 10, while still offering a solid return, shows a much more modest premium. This disparity is crucial when deciding where to send your valuable cards.
Cost & Turnaround Comparison
Beyond just the potential resale value, the cost of grading and the time it takes to get your cards back are significant factors in the profit equation. Sending a card to a grading company isn’t just about the potential payout; it’s also an investment in fees and patience. For collectors looking to maximize their return on investment (ROI), understanding these operational costs is just as vital as knowing the market price of a graded slab. Here’s a breakdown of current grading fees and posted turnaround times as of October 12, 2026.
| Grader | Tier for This Card | Fee per Card | Max Declared Value | Posted Turnaround |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PSA | Standard | $59.99 | $1,000 | 90-100 business days |
| BGS | Express (subgrades included) | $79.95 | Not published | 15 business days |
| CGC | Economy | $20.00 | $1,000 | 90 working days |
Note: Fees and turnaround times as posted on each grader’s own site on October 12, 2026, for the cheapest open single-card tier that covers this card’s value. PSA’s Value tiers (Value Bulk, Value, Value Plus and Value Max) have been paused since June 2, 2026. Beckett has paused its Base and Standard tiers, so Express is the only open BGS tier. CGC’s Bulk tier requires a 25-card minimum, so it is not used for single-card math.
For Gastly #177, which is a newer, highly desirable Illustration Rare from Temporal Forces, the card’s graded value keeps it in each grader’s entry tier. CGC’s Economy tier is the cheapest at $20.00, but its posted turnaround is 90 working days. PSA’s Value tiers have been paused since June 2, 2026, so its cheapest open tier is Standard at $59.99, posted at 90-100 business days. BGS, while not having direct sales data for a Gem Mint 9.5 in our dataset for Gastly #177, currently offers only its Express tier at $79.95 (subgrades included, posted at 15 business days), since Beckett has paused its Base and Standard tiers.
| Grade | Sold median | Tier & fee | Turnaround | Profit | ROI |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PSA 10 | $630 | Standard $59.99 | 90-100 business days | $372.50 | 220.9% |
| CGC 10 | $171 | Economy $20.00 | 90 working days | $14.57 | 11.3% |
Fees from each grader's own site, checked Oct 12, 2026. PSA's Value tiers are paused. Beckett is taking Express submissions only. eBay trading-card fee: 13.25% up to $7,500, 2.35% above, plus $0.40 per order. Shipping is an estimate. Prices are recent sold medians. The tier is set by the card's value; PSA publishes no fee above $10,000.
The ROI Math for Each Grader
When it comes to flipping graded cards, the ultimate goal for many is to achieve the highest possible return on investment (ROI). This means calculating not just the selling price of the graded card, but also factoring in the cost of acquiring the raw card, the grading fees, and the associated selling expenses like eBay fees and shipping. The numbers below for Gastly #177 use the median sold prices and estimated costs to show which grading company truly offers the best financial outcome in 2026.
PSA 10 ROI Analysis
-
Raw Cost: $108.63
-
Grading Fee (PSA Standard, the cheapest open tier for a $630.00 card): $59.99
-
eBay Fee (13.25% of $630.00 + $0.40 per order): $83.88
-
Shipping to Buyer (estimate): $5.00
-
Total Cost: $108.63 + $59.99 = $168.62
-
Net Sale Proceeds: $630.00 - $83.88 - $5.00 = $541.12
-
Net Expected Profit: $541.12 - $168.62 = $372.50
-
Expected ROI: 220.9%
-
Break-even Raw Price: $481.13
The PSA 10 offers a compelling profit margin. The significant premium over raw, even after accounting for costs, makes it a strong contender.
CGC 10 ROI Analysis
-
Raw Cost: $108.63
-
Grading Fee (CGC Economy, the cheapest single-card tier for a $171.30 card): $20.00
-
eBay Fee (13.25% of $171.30 + $0.40 per order): $23.10
-
Shipping to Buyer (estimate): $5.00
-
Total Cost: $108.63 + $20.00 = $128.63
-
Net Sale Proceeds: $171.30 - $23.10 - $5.00 = $143.20
-
Net Expected Profit: $143.20 - $128.63 = $14.57
-
Expected ROI: 11.3%
-
Break-even Raw Price: $123.20
This is where the data gets interesting. While CGC 10s are selling, the premium over raw is so modest that the profit, after all expenses, is only $14.57 (ROI 11.3%), even with CGC’s lower $20.00 fee. eBay fees, shipping and the raw card cost eat up most of the potential gains.
Winner on ROI: PSA 10.
The numbers clearly indicate that for Gastly #177, PSA 10 is the significantly more profitable grade to target based on current market data. The astronomical premium PSA 10s command over the raw price, even after factoring in grading fees and selling costs, dwarfs the minimal gains seen with a CGC 10.
Which Grader Should You Choose for THIS Card?
Based on the 90-day sold comps and the ROI calculations, the choice is unequivocally PSA for Gastly #177 if your primary goal is profit. The market clearly rewards a PSA 10 for this Illustration Rare with a significant multiplier over its raw value. With a median PSA 10 price of $630.00 against a raw median of $108.63, the profit potential is substantial, yielding an estimated profit of $372.50 and an ROI of 220.9% at PSA’s cheapest open tier. This is the kind of margin that collectors actively seeking to capitalize on the graded card market are looking for.
While CGC offers a lower entry price ($20.00 Economy), its premium for Gastly #177 is simply not enough to compete when aiming for maximum financial return. The median CGC 10 price of $171.30, while higher than raw, leaves a profit of only $14.57 after the grading fee and selling expenses, an ROI of 11.3%, against $372.50 for a PSA 10. The data suggests that a CGC 10 of this card is more of a thin-margin proposition or a personal collection piece rather than a strong flip.
Edge cases where another grader might win:
-
Personal Collection: If you are a fan of Gastly and simply want the card slabbed, CGC’s lower cost might be appealing for personal display.
-
Bulk Submissions for Personal Collection: If you have a large number of Gastly #177 cards and are just looking to slab them for protection or to fill out a binder, a bulk submission to CGC could be cost-effective.
-
Future Market Shifts: While current data favors PSA, markets can change. If CGC starts seeing increased demand for their top grades on Illustration Rares or if PSA’s pop count for Gastly #177 becomes excessively high, the landscape could shift. However, based on today’s data, PSA is the clear winner for profit.
When to Use Each Grader in General
While our analysis for Gastly #177 leans heavily towards PSA for profit, it’s important to remember that each grading company has its strengths and is better suited for different types of cards and collector goals.
-
PSA: Generally the undisputed king for modern and vintage mainstream collectibles, especially Pokémon and sports cards. Their slabs have the highest resale ceiling and are most widely recognized by the general collecting public. If you’re chasing the highest potential value on a popular card, PSA is often the go-to.
-
BGS: Traditionally strong in the sports card market, BGS (Beckett) is known for its meticulous grading and the highly sought-after “Black Label” Pristine 10. They also provide subgrades, which can be a major draw for collectors who analyze card condition in extreme detail. BGS is often preferred for vintage cards where the subgrades can really tell a story about a card’s history and preservation.
-
CGC: Has rapidly become a dominant force in the TCG space, including Pokémon. They are known for their competitive pricing, fast turnaround times, and excellent grading accuracy for trading cards. CGC is an excellent choice for bulk submissions, modern TCGs, and for collectors who value speed and cost-effectiveness without sacrificing quality.
-
SGC: While primarily known for its strong presence in vintage sports cards with its iconic tuxedo-style slabs and a dedicated following, SGC is also expanding its reach into TCGs. For collectors who appreciate the aesthetic and heritage of SGC, it can be a viable option for Pokémon cards as well, particularly if the card is older or if the collector prefers their slab design.
Where to Source This Card
If you’re looking to get your hands on Gastly #177, whether to submit for grading or to add to your personal collection, there are a few key places to check. A combination of online marketplaces and dedicated trading card sites offers the best chance of finding what you need.
For those ready to grade and seeking the best potential returns, checking existing graded copies is a smart move. You can Check active PSA-graded listings on eBay to see what PSA 10s are currently available and at what price points. This will give you real-time market data and potentially a slab to flip.
If you’re looking to acquire raw copies to grade yourself, or simply to compare prices of ungraded cards, TCGPlayer is an excellent resource. You can Browse raw copies on TCGPlayer to find a wide selection of raw Gastly #177 cards from various sellers, allowing you to pick the best condition and price for your needs. Remember, the condition of your raw card is crucial if you’re aiming for a high grade like a PSA 10.
Pro Tip: When buying raw cards with the intention of grading, always look for cards with strong centering, sharp corners, and minimal surface defects like scratches or print lines. Even minor flaws can prevent a perfect 10 grade. For Gastly #177, pay close attention to the border consistency and the crispness of the artwork.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the current market value for a PSA 10 Gastly #177 Illustration Rare?
As of June 2026, the median sold price for a PSA 10 Gastly #177 Illustration Rare from the Pokemon Temporal Forces set is approximately $630.00, based on 90-day eBay sold comps. This represents a significant premium of nearly 480% over the raw card’s median price of $108.63.
Is grading Gastly #177 with CGC profitable in 2026?
Based on current data, grading Gastly #177 with CGC for profit is not highly recommended. The median CGC 10 price is $171.30, which offers only a marginal increase over the raw card price. After CGC’s $20.00 Economy fee, eBay fees and an estimated $5.00 for shipping, the net profit is $14.57, an ROI of 11.3%, far below the $372.50 a PSA 10 returns.
Which grader offers the best return on investment for Gastly #177?
For Gastly #177 Illustration Rare from Pokemon Temporal Forces, PSA 10 offers the best return on investment. Our analysis shows an estimated ROI of 220.9% for a PSA 10, significantly outperforming CGC 10. This is driven by the substantial market premium PSA 10s command.
Should I grade my Gastly #177 if it’s not a PSA 10?
If your Gastly #177 is not expected to grade a PSA 10, the profitability diminishes significantly. A PSA 9 of Gastly #177 currently sells for a median of $120.00, only a small premium over the raw card, and after PSA’s $59.99 Standard fee, eBay fees and an estimated $5.00 for shipping it loses $69.92 (ROI -41.5%). Grading a copy that is unlikely to reach a PSA 10 only makes sense for a personal collection.
How long does it take to get cards graded by PSA and CGC?
Turnaround depends on the tier. As of October 12, 2026, PSA’s cheapest open tier (Standard, $59.99) is posted at 90-100 business days and CGC’s Economy tier ($20.00) at 90 working days. Faster tiers cost more: CGC Standard ($55.00) is posted at 10 working days and PSA Express ($199.00) at 20-30 business days. These are posted estimates and can fluctuate based on submission volume.
What is the raw median price for Gastly #177?
The raw median price for Gastly #177 from the Pokemon Temporal Forces set is $108.63, according to 90-day sold comps in June 2026. This figure is essential for calculating the potential profit and ROI when considering grading.
The world of Pokémon card grading is dynamic, and staying informed with up-to-date market data is crucial for making smart decisions. For Gastly #177 Illustration Rare, the current trend strongly favors PSA for those looking to maximize their profits. However, remember that grading is also about personal collecting goals, and sometimes the aesthetic of a CGC slab or the subgrades from BGS might be more appealing for your collection. No matter your chosen path, understanding the nuances of each grading company and the specific market performance of your cards is key. For more insights into building and managing your collection, be sure to check out our comprehensive card grading guides and dive deeper into the exciting world of Pokémon cards.