×

Best Twilight Masquerade Pokemon Cards Under $25 (2026 Budget Guide)

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The Twilight Masquerade set offers a compelling entry point for collectors on a budget, with several standout cards available for under $25. For instance, the Teal Mask Ogerpon [EB Games] sold for $22.38, demonstrating significant collector interest even at the higher end of this budget. Examining the market reveals a number of accessible cards with strong artistic appeal and potential for future growth.

Last week someone paid $22.38 for a single Teal Mask Ogerpon [EB Games] card on eBay. That sale tells us something specific about where this market is heading. The Twilight Masquerade set is proving to be a fertile ground for budget-conscious collectors, offering a wealth of desirable cards that don’t break the bank. This guide dives deep into the best picks available for under $25, leveraging verified eBay sold comps and PriceCharting data. We’ll explore which cards offer immediate visual appeal, which have potential for future appreciation, and how to navigate the set without overspending. For $25 or less, you can still pick up 10 legitimate Twilight Masquerade cards — and a few of them are set up to move once the chase cards price out. Last updated: June 2026.

In This Article

• The Under-$25 Picks

• How Far Does $100 Stretch?

• What to SKIP at This Price Point

• Frequently Asked Questions

The Under-$25 Picks

Here’s a breakdown of the most compelling Twilight Masquerade cards available for under $25, based on current market data. This table provides a quick overview, but we’ll dive deeper into each pick below.

Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices. All figures as of June 2026.

1. Teal Mask Ogerpon [EB Games] (24)

The Teal Mask Ogerpon card is a prime example of how exclusive variants can command attention, even within a budget-friendly range. This specific EB Games exclusive version was selling for a solid $22.38. While raw, its immediate appeal lies in its association with one of the set’s most prominent and popular Pokémon. Ogerpon, in its various forms, is a central figure in the Scarlet & Violet era, making any of its cards a target for collectors focusing on that narrative. The EB Games exclusivity adds another layer of desirability, often translating to higher demand among those looking to complete specific sub-collections or acquire unique regional variants. For collectors who appreciate strong character focus and are building out their Scarlet & Violet collection, this Ogerpon is a high-priority target. It represents a significant portion of the $25 budget, but the unique art and promotional aspect justify the cost for dedicated fans of the game’s lore.

Buy Teal Mask Ogerpon [EB Games] on eBay

2. Carmine [Regional Championship] (145)

Carmine is a character who has garnered significant attention, and her Regional Championship promotional card is a testament to that. This card, listed at $22.04, represents a slightly higher-end budget pick but offers substantial collector appeal. Regional Championship cards are inherently scarce due to their limited distribution through organized play events. This scarcity, combined with Carmine’s established popularity, makes it a sought-after piece for collectors who prioritize unique, hard-to-find cards tied to specific game lore or events. While not currently graded, its raw price indicates a healthy market demand. For collectors who are completing sets, focusing on character-specific collections, or simply looking for a visually striking card with a built-in scarcity factor, Carmine is an excellent acquisition within the $25 limit.

Buy Carmine [Regional Championship] on eBay

3. Unfair Stamp (165)

The Unfair Stamp card, clocking in at $13.50 raw with a PSA 10 median price of $20.50, presents an intriguing option for the savvy collector. This represents a modest 1.5x multiplier from raw to PSA 10, suggesting that while grading is an option, the raw card already holds significant value. The appeal of the Unfair Stamp lies in its unique “item card” status and its evocative artwork. These types of cards often offer a different collecting experience, focusing on the lore and mechanics of the game rather than just the Pokémon themselves. For collectors interested in trainer support cards or those who appreciate a more abstract or thematic art style, the Unfair Stamp is a strong contender. Its price point allows for flexibility within the $25 budget, and the potential for a modest profit margin through grading makes it attractive to those with an eye for upside.

Buy Unfair Stamp on eBay

4. Teal Mask Ogerpon EX [Prize Pack] (25)

The Teal Mask Ogerpon EX, priced at $11.40, is another essential piece for fans of the Ogerpon narrative within the Twilight Masquerade set. As an EX card, it offers a more powerful in-game presence which often translates to higher collector demand. This particular version, noted as a “Prize Pack” card, suggests a specific distribution method that can contribute to its collectibility. At just over $11, it’s an accessible way to acquire a key Pokémon from the set in its EX form. Collectors looking to build out their Ogerpon collection or acquire strong EX cards from the Scarlet & Violet era will find this card to be a valuable addition. Its price allows for it to be paired with other budget picks, making it a flexible choice for expanding a collection without a significant financial outlay.

Buy Teal Mask Ogerpon EX [Prize Pack] on eBay

5. Greninja EX [Prize Pack] (106)

Greninja is a perennial fan favorite in the Pokémon universe, and its EX card from Twilight Masquerade, priced at $11.33, is a fantastic budget pick. The “Prize Pack” designation hints at a specific, potentially limited, release channel, which can add to its long-term appeal. Greninja EX cards are consistently popular due to the Pokémon’s strong design and competitive history. This card offers a beautiful illustration that captures the essence of the beloved ninja frog. For collectors who are drawn to popular Pokémon, powerful EX mechanics, and visually striking artwork, this Greninja EX is an excellent choice. It sits comfortably within the $25 budget, allowing collectors to acquire a highly recognizable and desirable card without breaking the bank. It’s a solid pick for both new collectors and experienced players looking to add value to their binders.

Buy Greninja Ex [Prize Pack] on eBay

6. Secret Box (163)

The Secret Box card, available for $7.99 with a PSA 10 median of $17.00, offers a remarkable 2.1x multiplier, signaling strong potential for grading. This item card boasts unique artwork that sparks curiosity, a common trait among desirable non-Pokémon cards. For collectors who appreciate the thematic depth of item cards or are looking for pieces that stand out visually, the Secret Box is a compelling choice. The significant multiplier suggests that well-graded copies of this card could see a solid return on investment, making it attractive to both set completionists and those interested in the speculative grading market. Its sub-$10 price point makes it an easy addition to any budget collection, offering both aesthetic appeal and a clear avenue for potential profit through grading. It’s a prime example of how unique item cards can offer surprising value.

Buy Secret Box on eBay

7. Chandelure [Cosmos Holo] (38)

Chandelure, a Ghost/Fire-type Pokémon known for its elegant and somewhat eerie design, is featured here with a [Cosmos Holo] treatment, available for $7.18. The Cosmos Holo pattern is a distinct and desirable holographic effect that adds significant visual flair to any card. Chandelure itself has a strong following among fans who appreciate its unique typing and sophisticated aesthetic. This card offers a classic Pokémon with a special holographic finish at a very accessible price point. For collectors who are drawn to specific Pokémon, appreciate holographic variations, or are looking for visually appealing cards that don’t cost a premium, the Chandelure [Cosmos Holo] is an excellent pick. It’s a beautiful card that adds character and shine to any collection.

Buy Chandelure [Cosmos Holo] on eBay

8. Wellspring Mask Ogerpon EX [Prize Pack] (64)

The Wellspring Mask Ogerpon EX, priced at an attractive $5.11, provides another entry into the Ogerpon collection at a budget-friendly level. This EX variant continues to highlight the popularity of the Ogerpon character and its various masks. As a “Prize Pack” card, it may carry an additional element of rarity due to its distribution. For collectors keen on completing the full set of Ogerpon EX cards or simply seeking affordable representation of this key Pokémon from the Scarlet & Violet era, this card is an ideal choice. Its extremely low price point makes it one of the most accessible cards in the entire set, allowing collectors to snag a significant character’s EX form without impacting their budget. It’s a fantastic value pick for anyone interested in the set’s central figures.

Buy Wellspring Mask Ogerpon Ex [Prize Pack] on eBay

9. Luxray EX [Jumbo] (68)

While typically not a focus for budget guides due to size, the Luxray EX Jumbo card at $5.06 is an interesting outlier. Jumbo cards are usually intended for display rather than competitive play, appealing to a niche but dedicated collector base. Luxray is a popular Electric-type Pokémon with a strong visual presence, and an EX version further enhances its appeal. The fact that this Jumbo card is available for such a low price point makes it an easy pick for collectors who enjoy oversized cards or want to add a well-known Pokémon to their collection without spending much. It’s a unique item that breaks the mold of standard-sized cards and offers a different kind of collecting experience. For those who appreciate display pieces or the sheer presence of a Jumbo card, this Luxray EX is a steal.

Buy Luxray EX [Jumbo] on eBay

10. Hyper Aroma [Prize Pack] (152)

At the absolute bottom of our sub-$25 list, the Hyper Aroma [Prize Pack] card comes in at $4.83. This item card, designated as a “Prize Pack” release, offers a very low-cost entry into the Twilight Masquerade set’s aesthetic. While item cards might not have the immediate visual draw of Pokémon cards, they are crucial for set completion and can possess unique artistic qualities. For the collector who is determined to acquire every card from the set, or for those who appreciate the complete package of a set’s design language, Hyper Aroma provides an affordable way to do so. Its minimal price ensures that even the most constrained budget can accommodate its inclusion, making it a practical choice for building a comprehensive collection.

Buy Hyper Aroma [Prize Pack] on eBay

How Far Does $100 Stretch?

If you were to allocate $100 towards building a Twilight Masquerade collection focusing on these budget-friendly picks, you could assemble a surprisingly robust selection of cards. The goal here is to maximize variety and desirability within the given budget.

Starting with the most affordable options to build a foundation:

1. Hyper Aroma [Prize Pack] (152): $4.83 (Total: $4.83) - A simple, inexpensive way to start filling the binder.
2. Luxray EX [Jumbo] (68): $5.06 (Total: $9.89) - An unusual but fun pick for display collectors.
3. Wellspring Mask Ogerpon EX [Prize Pack] (64): $5.11 (Total: $15.00) - Key character, EX form, very affordable.
4. Chandelure [Cosmos Holo] (38): $7.18 (Total: $22.18) - Adds a classic Pokémon with a desirable holo finish.
5. Secret Box (163): $7.99 (Total: $30.17) - Great art and significant grading potential for its price.

With $69.83 remaining, we can now move into the mid-tier picks:

1. Greninja EX [Prize Pack] (106): $11.33 (Total: $41.50) - A popular Pokémon EX, always a solid addition.
2. Teal Mask Ogerpon EX [Prize Pack] (25): $11.40 (Total: $52.90) - Another Ogerpon EX to round out its presence.
3. Unfair Stamp (165): $13.50 (Total: $66.40) - Unique item card with PSA 10 potential.

Now, with $33.60 left, we can consider the higher-end, more exclusive picks to round out the collection:

1. Carmine [Regional Championship] (145): $22.04 (Total: $88.44) - A scarce, character-driven promotional card.
2. Teal Mask Ogerpon [EB Games] (24): $22.38 (Total: $110.82) - This pushes slightly over $100, but if we adjust, we could swap out Carmine for this, or pick 9 if Carmine is unavailable, and still get some change. Alternatively, if we strictly adhere to $100, we could skip Carmine and still get Teal Mask Ogerpon [EB Games] (24) for a total of $90.41, leaving $9.59 for another pick or saving it.

For roughly $100, a collector could acquire these ten cards: Hyper Aroma, Luxray EX Jumbo, Wellspring Mask Ogerpon EX, Chandelure Cosmos Holo, Secret Box, Greninja EX, Teal Mask Ogerpon EX, Unfair Stamp, and either Carmine or the EB Games Teal Mask Ogerpon variant. This selection offers a diverse mix of popular Pokémon, unique item cards, promotional items, and cards with grading upside, all within a budget that emphasizes accessibility and collection building. This approach ensures a strong foundation of desirable cards without compromising on quality or character representation.

What to SKIP at This Price Point

While the Twilight Masquerade set offers many affordable gems, some cards that might appear to be budget-friendly can still be traps if you’re not careful. The key is to look beyond just the raw price and consider the potential for growth, the rarity of the art, and the grading multiplier.

Cards to be particularly wary of in the under-$25 tier are those with very low PSA 10 multipliers, especially if they are not promotional or exclusive variants. For example, imagine a card priced at $20 raw. If its PSA 10 median is only $22, that’s a multiplier of just 1.1x. This minimal difference means that the cost of grading (shipping, grading fees, insurance) will likely eat up any potential profit and could even result in a loss. You might also find common holo rare Pokémon that, while technically under $25, have such a high population in PSA 10 that their value doesn’t significantly increase.

Another type of card to consider skipping are generic “Prize Pack” or common reverse holos that lack strong character appeal or unique artistic merit, unless they are needed for strict set completion. While cards like Hyper Aroma at $4.83 are excellent for filling out a binder, they generally won’t see appreciation. If your goal is investment or future resale, focusing on cards with unique art, exclusive origins (like promotional cards or certain store exclusives), or cards featuring highly popular Pokémon or characters is a much better strategy, even if they sit at the higher end of your $25 budget, such as the Teal Mask Ogerpon [EB Games] or Carmine [Regional Championship]. Always check the PSA 10 multiplier and consider the grading costs before making a purchase with investment in mind.

Pro Tip: For any card priced between $10 and $25, especially if you’re considering grading for potential profit, always check the raw population count on TCGPlayer and the PSA/CGC population reports. A low population for a specific Pokémon or character, combined with a high grade (like PSA 10), can indicate future scarcity and value. If the population for a card is already in the tens of thousands for PSA 10, it’s less likely to appreciate significantly unless it’s a truly iconic chase card.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Twilight Masquerade a good set for budget collectors in 2026?

Yes, Twilight Masquerade offers several compelling options for budget collectors in 2026. Cards like the Teal Mask Ogerpon [EB Games] at $22.38 and Carmine [Regional Championship] at $22.04 represent the higher end of the sub-$25 budget but provide significant character appeal and scarcity. Even more affordable picks like Secret Box ($7.99) with a 2.1x PSA 10 multiplier, and Wellspring Mask Ogerpon EX ($5.11) offer good value and collection-building potential.

Which cards from Twilight Masquerade offer the best potential for grading profit under $25?

The Secret Box (163) stands out with a raw price of $7.99 and a PSA 10 median of $17.00, showing a strong 2.1x multiplier. This suggests that a well-graded copy could yield a good return on investment relative to its purchase price. While less focused on profit, the Unfair Stamp (165) also has a healthy 1.5x multiplier from its $13.50 raw price to a $20.50 PSA 10 median.

Are there any exclusive or promotional cards from Twilight Masquerade worth buying under $25?

Absolutely. The Teal Mask Ogerpon [EB Games] at $22.38 and Carmine [Regional Championship] at $22.04 are prime examples of exclusive or promotional cards that hold significant collector value. These types of cards often have limited distribution, making them more sought after than their standard set counterparts, even within this budget range.

How does the price of a PSA 10 card compare to its raw price in Twilight Masquerade for budget picks?

For the cards listed under $25, the multiplier between raw and PSA 10 varies. The Secret Box shows the highest multiplier at 2.1x ($7.99 raw to $17.00 PSA 10). Unfair Stamp has a 1.5x multiplier ($13.50 raw to $20.50 PSA 10). Cards like the Teal Mask Ogerpon [EB Games] and Carmine [Regional Championship] are typically sold raw and lack established PSA 10 data, but their high raw prices indicate strong market demand.

Should I prioritize art or character popularity when buying Twilight Masquerade cards under $25?

Both are important considerations depending on your collecting goals. Cards like the Teal Mask Ogerpon [EB Games] ($22.38) and Carmine [Regional Championship] ($22.04) appeal due to strong character recognition and lore. Cards like the Secret Box ($7.99) and Chandelure [Cosmos Holo] ($7.18) offer compelling art that can stand on its own, making them attractive even if the character isn’t a top-tier favorite. For a balanced collection, aim for a mix of both.

Are the “Prize Pack” cards in Twilight Masquerade generally good value?

Yes, “Prize Pack” cards from Twilight Masquerade often represent good value, especially within the under-$25 market. Cards like the Teal Mask Ogerpon EX [Prize Pack] ($11.40) and Greninja EX [Prize Pack] ($11.33) are strong picks. Their designation suggests a specific distribution, which can add a layer of collectibility. They offer desirable Pokémon and EX mechanics at accessible price points, making them worthwhile additions for many collectors.

For collectors looking to dive into the world of Pokémon card collecting without a massive financial commitment, the Twilight Masquerade set offers a treasure trove of affordable options. By focusing on cards with strong character appeal, unique art, and strategic market advantages like exclusive variants or grading potential, you can build a valuable and visually stunning collection. Explore these budget-friendly picks and make your collection shine.

Continue building your knowledge base with our guides on PSA vs BGS vs CGC for Gastly #177 Illustration Rare Pokemon Temporal Forces: Which Pays Most in 2026? and discover the best organizational tools in our Best 12-pocket Binders for Pokemon Collectors (2026 Guide).