How to Submit Games to PSA 2026

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Submitting games to PSA in 2026 offers a clear path to asset protection and potential value enhancement, with top-tier graded NES titles like Stadium Events potentially reaching $60,000+ at PSA 10, and complete-in-box N64 staples like Super Mario 64 showing strong premiums over their loose counterparts. The key to a successful submission lies in strategic selection, meticulous preparation, and understanding PSA’s current grading standards to maximize your chances of achieving a high grade.

Most guides on submitting games to PSA are stuck in the past, failing to account for evolving market trends and PSA’s refined grading criteria for video games. In 2026, the approach needs to be data-driven, focusing on games with demonstrable aftermarket demand and rarity, coupled with an understanding of the nuances that differentiate a near-perfect game from a merely good one. This isn’t about blindly sending every old game you own; it’s about identifying the true gems that will resonate with collectors and command premium prices when professionally authenticated and graded. The landscape of retro game collecting has matured, and your submission strategy must evolve with it. Last updated 2026-05-22.

Why Grade Your Video Games in 2026?

The allure of grading video games in 2026 extends far beyond mere protection. For collectors and investors alike, a PSA-graded game represents a standardized measure of condition, rarity, and authenticity. This standardization significantly impacts market liquidity and potential resale value. Consider the Nintendo 64 market: a loose copy of WWF No Mercy might fetch $30-$40 on average, but a graded PSA 9 version can easily command upwards of $80-$100, and a coveted PSA 10 can push past $150, representing a substantial multiplier. This premium isn’t just about the sticker; it’s about the assurance of a pristine, expertly preserved piece of gaming history.

The data consistently shows that graded games, especially those in high grades (PSA 9 and PSA 10), command a significant market premium over their raw, unslabbed counterparts. This is particularly true for iconic titles from sought-after consoles like the NES, SNES, and Nintendo 64. For example, a sealed, mint condition copy of The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time for N64 is a grail for many, and a PSA 10 grade can add hundreds, if not thousands, to its already impressive value. The market has embraced third-party grading as a crucial factor in determining a game’s desirability and investment potential.

Understanding PSA’s Grading Standards for Video Games

PSA’s grading for video games is a meticulous process that evaluates several key aspects of the game package, including the cartridge, manual, and outer box (for CIB and sealed games). While PSA 10 “Gem Mint” is the ultimate goal, achieving it requires near-perfection across all facets of the game’s condition. This includes the condition of the cart itself (minimal to no scratches, clean label with no fading or peeling), the completeness and condition of the manual (no creases, tears, or heavy wear), and the integrity of the outer box (sharp corners, no significant crushing, fading, or tears, and a strong seal for sealed games).

Even seemingly minor cosmetic flaws can prevent a game from reaching a top grade. For instance, slight “whitening” on the edges of a game box, a common issue with older cardboard packaging, can knock a point off the overall grade. Similarly, a barely noticeable crease on the instruction manual or a slight lift on a cartridge label can mean the difference between a PSA 9 and a PSA 10. For sealed games, the integrity of the seal is paramount; any signs of tampering or re-sealing will result in a significantly lower grade, if graded at all. Understanding these granular details is critical for collectors aiming for the highest possible grades.

Step-by-Step: How to Submit Games to PSA

Submitting games to PSA can seem daunting, but by following a structured approach, you can ensure a smooth and successful process. Here’s a breakdown of the essential steps:

Step 1: Research and Select Your Games

Before you even think about packing a box, identify which games are worth submitting. Not every game will yield a positive return on your grading investment. Focus on:

• Key Titles: Games that are considered classics, system-sellers, or have significant historical importance (e.g., Super Mario Bros., The Legend of Zelda, Pokémon Red/Blue, Sonic the Hedgehog).

• Rarity: Games that had limited print runs or are difficult to find in good condition (e.g., Stadium Events for NES, EarthBound for SNES, special edition releases).

• Condition: Prioritize games that are already in exceptional condition. Games with significant damage, wear, or missing components are less likely to achieve high grades and may not be worth the submission cost.

• Market Demand: Check recent sales data (comps) on platforms like eBay, PriceCharting, and dedicated collector forums to see what graded versions of your target games are selling for. A high grade should significantly increase the game’s value beyond the grading fees and return shipping.

Step 2: Prepare Your Games Meticulously

This is arguably the most critical phase. The better you prepare your games, the higher your chances of achieving a top grade.

• Clean Everything: Gently clean the cartridge, manual, and box. For cartridges, use isopropyl alcohol (90% or higher) on a cotton swab to clean the exterior plastic and contacts (use a dedicated electronic cleaner for contacts if preferred, but be cautious). For manuals and boxes, use a soft, dry cloth. Avoid any harsh chemicals or excessive moisture, which can damage labels and artwork.

• Assess Condition Critically: Before submitting, perform your own thorough assessment. Look for:

• Cartridge: Scratches, scuffs, faded or peeling labels, damage to the plastic.

• Manual: Creases, tears, writing, water damage, yellowing, missing pages.

• Box: Dents, crushing, seam splits, tears, fading, water damage, punctures.

• Sealed Games: Condition of the box, integrity of the cellophane wrap, presence and condition of any promotional stickers or seals. Check for signs of resealing.

• Document Condition: Take high-resolution photos of each game from multiple angles, documenting any existing flaws. This serves as a reference and can be helpful if any disputes arise.

Step 3: Understand PSA’s Submission Options and Fees

PSA offers various submission tiers based on estimated value and desired turnaround time. For most retro games, you’ll likely use their standard grading service.

• Membership Levels: PSA has different membership tiers (General, Collector, Super Collector, etc.). Higher tiers often grant access to more competitive pricing and faster turnaround times. General submission is available to all, but often has longer wait times and potentially higher per-item costs.

• Service Levels and Pricing: PSA’s pricing is typically based on the declared value of the item. The higher the declared value, the more expensive the grading fee. For rare and high-value games, PSA offers “Declared Value” services. For more common or lower-value games, they have economy or standard tiers. Always check the official PSA website for the most current pricing and service options, as these can change. Expect to pay anywhere from $20 to $100+ per game, depending on the tier and declared value.

• Turnaround Times: Be prepared for potentially long turnaround times, especially for popular eras or during peak submission periods. PSA will provide estimated turnaround times for each service level, but these are not guarantees.

Step 4: Fill Out the Submission Form and Package Your Games

Once you’ve selected your games and understand the costs, it’s time to fill out the submission form.

• Online Submission Portal: PSA uses an online portal for submitting your orders. You’ll need to create an account, select your service level, and accurately declare the value of each item.

• Insurance: PSA offers insurance options during the submission process. Consider insuring your package for its full declared value.

• Secure Packaging: This is crucial to prevent damage during transit.

• Cartridges: Place each cartridge in a protective sleeve or baggie. You can use simple plastic bags or specialized game sleeves. Ensure the label is facing up and protected.

• CIB Games: For Complete-In-Box games, use archival-quality plastic cases or bags that fit the game box snugly without putting pressure on the seams. Consider adding extra padding around the box.

• Sealed Games: These require the most care. Use sturdy boxes and ample cushioning material (bubble wrap, packing peanuts, foam). Ensure the game box is centered and cannot shift during transit.

• Shipping Box: Use a strong, appropriately sized shipping box. Fill any voids with packing material to prevent movement. Do not overpack, as this can also cause damage.

• Shipping: Ship your package via a reputable carrier that offers tracking and insurance (e.g., USPS Priority Mail, FedEx, UPS). Always send your package to the correct PSA Submission Center address, as listed on their website.

Step 5: Track Your Submission and Receive Your Graded Games

After shipping your submission, you can track its status through the PSA online portal.

• Status Updates: PSA will provide updates on your submission’s progress, from initial receipt to grading and shipping.

• Receiving: Once graded and shipped back, inspect your returned games immediately for any damage that may have occurred during transit from PSA.

What to Avoid When Submitting Games to PSA

Even with the best intentions, certain common pitfalls can derail a submission. Awareness of these issues can save you time, money, and disappointment.

• Submitting Damaged or Incomplete Games: Sending in games with significant physical damage (large tears on boxes, heavy cart scratches, missing manuals) is rarely a good investment. PSA grades based on condition, and severe damage almost guarantees a low grade.

• Over-Declaring Value: While it’s important to insure your items, excessively over-declaring a game’s value can lead to higher grading fees without a corresponding increase in your potential return if the grade isn’t exceptional. Be realistic with your valuations.

• Poor Packaging: This is a cardinal sin. Games that arrive damaged due to inadequate packaging can be rejected outright or receive lower grades than their condition warrants. Invest in quality shipping supplies.

• Ignoring PSA’s Guidelines: PSA has specific guidelines for how items should be submitted. Failing to follow these, such as not properly filling out the submission form or attempting to submit items that PSA does not grade, can lead to delays or the return of your submission.

Comparing Grading Services: PSA vs. Others

While PSA is the dominant player in the video game grading market, other services like Beckett Grading Services (BGS) and CGC (Certified Guaranty Company) also exist. Each has its own grading scale, fee structure, and market perception.

For most retro video games, especially those from the 8-bit and 16-bit eras, PSA is typically the preferred choice due to its established market presence and the highest resale premiums it commands for top-graded items. However, if sub-grades and detailed condition breakdowns are important to you, BGS or CGC might be worth considering.

Pro Tip: Before submitting any valuable game, do a thorough “pre-grade” yourself. Compare your game to high-grade examples sold online. Be honest about any flaws, as PSA graders are trained to spot even minor imperfections. If you’re unsure about a game’s potential grade, it might be better to hold off or seek a second opinion from experienced collectors.

Popular Consoles and Games for Grading in 2026

Certain consoles and their flagship titles consistently perform well in the graded market. Focusing on these can increase your chances of a profitable submission.

• Nintendo Entertainment System (NES): Iconic titles like Super Mario Bros., The Legend of Zelda, and the exceedingly rare Stadium Events are prime candidates. Graded NES games, especially in complete-in-box (CIB) condition, command significant premiums. A PSA 9 CIB Stadium Events can reach astronomical figures, highlighting the demand for extreme rarity and condition.

• Super Nintendo Entertainment System (SNES): Games like Super Metroid, Chrono Trigger, and EarthBound are highly sought after. CIB SNES games in high grades are becoming increasingly scarce, driving up demand. A PSA 9 CIB EarthBound can fetch upwards of $1,000-$1,500, with PSA 10s commanding even more.

• Nintendo 64: Titles such as The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, Super Mario 64, and the WWF wrestling series (No Mercy, WrestleMania 2000) are popular. Graded N64 games, especially sealed or CIB, show strong appreciation. For instance, a PSA 9 CIB The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time often sells in the $200-$300 range, with PSA 10s tripling that.

• Sega Genesis: Core titles like Sonic the Hedgehog series, Phantasy Star, and Streets of Rage are good grading targets. CIB Genesis games, particularly those with clean labels and boxes, hold their value well when graded.

Affiliate Recommendations: Essential Gear for Submission Prep

To ensure your games are prepped and protected for their journey to PSA, having the right tools is essential.

For cleaning cartridges and contacts, a good quality IPA and cotton swabs are a must. Consider an electronic contact cleaner for optimal performance.

• For protecting cartridges before submission, archival-quality plastic sleeves are ideal. These prevent scratches and scuffs during transit.

• For CIB and sealed games, investing in Mylar bags or archival clamshells provides superior protection for the boxes. These add a layer of cushioning and prevent minor dents or tears.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I determine the declared value for my game submission to PSA?

The declared value should represent the current market value of your game in the grade you expect it to receive. Use recent sales data (comps) for PSA-graded copies of that game in similar condition. If you expect a PSA 10, declare a value consistent with PSA 10 sales. If you’re unsure, err on the side of caution or consult PSA’s value guides.

Can I submit a game with a damaged outer box to PSA?

PSA will grade games with some level of box wear, but significant damage like large tears, crushing, or seam splits will negatively impact the grade. For sealed games, damage to the box can also affect the overall grade significantly. It is often best to submit games that are in the best possible condition to maximize your grading potential.

What is the typical turnaround time for game grading with PSA?

Turnaround times vary greatly depending on the service level chosen, the declared value of the items, and PSA’s current submission volume. Economy services can take several months, while premium or expedited services may be faster but cost significantly more. Always check the PSA website for the most up-to-date estimated turnaround times.

Is it worth grading common, low-value games?

Generally, it is not financially advisable to grade common, low-value games unless they are in absolutely pristine, Gem Mint (PSA 10) condition and you are submitting a large batch to potentially offset costs. The grading fees and return shipping often exceed the market value of a graded common game, making it a poor investment unless you are targeting a specific set completion or personal collection goal.

What are PSA’s requirements for sealed game grading?

PSA grades sealed games based on the condition of the seal, the game’s internal contents (assessed through visual inspection of the exterior packaging), and the outer box. They will look for original factory seals and packaging. Any signs of tampering, resealing, or significant damage to the box or seals will be noted on the label and can result in a lower grade.

How do I check the pop report for my game before submitting?

You can check PSA’s Population Report (Pop Report) on their official website. Search for your specific game title and console. The Pop Report shows how many copies of that game have been graded by PSA and in what quantities for each grade. This data is invaluable for understanding the rarity of high grades and setting realistic expectations.

By understanding these nuances and approaching your submission strategy with care and diligence, you can navigate the process of submitting games to PSA in 2026 with confidence and aim to maximize the value and preservation of your treasured retro video games. For more on specific game consoles and their grading potential, explore our guide on Yoshi’s Story Nintendo 64: PSA Pop Report + Loose / CIB / Sealed Prices.