Verified comps. Grading math. No guesswork.
stay with me 31 psa pop report

Image sourced from eBay listings

Stay with Me #31 MTG Final Fantasy Through the Ages PSA + CGC Pop Report: Rarity vs Price 2026

Published 2026-11-11 · Updated 2026-11-11 · by Jason Trogdon
TCG Collectibles 5 min read
RAW $105PSA 10 $520MULTIPLIER 5.0×PRICES AS OF Nov 11, 2026

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

PSA has graded 156 copies of Stay with Me #31 from Final Fantasy Through the Ages at Gem Mint 10, out of 286 PSA-graded copies (320 across PSA and CGC). PriceCharting lists a PSA 10 at $520.25 and a raw copy at $104.91, 5.0x apart.

In This Article

The Population Report

PSA and CGC have graded 320 copies of Stay with Me #31 from Final Fantasy Through the Ages: 286 by PSA and 34 by CGC. The table lists every grade with a count, and PriceCharting’s listed price where it has one.

Grade PSA CGC Total PriceCharting Price
10 156 19 175 $520.25
9 97 12 109 $110.00
8.5 — 2 2 —
8 27 1 28 $82.50
7 2 — 2 —
6 3 — 3 —
4 1 — 1 —

320 total graded across PSA and CGC (286 PSA + 34 CGC). PriceCharting lists a PSA 10 at $520.25. CGC counts from CGC’s population report, Nov 11, 2026 (the 10 row adds Pristine 10 and Gem Mint 10).

156 of the 286 PSA copies (55%) are PSA 10, and PSA 9 and PSA 10 together make 253 (88%). CGC has 19 at grade 10 out of 34 (its 10 row adds Pristine 10 and Gem Mint 10). PriceCharting also lists a PSA 9 at $99.00 and a raw copy at $104.91.

Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices, and PriceCharting pop pages (PSA + CGC), plus PSA’s population report.

Reading the Scarcity Signal

With 156 PSA 10s, Stay with Me #31 sits in the scarce band on this site’s scale (50 to 199 PSA 10s). The PSA gem-mint rate is 55%: 156 of 286 PSA submissions came back a 10. Counting CGC’s grade-10 copies, 175 of 320 graded copies (55%) are a 10. Each new PSA 10 adds 0.6% to the PSA 10 supply.

Rarity vs Price

A PSA 10 Stay with Me #31 is listed at $520.25 against $104.91 raw, 5.0x the raw price. A PSA 9 is listed at $99.00, $5.91 below raw. The PSA 10 price is 5.3x the PSA 9 price.

Grading calculator
Fees checked Oct 12, 2026Prices as of Nov 11, 2026
Covers cards up to $1,000. Turnaround 90-100 business days.
$
Raw price: $105
$
Median: $520
$
Estimate
Profit
$281.02
Profit after all costs
170.4%
Return on cost
$385.93
Most you can pay raw
Where the sale price goes
Raw cost $104.91Grading fee $59.99eBay fee $69.33Shipping $5.00Profit $281.02
If it comes back a PSA 9 (at $110), you still paid the Standard fee: −$74.88.
156 of 286 PSA copies graded 1 to 10 are 10s (54.5%). That is the historical share across all submissions, not your odds.

Fees from each grader's own site, checked Oct 12, 2026. PSA's Value tiers are paused. Beckett is taking Express submissions only. eBay trading-card fee: 13.25% up to $7,500, 2.35% above, plus $0.40 per order. Shipping is an estimate. Prices are PriceCharting's listed prices or recent sold medians. The tier is set by the card's value; PSA publishes no fee above $10,000.

What the Pop Data Says About Grading New Copies

At 156 PSA 10s the grade is under this site’s 500-copy pop-saturation cutoff: a new PSA 10 adds 0.6% to the supply at the top grade. A card valued at $520.25 goes in at PSA’s Standard tier ($59.99, the cheapest open tier for that value; fees checked 2026-10-12). A PSA 10 sold on eBay at $520.25 nets $445.92 after the $69.33 eBay fee and $5.00 shipping. Against a total cost of $164.90 (raw $104.91 plus the $59.99 fee) that is a profit of $281.02 (170.4% on cost). Break-even is a PSA 10 sale of $196.31 at today’s raw price, or a raw price of $385.93 at today’s PSA 10 price. If the card comes back a PSA 9 and sells at $99.00, it nets $80.48 after the $13.52 eBay fee and shipping, a loss of $84.42 on the same $164.90 cost.

The Bottom Line

156 PSA 10s exist for Stay with Me #31 out of 286 PSA submissions, 320 graded copies across PSA and CGC. A PSA 10 lists at $520.25 and nets $445.92 after eBay fees and shipping; grading a $104.91 raw copy costs $164.90 all in. The numbers above are the whole picture this page has; what to do with them is the reader’s call.

Where to Buy

Graded copies of Stay with Me #31 trade on eBay; Check active graded listings on eBay shows what is listed now.

Raw copies are listed on TCGplayer: Browse raw copies on TCGPlayer.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many Stay with Me #31 cards have been graded PSA 10?

PSA has graded 156 copies of Stay with Me #31 at PSA 10, out of 286 PSA-graded copies (55%).

What is a PSA 10 Stay with Me #31 worth?

PriceCharting lists a PSA 10 Stay with Me #31 at $520.25 and a raw copy at $104.91.

What is the gem-mint rate for Stay with Me #31?

55% of PSA submissions came back a 10 (156 of 286). PSA 9 and 10 together are 88%.

What does it cost to grade a raw Stay with Me #31, and where is break-even?

Raw $104.91 plus PSA’s Standard fee of $59.99 is $164.90. A PSA 10 has to sell for $196.31 on eBay to cover that, the eBay fee and $5.00 shipping.

How many Stay with Me #31 cards has CGC graded?

CGC has graded 34 copies, 19 at grade 10.

Is Stay with Me #31 pop-saturated?

No. This site calls a grade pop-saturated at 500 PSA 10s; Stay with Me #31 has 156.

More on TCG Collectibles and card grading across the site. Related: Top 10 Most Valuable Series 5 Booster Cards (2026); Top 10 Most Valuable Wilds Unknown Cards (2026); Top 10 Most Valuable Championship Series Cards (2026).

Data: PSA population reports · PriceCharting · eBay sold listings. Analysis: What The Slab. How we get our numbers.

Price data, not financial advice. Past sales don't predict future value. We may earn a commission on eBay, TCGplayer and Amazon links.

Weekly graded sales report

Free weekly email. Unsubscribe anytime.

J

About Jason

Jason has been collecting cards since 1999 and retro video games since 2008. Based in the Southeast US. What The Slab cites real eBay sold comps, PriceCharting data, and PSA pop reports — no guesswork. Read more → · How we get our numbers