×

Image sourced from eBay listings

Is Carrying on His Will One Piece Worth Collecting? 2026 Investment Review

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The One Piece Carrying on His Will set presents a compelling, albeit specialized, collecting opportunity in 2026, with its top 8 chase cards currently valued between $663.87 and $8,955 raw. For collectors focused on high-grade investment, the Portgas.D.Ace [Red Manga] OP13-119 card shows the highest calculable grading ROI at 73.2%, making it the strongest candidate for grading and flipping.

Most TCG guides are wrong about which cards to grade — and the data proves it.

Verdict: WATCH. The One Piece Carrying on His Will set offers significant potential for collectors and investors alike, particularly for its high-impact chase cards. The top 8 cards alone represent a raw market value of $22,435, highlighting the set’s concentrated value. The Monkey.D.Luffy [Red Manga] OP13-118 card stands out with a raw price of $8,955 and a PSA 10 median of $30,000, a 3.4x multiplier; no grading ROI is given for it, because PSA publishes no grading fee for cards valued above $10,000. While the complete set’s value, factoring in commons and unlisted rarities, is likely 1.2x to 1.5x the sum of its top cards, the core appeal is undeniably in its elite few. This set warrants a cautious but optimistic approach, especially for those targeting high-grade specimens. Last updated: October 2026.

In This Article

• About Carrying on His Will

• The Top Chase Cards (ranked table)

• Monkey.D.Luffy [Red Manga] OP13-118

• Portgas.D.Ace [Red Manga] OP13-119

• Sabo [Red Manga] OP13-120

• Monkey.D.Luffy [Manga] OP13-118

• Shanks [Gold] OP09-004

• Portgas.D.Ace [Manga] OP13-119

• Shanks [Silver] OP09-004

• Sabo [Manga] OP13-120

• Investment Analysis

• Worth Collecting? The Verdict

• Frequently Asked Questions

About Carrying on His Will

The One Piece Carrying on His Will set emerged in 2026, quickly becoming a focal point for dedicated collectors within the TCG community. While the exact card count for the full set remains undisclosed, the established chase cards alone demonstrate a significant demand and a clear hierarchy of value, particularly among its manga-variant printings and unique color-coded rarities. This set taps into the enduring popularity of the One Piece franchise, a narrative that has captivated audiences globally for decades and translated into a fervent collector base for its associated merchandise, including trading cards.

The scarcity and desirability of certain cards within the Carrying on His Will set are directly tied to iconic characters and their narrative significance. The “Red Manga” variants, for instance, command premium prices, signaling a strong collector preference for these highly sought-after, visually distinct versions. This focus on specific, high-impact cards means that while the overall set might not be as broad in its appeal as some mainstream releases, its peak value is concentrated in a select few, making targeted acquisition a key strategy for collectors and investors looking to capitalize on the set’s strongest assets.

The Top Chase Cards (ranked table)

Grading ROI assumes a PSA 10, graded at PSA’s cheapest open tier for the card’s value (Standard $59.99 up to $1,000; PSA’s Value tiers are paused; fees checked October 12, 2026), sold on eBay (13.25% fee + $0.40) with an estimated $5 shipping. No figure is given above $10,000, where PSA publishes no fee.

Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices, and PSA public-API pop reports. All figures as of October 2026.

1. Monkey.D.Luffy [Red Manga] OP13-118

The Monkey.D.Luffy [Red Manga] OP13-118 card stands as the undisputed crown jewel of the Carrying on His Will set. With a raw price of $8,955, its value is substantial, but the real story is in its graded potential. A PSA 10 grade commands a median of $30,000, representing a 3.4x multiplier from the raw price. The uplift is impressive, but no grading ROI is given for this card: at a $30,000 value it sits above $10,000, where PSA publishes no grading fee, so the full cost of submitting a raw copy cannot be priced.

Buy Monkey.D.Luffy [Red Manga] OP13-118 on TCGPlayer Buy Monkey.D.Luffy [Red Manga] OP13-118 on eBay

2. Portgas.D.Ace [Red Manga] OP13-119

Following closely behind Luffy is the Portgas.D.Ace [Red Manga] OP13-119 card. This card holds significant appeal, with a raw price of $3,804 and a PSA 10 median price of $8,650. The multiplier here is 2.3x, which, while lower than Luffy’s top-tier figure, still presents a strong opportunity. The grading ROI for this card sits at 73.2%, indicating that submitting raw copies for grading is a financially sound decision for those looking to maximize returns. Its position as the second-highest valued card underscores the desirability of the “Red Manga” variants within this set.

Buy Portgas.D.Ace [Red Manga] OP13-119 on TCGPlayer Buy Portgas.D.Ace [Red Manga] OP13-119 on eBay

3. Sabo [Red Manga] OP13-120

The Sabo [Red Manga] OP13-120 card continues the trend of high value associated with the “Red Manga” variants. Currently priced at $3,500 raw, its PSA 10 median reaches $7,300, marking a 2.1x multiplier. The grading ROI stands at a healthy 54.4%. This means that while it might not offer the explosive returns of the top two cards, it still provides a solid investment avenue for collectors willing to pursue gem-mint grades. The consistent strong performance of these three cards highlights a clear preference within the market for this specific rarity tier and character representation.

Buy Sabo [Red Manga] OP13-120 on TCGPlayer Buy Sabo [Red Manga] OP13-120 on eBay

4. Monkey.D.Luffy [Manga] OP13-118

Moving away from the “Red Manga” variants, the Monkey.D.Luffy [Manga] OP13-118 card represents a slightly more accessible entry point into high-value collecting for this set. With a raw price of $2,099 and a PSA 10 median of $3,780, it offers a 1.8x multiplier. The grading ROI here is 33.7%, which is still a respectable figure. This card demonstrates that even within the “Manga” category, Luffy’s presence ensures significant market demand. It’s a good option for collectors who want a high-profile character card without the absolute top-tier investment required for its “Red Manga” counterpart.

Buy Monkey.D.Luffy [Manga] OP13-118 on TCGPlayer Buy Monkey.D.Luffy [Manga] OP13-118 on eBay

5. Shanks [Gold] OP09-004

Shanks, a fan-favorite character, also features prominently with his [Gold] variant, OP09-004. This card is priced at $1,492 raw, with a PSA 10 median of $2,332. The multiplier is 1.6x, and the grading ROI is 19.3%. While this ROI is lower than the manga variants, it signifies a stable, if less aggressive, investment potential. The “Gold” rarity suggests a visually appealing card with inherent desirability, and its presence in the top chase list indicates a strong, consistent demand from collectors who value character recognition and established rarity tiers.

Buy Shanks [Gold] OP09-004 on TCGPlayer Buy Shanks [Gold] OP09-004 on eBay

6. Portgas.D.Ace [Manga] OP13-119

The Portgas.D.Ace [Manga] OP13-119 card offers a more accessible price point for collectors looking to acquire Ace’s manga variant. At $970 raw, its PSA 10 median is $1,726, resulting in a 1.8x multiplier and a grading ROI of 27.6%. This figure is notably higher than other cards with the same multiplier, suggesting that Ace’s [Manga] variant might offer a slightly better return on grading investment compared to some of his contemporaries at this tier. It’s a solid choice for those targeting the “Manga” category with a character that holds significant sentimental value for fans.

Buy Portgas.D.Ace [Manga] OP13-119 on TCGPlayer Buy Portgas.D.Ace [Manga] OP13-119 on eBay

7. Shanks [Silver] OP09-004

Complementing the [Gold] variant, the Shanks [Silver] OP09-004 card presents another collectible option for fans of the Yonko. This card is listed at $949.99 raw, with a PSA 10 median of $1,480. It has a 1.6x multiplier and a grading ROI of 24.1%. While the ROI is modest, its price point makes it an achievable acquisition for a broader range of collectors. The existence of both Gold and Silver variants for Shanks offers collectors a choice based on their aesthetic preferences and budget, with the Gold variant showing a slightly higher market premium.

Buy Shanks [Silver] OP09-004 on TCGPlayer Buy Shanks [Silver] OP09-004 on eBay

8. Sabo [Manga] OP13-120

Rounding out the top eight chase cards is the Sabo [Manga] OP13-120. Priced at $663.87 raw, its PSA 10 median is $1,056, yielding a 1.6x multiplier and a 22.4% grading ROI. This card represents the most accessible entry into the top-tier chase cards of the Carrying on His Will set. While its ROI is not as high as some of the other manga variants, its lower entry price makes it an attractive option for collectors looking to complete a significant portion of the set’s high-value cards without a major upfront investment.

Buy Sabo [Manga] OP13-120 on TCGPlayer Buy Sabo [Manga] OP13-120 on eBay

Investment Analysis

Grading ROI Across the Set

The Carrying on His Will set shows a clear tiered approach to grading ROI, with the “Red Manga” variants offering the most substantial calculable returns. Portgas.D.Ace [Red Manga] OP13-119 leads at 73.2% (a $3,220.83 profit per PSA 10 after PSA’s $599 Premier fee, eBay fees, and shipping), followed by Sabo [Red Manga] OP13-120 at 54.4%. Monkey.D.Luffy [Red Manga] OP13-118 has no ROI figure, because its $30,000 PSA 10 value is above $10,000, where PSA publishes no grading fee. The “Manga” variants like Portgas.D.Ace [Manga] OP13-119 (27.6%) and Sabo [Manga] OP13-120 (22.4%) also offer viable grading opportunities, suggesting that pursuing PSA 10 grades on desirable cards is a consistent strategy within this set, as long as the card comes back a 10.

Complete-Set Cost

The sum of the top 8 card raw prices—$22,435—provides a significant floor for assessing the set’s value. However, it’s crucial to understand this is not the total cost. For TCGs like One Piece, the cost of completing a set typically ranges from 1.2 to 1.5 times the value of the top cards, accounting for the accumulation of commons, uncommons, rares, and any lower-tier parallels or special printings not captured in the top 8. Therefore, a realistic estimate for acquiring the full Carrying on His Will set in raw condition would likely fall between $26,922 and $33,652.50.

Short-Term vs. Long-Term View

In the short term (90 days), the data available for the Carrying on His Will set suggests a stable to rising market for its top chase cards, driven by collector demand and the rarity of the “Red Manga” variants. Long-term, the set’s value will likely remain tied to the enduring popularity of One Piece and the consistent demand for these iconic characters.

Risks

The primary risk for collectors investing in the Carrying on His Will set is the potential for reprints. While the “Red Manga” and other special variants are often designed with exclusivity in mind, the possibility of future reintroduction, perhaps with minor differences, can dilute the scarcity and impact the value of existing cards. Additionally, the general market trends within the TCG space, such as shifts in player popularity or the introduction of new, more dominant sets, can affect demand. Grading company shifts or changes in grading standards could also indirectly influence the market for graded cards.

Worth Collecting? The Verdict

WATCH. The One Piece Carrying on His Will set offers a concentrated value proposition, heavily weighted towards its top-tier chase cards, making it an appealing, albeit specialized, collection target for 2026.

The TCG Collectibles Completionist: For collectors who prioritize owning complete sets of popular franchises, Carrying on His Will is a WATCH. The estimated complete set cost, even considering the top 8 cards alone at $22,435, suggests a significant investment. However, the appeal lies in the rarity of the “Red Manga” variants, which will be the driving force for dedicated completionists. Acquiring the core high-value cards is essential, with the understanding that bulk acquisition will follow.

The ROI-Focused Investor: This set is a BUY for ROI-focused investors, particularly if they can acquire raw cards at favorable prices for grading. The Portgas.D.Ace [Red Manga] OP13-119 card, with a 73.2% grading ROI, is a prime example, and Sabo [Red Manga] OP13-120 follows at 54.4%. The Monkey.D.Luffy [Red Manga] OP13-118 carries the biggest graded premium, but its grading cost cannot be priced above $10,000. Investors should focus on sourcing these specific cards in high condition, as the PSA 10 multiplier is substantial.

The New Collector with $11,217 to Spend: For a new collector with a budget of $11,217, the Carrying on His Will set is a WATCH, with a focus on acquiring the higher-tier “Manga” and potentially “Gold” variants first. This budget allows for acquiring cards like the Monkey.D.Luffy [Manga] OP13-118 ($2,099 raw) and potentially the Shanks [Gold] OP09-004 ($1,492 raw) and Shanks [Silver] OP09-004 ($949.99 raw). While the top “Red Manga” cards are likely out of reach at current raw prices, this budget allows for building a strong foundation with individually valuable cards that still hold significant appeal.

Pro Tip: When considering the purchase of raw cards for grading, always factor in the grading fees and turnaround time. The profit margins calculated here are based on the potential ROI from a PSA 10 grade. Lower grades, even if still profitable, will yield a lower return. Thoroughly inspect cards for common grading pitfalls like edge whitening, surface scratches, and poor centering before submitting.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Carrying on His Will worth collecting in 2026?

Yes, the set is worth collecting, especially for its high-value chase cards like the Monkey.D.Luffy [Red Manga] OP13-118, which sells for $30,000 in PSA 10 against $8,955 raw. The set’s value is concentrated in its elite cards, making it attractive for targeted investments.

What is the most valuable card in the Carrying on His Will set?

The Monkey.D.Luffy [Red Manga] OP13-118 is the most valuable card, with a raw price of $8,955 and a PSA 10 median of $30,000. That 3.4x graded premium underscores its status; no grading ROI is given, because PSA publishes no grading fee above $10,000.

How much does it cost to complete the Carrying on His Will set?

The sum of the top 8 raw card prices is $22,435. Considering commons and other unlisted rarities, the total cost to complete the set is estimated to be 1.2 to 1.5 times this amount, likely ranging from $26,922 to $33,652.50.

Should I buy raw cards or graded cards for the Carrying on His Will set?

For investors seeking the highest potential returns, buying raw cards and grading them (especially the top chase cards) is recommended due to strong grading ROIs. For collectors focused on immediate display or completion, purchasing PSA 10 graded cards might be more convenient, though at a higher price point.

For those looking to dive deeper into the world of TCG collecting and investment, exploring our guides on Is Commander 2019 MTG Worth Collecting? 2026 Investment Review or Is Fabled Lorcana Worth Collecting? 2026 Investment Review can offer further insights into valuable sets within the TCG Collectibles niche.