Image sourced from eBay listings
Is Commander 2016 MTG Worth Collecting? 2026 Investment Review
This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Commander 2016 MTG is a WATCH for collectors in 2026, particularly those seeking individual high-value cards. The top 8 chase cards alone are valued at $178.59 raw, with Commander 2016’s premier card, Burgeoning, currently commanding $30.14. While the set lacks readily available PSA 10 data for a clear grading ROI calculation, the established raw prices suggest potential for strategic acquisitions.
90-day sold data shows Commander 2016 chase card medians have held steady, with Burgeoning leading the pack at a significant raw price point of $30.14. While specific PSA 10 data is absent, preventing a direct multiplier calculation, the current market valuation of the top 8 cards at $178.59 provides a solid foundation for assessing the set’s investment potential. This Commander release from 2016 continues to be a subject of interest for Magic: The Gathering collectors, especially those focused on Commander-specific staples. Last updated: September 2026.
In This Article
-
About Commander 2016
-
The Top Chase Cards
-
Individual Chase Card Spotlights
-
Investment Analysis
-
Worth Collecting? The Verdict
-
Frequently Asked Questions
About Commander 2016
Released in 2016, the Commander 2016 set holds a unique place within the history of Magic: The Gathering’s Commander product line. This release was notable for being the first Commander product to feature four-color commanders, a significant design shift that expanded deck-building possibilities and introduced new strategic archetypes for players. While the exact card count for the entire Commander 2016 release isn’t specified, these products are generally known for their curated selection of powerful cards aimed at enhancing the Commander format, often including sought-after reprints and new, format-defining cards.
In the context of TCG collectibles, Commander sets have consistently proven to be strong performers. They are often printed in finite quantities compared to core sets and are designed with a specific, engaged player base in mind. This inherent scarcity, combined with the consistent demand from Commander players looking to upgrade their decks with synergistic and powerful cards, tends to drive prices for key singles upward over time. Commander 2016, with its innovative four-color commander mechanic, introduced cards that quickly became integral to various Commander archetypes, thereby establishing their long-term collectible value.
The Top Chase Cards
The following table outlines the top 8 chase cards from the Commander 2016 set, ranked by their current raw price. This data provides a foundational understanding of the set’s most sought-after pieces and their immediate market value as of September 2026.
| # | Card | Raw | PSA 10 | Multiplier | Grading Play |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Burgeoning | $30.14 | — | — | — |
| 2 | Atraxa, Praetors’ Voice | $29.97 | — | — | — |
| 3 | Tymna the Weaver | $29.63 | — | — | — |
| 4 | Thrasios, Triton Hero | $22.39 | — | — | — |
| 5 | Lurking Predators | $19.72 | — | — | — |
| 6 | Reyhan, Last of the Abzan | $17.72 | — | — | — |
| 7 | Benefactor’s Draught | $14.72 | — | — | — |
| 8 | Chain of Vapor | $14.30 | — | — | — |
Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices, and PSA public-API pop reports. All figures as of September 2026.
1. Burgeoning (Card #)
Burgeoning stands at the pinnacle of Commander 2016’s chase cards, currently valued at $30.14 raw. This price point is a direct reflection of its immense power and utility within the Commander format. As a card that can significantly accelerate land drops, it’s a cornerstone for many combo and ramp-focused decks, driving consistent demand. The lack of PSA 10 data makes assessing a direct grading ROI challenging, but its high raw price suggests that even a moderately graded copy (e.g., PSA 8 or 9) could hold substantial value. Its consistent performance in high-level Commander play solidifies its status as a must-have for collectors seeking to own iconic pieces of the format.
2. Atraxa, Praetors’ Voice (Card #28)
Atraxa, Praetors’ Voice is a dominant force in the Commander landscape, reflected in its $29.97 raw price. As one of the original four-color commanders, Atraxa has been a fan favorite since its release, enabling potent superfriends, proliferate, and various other synergistic strategies. Its broad appeal across multiple archetypes ensures consistent demand from a wide segment of the Commander player base. The absence of PSA 10 pricing prevents a direct calculation of grading profit potential, but the strong raw price indicates that acquiring high-grade copies could still be a lucrative endeavor for investors.
Buy Atraxa, Praetors’ Voice on eBay Buy Atraxa, Praetors’ Voice on TCGPlayer
3. Tymna the Weaver (Card #)
Tymna the Weaver commands a healthy $29.63 raw price, positioning it as a top-tier chase card from Commander 2016. As a commander that synergizes with attacking and card advantage, Tymna is a popular choice for aggressive and value-oriented decks. Its ability to generate card draw on nearly any creature-based attack makes it a consistent engine for maintaining hand size and overwhelming opponents. Without PSA 10 data, calculating the grading return is speculative, but the substantial raw value suggests that high-grade Tymna cards are valuable assets for collectors.
4. Thrasios, Triton Hero (Card #)
Thrasios, Triton Hero holds a respectable $22.39 raw price, highlighting its role as a critical enabler in many Commander decks. Thrasios is renowned for its ability to act as a mana sink and a powerful card-drawing engine, often pairing with other commanders to create game-winning combinations. Its flexibility and late-game potential make it a staple in competitive and casual Commander circles alike. The lack of graded population data prevents a direct grading ROI analysis, but its strong raw valuation underscores its desirability among collectors seeking key Commander staples.
Buy Thrasios, Triton Hero on eBay
5. Lurking Predators (Card #)
Lurking Predators comes in at $19.72 raw, marking it as a significant chase card with a unique play pattern. This enchantment can dramatically alter the game by allowing players to cast creatures for free as opponents cast spells, creating powerful tempo swings and board presence. Its high impact on the game state makes it a desirable card for creature-heavy and reactive strategies. While specific PSA 10 pricing is unavailable, the card’s substantial raw value suggests that high-grade copies are valuable and sought after by Commander players looking for impactful enchantments.
6. Reyhan, Last of the Abzan (Card #)
Reyhan, Last of the Abzan is valued at $17.72 raw, reflecting its strong synergy within graveyard and +1/+1 counter-themed Commander decks. As a partner commander that doubles down on creature death triggers for counters, Reyhan facilitates powerful board states and resilient strategies. It’s a key piece for many Abzan-colored commander pairings. The absence of PSA 10 data prevents a concrete grading ROI calculation, but the solid raw price indicates that high-grade Reyhan cards are desirable assets for collectors specializing in synergistic Commander pieces.
Buy Reyhan, Last of the Abzan on eBay
7. Benefactor’s Draught (Card #)
Benefactor’s Draught sits at $14.72 raw, indicating its niche but consistent demand within the Commander ecosystem. This enchantment provides a valuable effect of drawing a card whenever an opponent loses life from a source other than combat damage, rewarding players for using various life-drain or direct damage strategies. Its ability to provide incremental card advantage makes it a useful tool for controlling or tempo-oriented decks. Without graded data, direct ROI is uncertain, but the raw price suggests that this card offers potential value for collectors.
Buy Benefactor’s Draught on eBay
8. Chain of Vapor (Card #)
Chain of Vapor rounds out the top 8 with a raw price of $14.30. This instant-speed bounce spell is a highly efficient and flexible removal option in Commander, capable of clearing threats or resetting permanents. Its low mana cost and ability to bounce multiple permanents make it an invaluable tool for both defensive and offensive plays. While PSA 10 data is not available, the strong raw price confirms its staple status. For collectors, acquiring high-grade copies represents a sound investment in a universally useful Commander card.
Buy Chain of Vapor on eBay Buy Chain of Vapor on TCGPlayer
Investment Analysis
Grading ROI Across the Set
With the current data for Commander 2016, a definitive grading ROI calculation for PSA 10 is not possible due to the lack of reported PSA 10 median prices for any of the chase cards. However, we can infer potential based on the raw prices. Cards like Burgeoning ($30.14 raw) and Atraxa, Praetors’ Voice ($29.97 raw) have strong base values. What the raw prices do show is how high a PSA 10 would have to sell. At PSA’s current fees (Standard $59.99 per card for cards up to $1,000; PSA’s Value tiers are paused, checked October 12, 2026), eBay’s 13.25% trading-card selling fee and an estimated $5 shipping, a PSA 10 Burgeoning would need to sell for about $110.12 just to break even, roughly 3.7 times its raw price, and a PSA 10 Atraxa, Praetors’ Voice about $109.92. Investors should monitor pop reports for these key cards to identify opportunities where a high grade might significantly outperform the raw market value.
Complete-Set Cost
The sum of the top 8 card raw prices for Commander 2016 is $178.59. This figure serves as a lower-bound floor for acquiring the set’s most valuable singles. For Magic: The Gathering TCG collectibles, it’s prudent to estimate the true cost of a complete set by multiplying this floor by a factor of 1.0 to 1.2. This accounts for the additional cost of commons, uncommons, rares, and any potential parallels or alternate art versions that exist, which are not included in the top chase card calculation. Therefore, a rough estimate for acquiring the entire Commander 2016 set might range from approximately $179 to $215 raw. This is a modest entry point for a Commander product with several highly sought-after singles.
Short-Term vs. Long-Term View
Commander 2016 was released in 2016, giving it a decade-long track record in the market. The current raw prices of its top cards suggest stability rather than explosive short-term growth, which is typical for established Commander staples that have already seen significant price appreciation and widespread adoption. The sustained demand from the Commander format provides a solid foundation for long-term value retention and gradual appreciation. Short-term fluctuations might occur based on metagame shifts or reprint announcements, but the inherent power and utility of cards like Burgeoning and Atraxa, Praetors’ Voice ensure their relevance and demand for years to come.
Risks
The primary risk associated with collecting Commander 2016, as with any Magic: The Gathering product, is the potential for reprints. Wizards of the Coast occasionally reintroduces popular Commander cards into new products, which can temporarily depress the market value of original printings. Another risk is the evolving landscape of the Commander format itself; while the current chase cards are highly unlikely to become obsolete, shifts in dominant strategies or the introduction of powerful new staples could marginally impact demand for older cards. Finally, the grading market itself presents risks, including changes in grading standards, grading company popularity, or sudden drops in the perceived value of graded cards versus raw copies.
Worth Collecting? The Verdict
Verdict: WATCH
Commander 2016 is a WATCH set in 2026 for collectors. While a complete set acquisition is reasonably priced, the true value lies in its individual chase cards. The lack of graded pricing data makes direct grading ROI speculative, but the established raw prices of cards like Burgeoning ($30.14) and Atraxa, Praetors’ Voice ($29.97) suggest a strong foundation for collectors interested in high-demand singles.
-
The TCG Collectibles Completionist: WATCH. The complete set cost is relatively low ($179-$215 raw estimate), making it an attainable goal. The set contains iconic Commander staples that any serious collector of the format would want to own. Focus on acquiring these key singles over time.
-
The ROI-Focused Investor: WATCH. The absence of PSA 10 data for key cards is a significant hurdle for immediate profit calculation. However, the strong raw prices of Burgeoning and Atraxa suggest that if high-grade copies begin to surface and command premiums, there could be opportunity. Monitor pop reports and potential grading trends.
-
The New Collector with $89 to Spend: BUY (select singles). With $89, a new collector could acquire several of the top-tier chase cards from Commander 2016. Focusing on cards like Thrasios, Triton Hero ($22.39) or Lurking Predators ($19.72) would provide substantial value and playability within the Commander format, offering immediate satisfaction and a strong entry into collecting valuable MTG singles.
Pro Tip: When assessing Commander 2016 for investment, prioritize cards that have consistently seen play and demand across multiple Commander archetypes. Cards like Atraxa, Praetors’ Voice and Thrasios, Triton Hero are prime examples due to their unique abilities and four-color identity, making them less susceptible to market shifts driven by specific deck trends.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Commander 2016 a good set to complete?
Commander 2016 is a good set to complete if you are a collector focused on the Commander format’s history and iconic cards. The estimated raw cost for the complete set is modest, around $179-$215. While it may not offer the same explosive growth potential as newer, highly scarce sets, it contains several highly playable and valuable singles that are staples in many Commander decks.
What makes the chase cards in Commander 2016 so valuable?
The chase cards in Commander 2016 are valuable primarily due to their strategic importance and unique mechanics within the Commander format. Cards like Atraxa, Praetors’ Voice and Thrasios, Triton Hero are powerful four-color commanders that enable complex and effective deck strategies. Burgeoning is a high-impact ramp spell that accelerates gameplay significantly. Their consistent inclusion in popular Commander decks drives demand, which, in turn, supports their market prices.
Should I buy raw cards or graded cards from Commander 2016?
Given that Commander 2016 lacks readily available PSA 10 pricing data for its top chase cards, buying raw cards for individual use or for potential future grading is a viable strategy. If you are an investor looking for immediate portfolio value and have the expertise to identify high-quality raw cards, focusing on acquiring near-mint raw copies of cards like Burgeoning or Tymna the Weaver could be more cost-effective. However, be aware of the risks associated with raw card condition.
How do the four-color commanders from Commander 2016 compare to other Commander sets?
The four-color commanders from Commander 2016, such as Atraxa, Praetors’ Voice, were groundbreaking at the time of release, opening up new deck-building horizons. While subsequent Commander sets have also introduced multi-color commanders, the original four-color cards from 2016 remain highly sought after because they were pioneers in that space. Their unique abilities and the established player base for their archetypes ensure their continued relevance and collectible value compared to newer, but perhaps less historically significant, counterparts.
What is the estimated cost to acquire the complete Commander 2016 set?
Based on the sum of the top 8 chase card raw prices ($178.59) and applying a multiplier of 1.0-1.2 for commons and other unlisted cards, the estimated raw cost to acquire the complete Commander 2016 set is approximately $179 to $215. This figure does not include the cost of grading, shipping, or taxes. It represents a baseline for acquiring all cards in near-mint or lightly played condition.
Are there any reprints of Commander 2016 chase cards that affect their value?
While specific reprint information for every card in Commander 2016 is not provided, it’s a general risk for any Magic: The Gathering set that popular cards are subject to reprints in future Commander products or special sets. Reprints can impact the market value of original printings, though cards with established demand and iconic status often retain a premium for their originality. Collectors should stay informed about any new releases that might include these key cards.
Commander 2016 represents a solid entry point for collectors interested in the evolution of the Commander format. For those looking to delve deeper into Magic: The Gathering’s collectible history, explore our guides on Is Commander 2015 MTG Worth Collecting? 2026 Investment Review and Is Commander MTG Worth Collecting? 2026 Investment Review within our TCG Collectibles section.