Image sourced from eBay listings
Is Chronicles MTG Worth Collecting? Top Cards & Prices
This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Chronicles MTG suits collectors, particularly for those targeting specific high-demand cards like Concordant Crossroads, which commands a 2.6x multiplier between raw and PSA 10 prices.
In This Article
-
About Chronicles
-
The Top Chase Cards
-
Individual Chase Card Breakdowns
-
- Concordant Crossroads
-
- City of Brass
-
- Ashnod’s Altar
-
- Blood Moon
-
- Nicol Bolas
-
- Urza’s Mine [Anson Maddocks]
-
- Arena of the Ancients
-
Investment Analysis
-
Grading ROI Across the Set
-
Complete-Set Cost Estimation
-
Short-Term vs. Long-Term Outlook
-
Potential Risks
-
Worth Collecting? The Bottom Line
-
Pro Tip
-
Frequently Asked Questions
About Chronicles
Magic: The Gathering Chronicles, released in 1995, occupies a unique space within the collectible card game landscape. While not a primary set in the traditional sense like Alpha or Beta, it functions as a compilation set, drawing from various earlier Magic sets. This makes its appeal a blend of nostalgia for older players and a gateway for newer collectors to acquire iconic cards that might otherwise be prohibitively expensive or difficult to find in their original printings. The strategy of reprinting older, sought-after cards in a single, accessible product is a powerful draw for the collectibles market.
The Top Chase Cards
The market for Magic: The Gathering Chronicles in 2026 is primarily driven by a select group of powerful and iconic cards. These represent the highest value within the set and are the main targets for investors and serious collectors. The disparity between raw prices and graded, gem-mint conditions, particularly at PSA 10, reveals a large graded premium, although at PSA’s current $59.99 Standard fee only one card, Blood Moon, clears its grading costs.
The following table breaks down the top 8 chase cards, offering a clear view of their current market standing:
| # | Card | Raw | PSA 10 | Multiplier | Grading Play |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Concordant Crossroads | $30.49 | $78.41 | 2.6× | -30.8% |
| 2 | City of Brass | $24.00 | — | — | — |
| 3 | Ashnod’s Altar | $10.25 | $52.08 | 5.1× | -43.4% |
| 4 | Blood Moon | $8.21 | $87.58 | 10.7× | 3.5% |
| 5 | Nicol Bolas | $4.54 | — | — | — |
| 6 | Urza’s Mine [Anson Maddocks] | $3.49 | — | — | — |
| 7 | Arena of the Ancients | $3.46 | — | — | — |
Grading ROI assumes a PSA 10, graded at PSA’s cheapest open tier for the card’s value (Standard $59.99 up to $1,000; PSA’s Value tiers are paused; fees checked October 12, 2026), sold on eBay (13.25% fee + $0.40) with an estimated $5 shipping. No figure is given above $10,000, where PSA publishes no fee.
Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices, and PSA population reports.
Individual Chase Card Breakdowns
1. Concordant Crossroads (Card #)
Concordant Crossroads is the current king of Chronicles, with a raw price of $30.49 and a PSA 10 price of $78.41. This represents a substantial 2.6x multiplier, but the calculated grading ROI is -30.8%: after PSA’s $59.99 Standard fee, eBay fees, and shipping, a raw copy graded PSA 10 and sold at that price loses $27.86. A raw copy would need to cost $2.63 or less to break even. For collectors focused on high-value singles, buying a Concordant Crossroads already graded is the better route.
Buy Concordant Crossroads on eBay Buy Concordant Crossroads on TCGPlayer
2. City of Brass (Card #)
City of Brass currently sits at a raw price of $24.00, positioning it as the second most valuable single card within the Chronicles set. Despite the lack of grading data, its strong raw price indicates significant demand from players and collectors looking to acquire this staple land card. For those aiming for set completion or building powerful decks, City of Brass remains a key acquisition from Chronicles.
Buy City of Brass on eBay Buy City of Brass on TCGPlayer
3. Ashnod’s Altar (Card #)
Ashnod’s Altar is a notable card in Chronicles, with a raw price of $10.25 and a PSA 10 price of $52.08. This provides a robust 5.1x multiplier between raw and graded versions, but the grading ROI is calculated at -43.4%, a loss of $30.46 per card even at PSA 10, because PSA’s $59.99 Standard fee is larger than the gap between the raw and PSA 10 prices. Grading raw copies of Ashnod’s Altar for resale does not pay at current fees.
Buy Ashnod’s Altar on eBay Buy Ashnod’s Altar on TCGPlayer
4. Blood Moon (Card #)
Blood Moon stands out as a highly potent investment within the Chronicles set, boasting a raw price of $8.21 and a commanding PSA 10 price of $87.58. This translates to an impressive 10.7x multiplier, the highest among the top chase cards for which PSA 10 data is available. The grading ROI is a slim 3.5%, a $2.38 profit per card at PSA 10 after PSA’s $59.99 Standard fee, eBay fees, and shipping, and the only positive figure in the set. A raw copy breaks even at PSA 10 up to $10.59, so the margin disappears quickly if the raw price rises or the card grades below a 10.
Buy Blood Moon on eBay Buy Blood Moon on TCGPlayer
5. Nicol Bolas (Card #)
Nicol Bolas is another iconic character to appear in Chronicles, with a raw price of $4.54. Similar to other cards in the set, there is no PSA 10 price data available, preventing an assessment of its grading multiplier and ROI. However, its raw price indicates a solid level of demand, driven by the character’s legendary status in the Magic: The Gathering lore. Collectors who value lore and powerful characters will find Nicol Bolas a compelling addition to their collection, even without definitive grading metrics.
Buy Nicol Bolas on eBay Buy Nicol Bolas on TCGPlayer
6. Urza’s Mine [Anson Maddocks] (Card #)
Urza’s Mine, specifically the version associated with Anson Maddocks, is priced at $3.49 raw. As with several other cards in this list, there is no PSA 10 price available, which means its grading potential remains unexplored in terms of concrete figures. Despite this, its presence in the top chase cards list signifies its importance within the set. For players and collectors familiar with the classic Urza lands, this version from Chronicles holds a particular appeal, representing a more accessible entry point to owning these powerful pieces of Magic’s history.
Buy Urza’s Mine [Anson Maddocks] on eBay Buy Urza’s Mine [Anson Maddocks] on TCGPlayer
7. Arena of the Ancients (Card #)
Arena of the Ancients rounds out the top 8 chase cards for Chronicles with a raw price of $3.46. Like many of its counterparts in this set, specific data for its PSA 10 price is not available, leaving its grading multiplier and ROI unknown. Nevertheless, its position among the most sought-after cards highlights its perceived value within the market. Collectors looking to complete the Chronicles set or acquire unique, older artifacts will find Arena of the Ancients to be a key piece, driven by its raw price and historical significance.
Buy Arena of the Ancients on eBay Buy Arena of the Ancients on TCGPlayer
Investment Analysis
Grading ROI Across the Set
The grading landscape for Chronicles is thin at current fees. Blood Moon is the only card with a positive grading ROI, a slim 3.5% (a $2.38 profit per PSA 10) on its 10.7x multiplier from raw to PSA 10. Ashnod’s Altar (-43.4% ROI, 5.1x multiplier) and Concordant Crossroads (-30.8%, 2.6x) lose money even at PSA 10, because PSA’s cheapest open tier is now Standard at $59.99 per card (the Value tiers are paused), more than either card’s graded premium. Grading for profit only works here at low raw prices, and collectors must also factor in the risk of not achieving a Gem Mint 10 grade.
Complete-Set Cost Estimation
To accurately estimate the cost of acquiring a complete set, a multiplier must be applied to account for the numerous commons, uncommons, and potential unlisted rarities that make up the full checklist.
Short-Term vs. Long-Term Outlook
The current data, while a snapshot from September 2026, offers clues into the market dynamics of Chronicles. The high multipliers for cards like Blood Moon (10.7x) and Ashnod’s Altar (5.1x) suggest that there’s a consistent demand for graded versions of these powerful cards, which in turn drives up the perceived value of graded copies. This could indicate a stable or upward trend for these specific chase cards in the short to medium term, especially if playability in popular formats persists. In the long term, Chronicles’ status as a compilation set of older, desirable cards should support its value. Sets that offer access to iconic cards from Magic’s earlier days tend to retain collector interest, making it a potentially stable, albeit not explosive, investment for those looking to hold for years.
Potential Risks
Several factors could influence the investment potential of Magic: The Gathering Chronicles. The primary risk for any Magic set is the potential for reprints. While Chronicles itself is a reprint set, Wizards of the Coast could, in theory, choose to reprint these specific cards again in future products, potentially diluting the scarcity of the Chronicles versions. Secondly, the meta-game shifts within Magic: The Gathering can impact card demand; if cards like Blood Moon or Concordant Crossroads become less relevant in competitive play, their value could decline. Finally, the grading market itself carries risks. Changes in grading standards, the rise of competing grading companies, or a significant shift in collector sentiment towards graded versus raw cards could all affect the long-term appreciation of graded Chronicles cards.
Worth Collecting? The Bottom Line
Magic: The Gathering Chronicles suits collectors who appreciate its compilation nature and the inclusion of iconic cards. While not a top-tier investment for rapid gains, it offers steady value, particularly in its graded chase cards like Blood Moon and Ashnod’s Altar.
Here’s a breakdown for different collector types:
- The ROI-Focused Investor: Only Blood Moon shows a positive grading ROI (3.5%, a $2.38 profit per PSA 10), while Ashnod’s Altar (-43.4%) and Concordant Crossroads (-30.8%) lose money at PSA’s $59.99 Standard fee. Grading for profit here depends on buying Blood Moon raw at $10.59 or less and getting the 10. Be aware of grading fees and turnaround times.
Pro Tip
For collectors interested in maximizing value from Chronicles, focus your grading efforts on cards with the highest PSA 10 multipliers. Blood Moon, with its 10.7x multiplier, is the only card that clears PSA’s $59.99 Standard fee (a 3.5% grading ROI); Ashnod’s Altar, at 5.1x, still shows -43.4%. Always factor in grading submission costs and the potential for achieving a Gem Mint 10 grade when calculating your expected return on investment. Is Brother’s War Retro Artifacts MTG Worth Collecting? 2026 Investment Review offers similar analysis for artifact-heavy sets.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Chronicles MTG worth collecting in 2026?
Yes, Chronicles MTG is worth collecting in 2026, especially for its iconic chase cards like Blood Moon, which shows a 10.7x multiplier between raw and PSA 10 prices.
Which cards in Chronicles offer the best grading ROI?
Blood Moon is the only card with a positive grading ROI, a slim 3.5% ($2.38 per card at PSA 10) thanks to its 10.7x multiplier. Concordant Crossroads (-30.8%) and Ashnod’s Altar (-43.4%) lose money at PSA’s $59.99 Standard fee, eBay fees, and shipping.
How does Chronicles compare to other compilation sets in MTG?
Chronicles acts as a valuable compilation set, offering accessible entry points to older, sought-after cards, similar in principle to sets like Commander Anthologies. Its value is derived from the collectibility of its reprinted cards. Is Brother’s War Commander MTG Worth Collecting? 2026 Investment Review discusses another type of compilation product.
What are the main risks for collecting Chronicles MTG?
The primary risks include potential future reprints of its key cards by Wizards of the Coast, shifts in Magic’s meta-game affecting card playability, and potential changes in the grading market itself.
Can a new collector with $52 start collecting Chronicles?
For more insights into the world of Magic: The Gathering collectibles and investment strategies, explore our TCG Collectibles hub.
Data: PSA population reports · PriceCharting · eBay sold listings. Analysis: What The Slab. How we get our numbers.
Price data, not financial advice. Past sales don't predict future value. We may earn a commission on eBay, TCGplayer and Amazon links.
Weekly graded sales report
Free weekly email. Unsubscribe anytime.
