Image sourced from eBay listings
Top 10 Most Valuable 2023 Panini Prizm UFC Sports Cards (2026)
This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
The most valuable 2023 Panini Prizm UFC cards are led by Hasbulla Magomedov’s Blue Shimmer variant, which sold for $3,666 raw, and Bo Nickal’s Octagon card, which reached $2,900 in PSA 10 condition. These cards demonstrate significant market demand for burgeoning stars and internet personalities within the UFC collecting space.
2023 Panini Prizm UFC sports card sold volume is showing robust interest from collectors and investors in 2026, driven by a blend of established fan favorites and rising contenders. Here are the cards that are currently defining the market, based on verified eBay sold comps and PriceCharting data. The top 10 cards showcase a range of raw prices from $1,033 to $3,666, with graded values also demonstrating strong performance. Understanding these key assets is crucial for anyone looking to navigate the high-end segment of the 2023 Panini Prizm UFC checklist. The market is clearly favoring unique variants and breakout athletes.
Last updated: September 2026.
In This Article
-
The Top 10 2023 Panini Prizm UFC Market Data
-
- Hasbulla Magomedov [Blue Shimmer]
-
- Bo Nickal [Gold]
-
- Rinat Fakhretdinov [Gold Shimmer]
-
- Bo Nickal [Octagon]
-
- Alex Pereira [Octagon]
The Top 10 2023 Panini Prizm UFC Market Data
| # | Card | Set | PSA 10 | PSA 9 | Raw | Grading ROI | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Hasbulla Magomedov [Blue Shimmer] | 2023 Prizm UFC | $750.00 | — | $3,666 | -82.7% | — |
| 2 | Bo Nickal [Gold] | 2023 Prizm UFC | $2,317 | — | $3,000 | -37.3% | — |
| 3 | Rinat Fakhretdinov [Gold Shimmer] | 2023 Prizm UFC | — | — | $2,500 | — | — |
| 4 | Bo Nickal [Octagon] | 2023 Prizm UFC | $2,900 | — | $2,250 | -3.4% | — |
| 5 | Alex Pereira [Octagon] | 2023 Prizm UFC | $1,000 | — | $2,050 | -59.1% | — |
| 6 | Hasbulla Magomedov [Gold] | 2023 Prizm UFC | — | — | $2,025 | — | — |
| 7 | Hasbulla Magomedov [Mojo] | 2023 Prizm UFC | $2,375 | — | $1,675 | 9.7% | — |
| 8 | Bo Nickal [Blue Shimmer] | 2023 Prizm UFC | — | — | $1,525 | — | — |
| 9 | Hasbulla Magomedov [Octagon] | 2023 Prizm UFC | — | — | $1,412 | — | — |
| 10 | Conor McGregor [Gold Shimmer] | 2023 Prizm UFC | — | — | $1,033 | — | — |
Grading ROI assumes a PSA 10, graded at PSA’s cheapest open tier for the card’s value (Standard $59.99 up to $1,000; PSA’s Value tiers are paused; fees checked October 12, 2026), sold on eBay (13.25% fee + $0.40) with an estimated $5 shipping. No figure is given above $10,000, where PSA publishes no fee.
Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices. All figures as of September 2026.
1. Hasbulla Magomedov [Blue Shimmer] (200)
The undisputed top card in the 2023 Panini Prizm UFC set, at least in terms of raw sales, is the Hasbulla Magomedov [Blue Shimmer] variant. With a raw price point of $3,666, this card significantly outpaces all others on this list. While its PSA 10 median is listed at $750.00, resulting in a substantial -82.7% grading ROI, the sheer volume of raw interest is undeniable. This suggests collectors are either chasing the raw card for its immediate visual appeal or perhaps holding onto it with the hope that future market shifts will re-evaluate its graded potential. The massive difference between the raw price and the graded price indicates a current market preference for acquiring the card in its ungraded state. This is a unique phenomenon, and careful consideration of grading costs versus potential returns is essential for any investor considering this card. For those looking to acquire a piece of viral internet culture intertwined with combat sports memorabilia, this card is the ultimate prize.
Buy Hasbulla Magomedov [Blue Shimmer] (200) on eBay (active listings) Check Hasbulla Magomedov [Blue Shimmer] (200) sold comps on eBay
2. Bo Nickal [Gold] (103)
![Bo Nickal [Gold] #103](https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/~5YAAeSw-5BnpoHK/s-l800.jpg)
Bo Nickal’s [Gold] variant is a strong contender for the second most valuable card in the 2023 Panini Prizm UFC set, boasting a raw price of $3,000. When graded to PSA 10, this card commands a median price of $2,317, representing a -37.3% grading ROI. Despite the negative ROI on graded copies, the raw price indicates substantial demand for Nickal’s gold variant. This suggests that collectors and investors are willing to pay a premium for this particular card, possibly due to its eye-catching gold parallel and the rising profile of Bo Nickal himself. The disconnect between the raw and graded prices, while not as extreme as the top card, still warrants careful analysis. The potential for future appreciation in the graded market exists, but the current data points to a strong raw market driving its valuation. For collectors who believe in Nickal’s long-term potential, acquiring this gold card could be a strategic move.
Buy Bo Nickal [Gold] (103) on eBay (active listings) Check Bo Nickal [Gold] (103) sold comps on eBay
3. Rinat Fakhretdinov [Gold Shimmer] (116)
![Rinat Fakhretdinov [Gold Shimmer] #116](https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/7QMAAOSwlaBkS9xZ/s-l800.jpg)
Rinat Fakhretdinov’s [Gold Shimmer] card lands in the third spot with a solid raw price of $2,500. Currently, there is no available PSA 10 median data for this specific card, which makes assessing its graded potential and ROI impossible for now. However, its high raw price suggests a significant collector interest, likely driven by the allure of the gold shimmer parallel and Fakhretdinov’s performance. The absence of graded data presents both an opportunity and a risk. If a strong market emerges for graded copies, there could be substantial upside. Conversely, without established graded comps, predicting future performance is more speculative. Investors in this card would be wise to monitor the market closely for any emerging graded sales to establish a clearer valuation benchmark. This card represents a potential sleeper within the set if graded demand materializes.
Buy Rinat Fakhretdinov [Gold Shimmer] (116) on eBay (active listings) Check Rinat Fakhretdinov [Gold Shimmer] (116) sold comps on eBay
4. Bo Nickal [Octagon] (103)
![Bo Nickal [Octagon] #103](https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/PMQAAeSwEF9pLvy2/s-l800.jpg)
Bo Nickal continues to impress with his [Octagon] variant, securing the fourth spot. This card has a raw price of $2,250 and, notably, a PSA 10 median of $2,900, yet grading it shows a -3.4% ROI at current fees, a loss of about $89 per card. The PSA 10 premium is real, but it does not quite cover PSA’s $349 Super Express fee (the cheapest open tier for a card at this value), eBay’s selling fee and shipping. The strong performance in both raw and graded markets highlights Nickal’s growing appeal among collectors. The Octagon variant, often visually striking within the Prizm line, appears to resonate well with the fanbase. The combination of a popular fighter and a well-regarded card design makes this card an attractive prospect for collectors, though not as a grading flip at current prices. This card exemplifies a successful blend of athlete popularity and product appeal.
Buy Bo Nickal [Octagon] (103) on eBay (active listings) Check Bo Nickal [Octagon] (103) sold comps on eBay
5. Alex Pereira [Octagon] (111)
Alex Pereira’s [Octagon] variant takes the fifth position, with a raw price of $2,050. While its PSA 10 median is listed at $1,000, this results in a significant -59.1% grading ROI. This data suggests that, similar to some other high-value cards, the market is currently favoring the raw version of this Alex Pereira card. Despite the substantial loss on graded copies based on current data, Pereira’s status as a high-profile fighter likely contributes to its overall value. The disparity between the raw and graded figures warrants careful consideration for collectors. It could indicate that the PSA 10 market for this card is not yet fully established or that collectors prefer the immediate gratification of acquiring the raw card. For fans of “Poatan,” this card remains a notable item, but the grading aspect presents a clear financial hurdle.
Buy Alex Pereira [Octagon] (111) on eBay (active listings) Check Alex Pereira [Octagon] (111) sold comps on eBay
6. Hasbulla Magomedov [Gold] (200)
Another Hasbulla Magomedov card makes the list, this time the [Gold] variant, which sold for $2,025 raw. Similar to the Rinat Fakhretdinov [Gold Shimmer], there is no PSA 10 median data available for this card. This leaves its graded market performance and potential ROI unquantified. However, the raw price alone places it firmly within the top tier of this set. The continued strong performance of Hasbulla cards, even in different parallels, underscores his massive appeal beyond the traditional fight fanbase. For collectors looking to capitalize on the viral phenomenon, this gold variant is a significant option. The lack of graded data means that purchasing this card raw is a more speculative play concerning its long-term graded value. Monitoring any future graded sales will be key to understanding its true potential in the graded market.
Buy Hasbulla Magomedov [Gold] (200) on eBay (active listings) Check Hasbulla Magomedov [Gold] (200) sold comps on eBay
7. Hasbulla Magomedov [Mojo] (200)
Hasbulla Magomedov’s presence continues with the [Mojo] variant, positioned at number seven. This card has a raw price of $1,675 and a PSA 10 median of $2,375, giving a 9.7% grading ROI at current fees. This is the one card on this list where grading shows a profit, with the PSA 10 median covering the raw price, PSA’s grading fee, eBay’s selling fee and shipping. The Mojo parallel is often a sought-after variant within the Prizm line, and its combination with Hasbulla’s immense popularity creates a potent market force. The positive ROI here suggests that the graded market for this specific Hasbulla card is performing well, making it an attractive option for those looking to invest in graded assets with a proven track record. This card is a prime example of a high-demand player combined with a desirable parallel that benefits from grading.
Buy Hasbulla Magomedov [Mojo] (200) on eBay (active listings) Check Hasbulla Magomedov [Mojo] (200) sold comps on eBay
8. Bo Nickal [Blue Shimmer] (103)
Bo Nickal appears once more on the list with his [Blue Shimmer] variant, priced at $1,525 raw. As with several other cards, there is no available PSA 10 median data for this particular card. This leaves its graded market value and potential ROI as unknowns. The raw price indicates that collectors are actively seeking out this variant, attributing significant value to it even in its ungraded state. The consistent presence of Bo Nickal across multiple high-value cards in the 2023 Prizm UFC set speaks volumes about his rising star power within the collecting community. For those interested in Bo Nickal, this Blue Shimmer card represents a considerable investment at the raw level. Without graded comps, any assessment of its long-term graded potential remains speculative.
Buy Bo Nickal [Blue Shimmer] (103) on eBay (active listings) Check Bo Nickal [Blue Shimmer] (103) sold comps on eBay
9. Hasbulla Magomedov [Octagon] (200)
![Hasbulla Magomedov [Octagon] #200](https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/MywAAeSwwilqAn~c/s-l800.jpg)
Rounding out the top ten, we see another Hasbulla Magomedov card: the [Octagon] variant, with a raw price of $1,412. Similar to other entries lacking specific graded data, the PSA 10 median is unavailable. However, its position on this list, driven by its raw sale price, underscores the consistent demand for Hasbulla’s presence in the 2023 Panini Prizm UFC set. The Octagon design is a popular feature in Prizm releases, and its combination with Hasbulla’s viral fame continues to drive significant interest. For collectors focused on acquiring raw cards of this internet sensation, this Octagon variant is a notable option. The lack of graded data means that collectors are buying primarily for the raw card itself, with graded potential being an unconfirmed upside.
Buy Hasbulla Magomedov [Octagon] (200) on eBay (active listings) Check Hasbulla Magomedov [Octagon] (200) sold comps on eBay
10. Conor McGregor [Gold Shimmer] (125)
Conor McGregor, a perennial fan favorite, closes out the top 10 with his [Gold Shimmer] card, which sold for $1,033 raw. As with several other cards on this list, there are no PSA 10 sales in our data. This makes it difficult to gauge the card’s performance in the graded market or to calculate a grading ROI. Nevertheless, McGregor’s enduring popularity ensures that his cards will always command attention. The Gold Shimmer parallel is visually appealing, and combined with his name recognition, it accounts for the card’s significant raw value. For collectors focused on the biggest names in UFC, this card represents an accessible entry point into the higher-value spectrum of the 2023 Prizm UFC set. The raw market dictates its current valuation, with graded potential remaining a question mark.
Buy Conor McGregor [Gold Shimmer] (125) on eBay (active listings) Check Conor McGregor [Gold Shimmer] (125) sold comps on eBay
The Grading ROI Play
When assessing the investment potential of sports cards, the Grading Return on Investment (ROI) is a critical metric. At PSA’s current fees (Standard $59.99 per card for cards up to $1,000, Express $199 up to $2,500, Super Express $349 up to $5,000; PSA’s Value tiers are paused, checked October 12, 2026), eBay’s 13.25% trading-card selling fee and an estimated $5 shipping, only one card in the 2023 Panini Prizm UFC top 10 shows a grading profit. The Hasbulla Magomedov [Mojo] card offers a 9.7% grading ROI. With a raw price of $1,675 and a PSA 10 median of $2,375, the total cost is $1,874 ($1,675 raw + $199 PSA Express grading), and a PSA 10 sale at the median nets $2,054.91 after eBay’s fee and shipping, a profit of $180.91. The flip breaks even as long as the raw copy costs no more than $1,855.91, so the margin is thinner than the raw-to-PSA 10 gap suggests.
The Bo Nickal [Octagon] variant looks like a grading candidate at first glance, with a raw price of $2,250 and a PSA 10 median of $2,900, but the math does not hold up. A card at that value needs PSA’s Super Express tier ($349), bringing the total cost to $2,599, while a PSA 10 sale at the median nets $2,510.35 after eBay’s fee and shipping. That is a loss of $88.65, a -3.4% ROI. The flip only breaks even at a raw price of $2,161.35 or less.
Conversely, cards like the Hasbulla Magomedov [Blue Shimmer] show a substantial negative ROI of -82.7%. With a raw price of $3,666 and a PSA 10 median of $750, grading this card represents a loss of about $3,081. At these figures, grading is not a financially sound decision if the goal is profit. Even with minimal grading fees, breaking even would require a PSA 10 sale far exceeding the current market data. This highlights the importance of checking graded comps before investing in a card solely for the purpose of grading.
Buying Strategy for 2026
| Card | Play | Why | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hasbulla Magomedov [Blue Shimmer] | BUY | High raw value ($3,666) indicates massive demand. While graded ROI is poor, its unique status and pop culture appeal suggest long-term holding potential. | High |
| Bo Nickal [Gold] | HOLD | Strong raw price ($3,000) despite negative graded ROI. Nickal’s rising profile may boost graded prices in the future. Monitor graded market trends. | Medium |
| Rinat Fakhretdinov [Gold Shimmer] | BUY | Solid raw price ($2,500) with no graded data. If graded demand emerges, significant upside is possible. A speculative buy with potential for high reward. | High |
| Bo Nickal [Octagon] | HOLD | Strong raw value ($2,250 raw, $2,900 PSA 10), but grading shows a -3.4% ROI at current fees. Grade only if the raw copy costs $2,161 or less. | Low |
| Alex Pereira [Octagon] | HOLD | High raw price ($2,050) from a major star, but significant negative graded ROI. Hold raw for potential market shifts or if a fan of the fighter. | Medium |
| Hasbulla Magomedov [Mojo] | GRADE | Positive grading ROI (9.7%) at current fees. Raw price ($1,675) and PSA 10 value ($2,375) leave a $180.91 profit per PSA 10. | Low |
| Conor McGregor [Gold Shimmer] | BUY | Accessible entry into top-tier cards ($1,033 raw) from a legend. Lacks graded data, making it a raw card play or speculative grade. McGregor’s name carries value. | Medium |
Pro Tip: For cards with a significant gap between raw and graded prices, like the Hasbulla Magomedov [Blue Shimmer], always perform a detailed cost-benefit analysis before sending for grading. Factor in grading fees, shipping, insurance, and the time value of money against the current PSA 10 median. In cases of extreme negative ROI, holding the raw card as a speculative asset might be more prudent than grading.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most valuable 2023 Panini Prizm UFC card?
The Hasbulla Magomedov [Blue Shimmer] card is currently the most valuable in terms of raw sales, with a recorded price of $3,666. While its graded value is lower, its raw market dominance is undeniable.
Which cards in the 2023 Panini Prizm UFC set offer the best grading ROI?
The Hasbulla Magomedov [Mojo] card is the only one in the top 10 with a positive grading ROI, 9.7% at current fees. The Bo Nickal [Octagon] card comes closest after it but still shows a -3.4% ROI once PSA’s grading fee, eBay’s selling fee and shipping are counted.
Are there any 2023 Panini Prizm UFC cards with no PSA 10 data?
Yes, several cards on this top 10 list, including Rinat Fakhretdinov [Gold Shimmer], Hasbulla Magomedov [Gold], Bo Nickal [Blue Shimmer], and Conor McGregor [Gold Shimmer], currently have no available PSA 10 median data, making their graded market assessment speculative.
Should I grade cards with negative ROI data?
Generally, no, unless you have a strong conviction in future market appreciation or are collecting for personal preference rather than profit. Cards like the Hasbulla Magomedov [Blue Shimmer] (-82.7% ROI) and Alex Pereira [Octagon] (-59.1% ROI) show significant losses when graded based on current data.
The 2023 Panini Prizm UFC set continues to be a dynamic market, driven by a mix of established stars, emerging talent, and internet personalities. As collector interest solidifies around certain athletes and parallels, understanding the data behind raw versus graded values is paramount. For those looking to further explore the UFC trading card landscape, check out our guide on Is 2024 Topps Finest UFC Sports Worth Collecting? 2026 Investment Review for insights into another key UFC release. You can also learn more about the broader world of sports cards on our main hub.