Verified comps. Grading math. No guesswork.
most valuable 2023 panini select ufc cards

Image sourced from eBay listings

Top 10 Most Valuable 2023 Panini Select UFC Cards (2026)

Published 2026-08-29 · Updated 2026-11-05 · by Jason Trogdon
Sports Cards 5 min read
Joe Pyfer [Black Blue] #66RAW $2,750PRICES AS OF Aug 29, 2026

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The most valuable 2023 Panini Select UFC card on file is Joe Pyfer (Black Blue) #66 at $2,750.00 raw. The 10 cards below are ranked by raw price, down to Alex Pereira (Green) #65 at $799.99. 2 of them have a PSA 10 price on file.

In This Article

The Top 10 2023 Panini Select UFC Cards by Raw Price

# Card Raw PSA 10 PSA 10 against raw
1 Joe Pyfer (Black Blue) #66 $2,750.00 — —
2 Bo Nickal (Green) #309 $2,000.00 — —
3 Chuck Liddell $1,500.00 — —
4 Jon Jones (Green Disco) #251 $1,180.00 — —
5 Muhammad Mokaev (Tiger) #215 $999.00 — —
6 Jon Jones (Tiger) #251 $900.00 $380.75 0.4x
7 Islam Makhachev (Disco) #94 $850.00 $26.00 0.0x
8 Khabib Nurmagomedov (Tiger) #97 $827.32 — —
9 Erin Blanchfield (Zebra) #268 $800.00 — —
10 Alex Pereira (Green) #65 $799.99 — —

Data sources: What The Slab checks PriceCharting market prices and eBay sold listings. A dash means no PSA 10 sale on record. Sealed product is not ranked.

Card by Card

1. Joe Pyfer [Black Blue] (66)

Joe Pyfer (Black Blue) #66 is priced at $2,750.00 raw. No PSA 10 sale of Joe Pyfer (Black Blue) #66 is on record.

Joe Pyfer (Black Blue) #66 on eBay

2. Bo Nickal [Green] (309)

Bo Nickal (Green) #309 is priced at $2,000.00 raw. No PSA 10 sale of Bo Nickal (Green) #309 is on record.

Bo Nickal (Green) #309 on eBay

3. Chuck Liddell

Chuck Liddell is priced at $1,500.00 raw. No PSA 10 sale of Chuck Liddell is on record.

Chuck Liddell on eBay

4. Jon Jones [Green Disco] (251)

Jon Jones (Green Disco) #251 is priced at $1,180.00 raw. No PSA 10 sale of Jon Jones (Green Disco) #251 is on record.

Jon Jones (Green Disco) #251 on eBay

5. Muhammad Mokaev [Tiger] (215)

Muhammad Mokaev (Tiger) #215 is priced at $999.00 raw. No PSA 10 sale of Muhammad Mokaev (Tiger) #215 is on record.

Muhammad Mokaev (Tiger) #215 on eBay

6. Jon Jones [Tiger] (251)

Jon Jones (Tiger) #251 is priced at $900.00 raw. A PSA 10 Jon Jones (Tiger) #251 is priced at $380.75, 0.4x the raw price.

Jon Jones (Tiger) #251 on eBay

7. Islam Makhachev [Disco] (94)

Islam Makhachev [Disco] #94

Islam Makhachev (Disco) #94 is priced at $850.00 raw. A PSA 10 Islam Makhachev (Disco) #94 is priced at $26.00, 0.0x the raw price.

Islam Makhachev (Disco) #94 on eBay

8. Khabib Nurmagomedov [Tiger] (97)

Khabib Nurmagomedov (Tiger) #97 is priced at $827.32 raw. No PSA 10 sale of Khabib Nurmagomedov (Tiger) #97 is on record.

Khabib Nurmagomedov (Tiger) #97 on eBay

9. Erin Blanchfield [Zebra] (268)

Erin Blanchfield [Zebra] #268

Erin Blanchfield (Zebra) #268 is priced at $800.00 raw. No PSA 10 sale of Erin Blanchfield (Zebra) #268 is on record.

Erin Blanchfield (Zebra) #268 on eBay

10. Alex Pereira [Green] (65)

Alex Pereira [Green] #65

Alex Pereira (Green) #65 is priced at $799.99 raw. No PSA 10 sale of Alex Pereira (Green) #65 is on record.

Alex Pereira (Green) #65 on eBay

What a Grade Adds

2 of the 10 cards have a PSA 10 price on file. The widest gap is Jon Jones (Tiger) #251, where a PSA 10 is priced at 0.4x the raw price; the narrowest is Islam Makhachev (Disco) #94 at 0.0x. For Jon Jones (Tiger) #251 and Islam Makhachev (Disco) #94 the PSA 10 price on file is below the raw price. What grading costs and leaves after fees is worked out in Is 2023 Panini Select UFC Worth Collecting? Top Cards & Prices.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most valuable 2023 Panini Select UFC card?

By raw price, Joe Pyfer (Black Blue) #66 at $2,750.00.

Which 2023 Panini Select UFC card has the highest PSA 10 price?

Of the cards on this list, Jon Jones (Tiger) #251 at $380.75.

Which of these 2023 Panini Select UFC cards have a PSA 10 sale on record?

Jon Jones (Tiger) #251 and Islam Makhachev (Disco) #94.

What is the tenth most valuable 2023 Panini Select UFC card?

Alex Pereira (Green) #65 at $799.99 raw.

How are these cards ranked?

By raw price, highest first. Sealed product such as booster boxes and bundles is not ranked.


More on Sports Cards across the site.

Data: PriceCharting · eBay sold listings. Analysis: What The Slab. How we get our numbers.

Price data, not financial advice. Past sales don't predict future value. We may earn a commission on eBay, TCGplayer and Amazon links.

Weekly graded sales report

Free weekly email. Unsubscribe anytime.

J

About Jason

Jason has been collecting cards since 1999 and retro video games since 2008. Based in the Southeast US. What The Slab cites real eBay sold comps, PriceCharting data, and PSA pop reports — no guesswork. Read more → · How we get our numbers