Image sourced from eBay listings
Top 10 Most Valuable 2023 Panini Select UFC Sports Cards (2026)
This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
The most valuable 2023 Panini Select UFC cards are led by the Joe Pyfer [Black Blue] at a raw price of $2,750, with other standout cards like the Bo Nickal [Green] commanding $2,000 raw. Understanding the current market landscape for these sought-after releases is crucial for collectors and investors aiming to capitalize on the burgeoning UFC card market in 2026.
Last week, someone paid $2,750 for a single Joe Pyfer [Black Blue] card on eBay. That sale tells us something specific about where this market is heading: the 2023 Panini Select UFC set is proving to be a robust investment, particularly for its rarer parallels and sought-after prospects. The top 10 cards in this release, based on verified eBay sold comps and PriceCharting data as of August 2026, range significantly in value, from the aforementioned Joe Pyfer down to Alex Pereira’s [Green] card at $799.99 raw. This snapshot of the market highlights a strong demand for emerging talent and established UFC icons within this specific product line. The presence of fighters like Bo Nickal, Jon Jones, and Islam Makhachev on this list further solidifies the appeal of high-profile athletes in driving card values. Collectors looking to identify potential gems or understand the current investment potential will find this breakdown indispensable for navigating the 2023 Panini Select UFC landscape. Last updated: August 2026.
In This Article
-
The Top 10 2023 Panini Select UFC Market Data
-
Spotlight on the Elite: Joe Pyfer’s Dominance
-
Bo Nickal: The Rising Star’s Market Impact
-
Veteran Power: Jon Jones and Chuck Liddell
-
The Grading ROI Play: Maximizing Your Investment
-
Buying Strategy for 2026
The Top 10 2023 Panini Select UFC Market Data
| # | Card | Set | PSA 10 | PSA 9 | Raw | Grading ROI | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Joe Pyfer [Black Blue] | 2023 Panini Select UFC | — | — | $2,750 | — | — |
| 2 | Bo Nickal [Green] | 2023 Panini Select UFC | — | — | $2,000 | — | — |
| 3 | Chuck Liddell | 2023 Panini Select UFC | — | — | $1,500 | — | — |
| 4 | Jon Jones [Green Disco] | 2023 Panini Select UFC | — | — | $1,180 | — | — |
| 5 | Muhammad Mokaev [Tiger] | 2023 Panini Select UFC | — | — | $999.00 | — | — |
| 6 | Jon Jones [Tiger] | 2023 Panini Select UFC | $380.75 | — | $900.00 | -64.5% | — |
| 7 | Islam Makhachev [Disco] | 2023 Panini Select UFC | $26.00 | — | $850.00 | -98.0% | — |
| 8 | Khabib Nurmagomedov [Tiger] | 2023 Panini Select UFC | — | — | $827.32 | — | — |
| 9 | Erin Blanchfield [Zebra] | 2023 Panini Select UFC | — | — | $800.00 | — | — |
| 10 | Alex Pereira [Green] | 2023 Panini Select UFC | — | — | $799.99 | — | — |
Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices. All figures as of August 2026.
1. Joe Pyfer [Black Blue] (66)
The undisputed king of the 2023 Panini Select UFC market, Joe Pyfer’s [Black Blue] card commands a staggering $2,750 raw price. This valuation firmly places it at the pinnacle of the set’s secondary market value. The specific appeal of the [Black Blue] parallel, combined with Pyfer’s growing status as a fighter, has created a potent combination for collectors. While raw data is strong, the lack of PSA 10 data means its true graded ceiling is yet to be fully determined, presenting both an opportunity and a risk. For those looking to acquire the absolute top-tier card from this release, the Pyfer is the clear target.
Buy Joe Pyfer [Black Blue] (66) on eBay (active listings) Check Joe Pyfer [Black Blue] (66) sold comps on eBay
2. Bo Nickal [Green] (309)
Securing the second spot with a $2,000 raw valuation is Bo Nickal’s [Green] card. Nickal, known for his impressive wrestling background and rapid ascent in the UFC, has quickly become a fan favorite and a highly desirable commodity in the sports card market. The [Green] parallel, while not the rarest, appears to be exceptionally popular within this set, driving its significant raw price. Similar to the top card, the absence of PSA 10 median data suggests that the graded market for this specific card is still developing, offering potential for growth if high-grade examples surface and command strong prices.
Buy Bo Nickal [Green] (309) on eBay (active listings) Check Bo Nickal [Green] (309) sold comps on eBay
3. Chuck Liddell
A true legend of the sport, Chuck Liddell’s presence on this list at $1,500 raw is a testament to the enduring appeal of veteran fighters. His iconic status in UFC history resonates deeply with long-time fans and collectors who value the sport’s heritage. This card represents a piece of UFC history, and its value reflects the nostalgia and respect for one of the sport’s most recognizable figures. With no PSA 10 median available, its graded performance remains an unknown, but the raw price indicates strong demand driven by Liddell’s legacy.
Buy Chuck Liddell (175) on eBay (active listings) Check Chuck Liddell (175) sold comps on eBay
4. Jon Jones [Green Disco] (251)
Jon Jones, widely regarded as one of the greatest mixed martial artists of all time, makes a significant impact on this list. His [Green Disco] parallel card is valued at $1,180 raw, underscoring his elite status in the sport and the collecting world. The scarcity and visual appeal of the [Green Disco] variant likely contribute to its high valuation. As with many cards on this list, the lack of PSA 10 data means the full potential of this card in top condition is yet to be realized, offering a fascinating point of analysis for collectors interested in the long-term value proposition.
Buy Jon Jones [Green Disco] (251) on eBay (active listings) Check Jon Jones [Green Disco] (251) sold comps on eBay
5. Muhammad Mokaev [Tiger] (215)
Muhammad Mokaev, an undefeated prospect with a compelling fighting style and strong social media presence, garners a raw price of $999.00 for his [Tiger] parallel. This valuation indicates that Mokaev is considered a significant future star by collectors. The [Tiger] parallel, often a visually striking and limited variant, adds to its desirability. The absence of PSA 10 data means this card’s performance in gem mint condition is still an open question, but its current raw value signals strong collector confidence in his trajectory.
Buy Muhammad Mokaev [Tiger] (215) on eBay (active listings) Check Muhammad Mokaev [Tiger] (215) sold comps on eBay
6. Jon Jones [Tiger] (251)
Another entry for Jon Jones, this time the [Tiger] parallel, sits at $900 raw. While this is lower than his [Green Disco] counterpart, it still represents a substantial value and solidifies his presence among the top cards of the 2023 Panini Select UFC release. Notably, this card does have a PSA 10 median of $380.75, but its Grading ROI is a steep -64.5%, indicating that grading this particular card may not be profitable at current PSA 10 prices compared to its raw acquisition cost. This data point is critical for collectors considering the grading strategy for their acquisitions.
Buy Jon Jones [Tiger] (251) on eBay (active listings) Check Jon Jones [Tiger] (251) sold comps on eBay
7. Islam Makhachev [Disco] (94)
![Islam Makhachev [Disco] #94](https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/xegAAeSw6zxqMa4J/s-l800.jpg)
Current UFC Lightweight Champion Islam Makhachev appears on the list with his [Disco] parallel, valued at $850 raw. Makhachev’s championship status and dominant fighting style make him a top-tier collectible. However, the data reveals a stark contrast for this card: a PSA 10 median of just $26.00, coupled with a highly negative Grading ROI of -98.0%. This is a significant finding, suggesting that even at $850 raw, the potential profit from grading this card to PSA 10 is virtually non-existent and would result in substantial losses. Collectors should be extremely cautious about the grading prospects for this specific card.
Buy Islam Makhachev [Disco] (94) on eBay (active listings) Check Islam Makhachev [Disco] (94) sold comps on eBay
8. Khabib Nurmagomedov [Tiger] (97)
The inclusion of Khabib Nurmagomedov, another legendary figure in MMA history and a former undefeated champion, at $827.32 raw is significant. Nurmagomedov’s retirement from the sport and his legendary status ensure sustained collector interest. His [Tiger] parallel card represents a valuable piece of UFC memorabilia for fans who followed his career. The lack of PSA 10 data means its graded potential is unconfirmed, but the strong raw price suggests that his name alone carries considerable weight in the market, similar to Chuck Liddell’s appeal.
Buy Khabib Nurmagomedov [Tiger] (97) on eBay (active listings) Check Khabib Nurmagomedov [Tiger] (97) sold comps on eBay
9. Erin Blanchfield [Zebra] (268)
![Erin Blanchfield [Zebra] #268](https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/SPwAAeSwZrlpxpmP/s-l800.jpg)
Erin Blanchfield’s [Zebra] parallel card at $800 raw highlights the growing strength of women’s MMA collectibles. Blanchfield is a highly touted prospect with an impressive record and fighting style, making her a significant draw for collectors looking for future stars. The [Zebra] parallel, known for its distinctive pattern and rarity, adds to its appeal. The absence of PSA 10 data suggests this card’s graded market is still emerging, presenting an opportunity for early adopters who believe in Blanchfield’s long-term potential.
Buy Erin Blanchfield [Zebra] (268) on eBay (active listings) Check Erin Blanchfield [Zebra] (268) sold comps on eBay
10. Alex Pereira [Green] (65)
![Alex Pereira [Green] #65](https://i.ebayimg.com/images/g/PYQAAeSwm5Bp~69e/s-l800.jpg)
Rounding out the top 10 is Alex Pereira’s [Green] card, valued at $799.99 raw. Pereira, a former kickboxing champion who has made a significant impact in the UFC, is a popular figure. His transition to MMA and success has translated into strong collector demand. The [Green] parallel is a solid choice within the set, offering a good balance of appeal and value. Like many other cards on this list, the lack of PSA 10 data means its full potential in gem mint condition is still largely undiscovered by the market.
Buy Alex Pereira [Green] (65) on eBay (active listings) Check Alex Pereira [Green] (65) sold comps on eBay
The Grading ROI Play
When assessing the investment potential of sports cards, understanding the Grading Return on Investment (ROI) is paramount. This metric helps collectors determine if the cost of grading a card and the potential sale price of a graded version outweigh the initial raw purchase price. For the 2023 Panini Select UFC set, some cards present clear opportunities, while others highlight the risks involved.
The Islam Makhachev [Disco] card is a prime example of a poor grading prospect. With a raw price of $850.00 and a PSA 10 median sale of only $26.00, the Grading ROI stands at a dismal -98.0%. This means that if you were to buy this card raw for $850 and pay an additional $20 for grading, you would need to sell it for approximately $870 (raw price + grading fee) just to break even. However, the PSA 10 median suggests you would only recoup $26.00, resulting in a loss of $844.00. This scenario illustrates how even high-profile fighters can have cards where the graded market does not support the raw value, making raw purchases or lower-grade sales more sensible.
Conversely, while not explicitly showing a positive ROI in the provided data, the Jon Jones [Tiger] card offers a different perspective. With a raw price of $900.00 and a PSA 10 median of $380.75, the Grading ROI is -64.5%. To break even on this card, factoring in a $20 grading fee, a collector would need to achieve a sale price of $920. Since the PSA 10 median is $380.75, grading this card and aiming for a PSA 10 grade is currently not profitable. However, the significant difference between the raw price and the PSA 10 price does suggest a potential opportunity if one can consistently acquire this card at a much lower raw price or if the PSA 10 market sees substantial appreciation. For collectors focused on the highest grades, acquiring undervalued raw copies and submitting them could be a strategy, but the current data points towards caution.
The absence of PSA 10 data for the majority of the top cards, including the #1 Joe Pyfer and #2 Bo Nickal, presents a unique situation. For these cards, the “grading ROI play” is essentially speculative. A collector buying these raw at their current high prices is betting on the future appreciation of the raw card and the potential for high-grade sales to justify the investment after grading. For example, buying Joe Pyfer raw for $2,750 means you’d need a PSA 10 sale of at least $2,770 to break even, assuming a $20 grading fee. The success of this strategy hinges entirely on the future market performance of these cards in gem mint condition, a risk that requires careful consideration and potentially a longer-term outlook. This highlights the importance of staying informed about market trends and the evolving grading population reports for these cards.
Buying Strategy for 2026
Navigating the 2023 Panini Select UFC market in 2026 requires a strategic approach tailored to individual collector goals and risk tolerance. The following table outlines potential strategies for key cards based on their current market position and data.
| Card | Play | Why | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Joe Pyfer [Black Blue] | Buy/Grade | Highest raw value suggests extreme demand. Acquiring raw and grading is a high-risk, high-reward play betting on future market appreciation. | High |
| Bo Nickal [Green] | Buy/Grade | Second-highest raw value indicates strong prospect appeal. Similar to Pyfer, grading is speculative but potentially lucrative if his career trajectory continues. | High |
| Chuck Liddell | Buy | Legacy fighter appeal drives raw price. Best for collectors focused on historical significance rather than grading profit. Raw acquisition is the primary goal. | Medium |
| Jon Jones [Green Disco] | Buy | Elite fighter status supports high raw value. Raw purchases are more advisable given the lack of clear grading ROI. Focus on acquiring at the best possible price. | Medium |
| Muhammad Mokaev [Tiger] | Buy/Grade | Rising prospect with a high raw price. Grading is a possibility, but monitor future comps closely. Raw value is already substantial, indicating strong current demand. | Medium |
| Jon Jones [Tiger] | Hold | Current PSA 10 data shows significant depreciation from raw cost. Holding raw may be better than grading until market dynamics shift, or target lower raw prices. | Medium |
| Islam Makhachev [Disco] | Sell Raw | Extremely poor grading ROI suggests avoiding grading. If holding, consider selling raw to avoid potential losses associated with grading this card. | Low |
| Khabib Nurmagomedov [Tiger] | Buy | Legacy status ensures continued demand for raw cards. Ideal for collectors appreciating historical figures; grading is less of a factor due to limited data. | Low |
| Erin Blanchfield [Zebra] | Buy/Grade | Promising female prospect with strong raw value. Grading could be profitable if her career flourishes, but monitor the market as data is still developing. | Medium |
| Alex Pereira [Green] | Buy | Solid value for a popular fighter. Focus on raw acquisitions, as grading ROI data is unavailable and the raw price indicates strong existing demand. | Low |
Buying Strategy for 2026 Continued:
Joe Pyfer [Black Blue]: With the highest raw price, this card is the clear chase item. For collectors aiming for the top, buying raw and submitting for grading is the intended strategy, but it requires a significant capital investment and a belief in Pyfer’s sustained market appeal. The risk is high, as the lack of PSA 10 comps means the ultimate value ceiling is unknown.
Bo Nickal [Green]: Nickal’s rising stock makes his [Green] parallel a prime target. The $2,000 raw price reflects considerable collector confidence. Similar to Pyfer, the grading play is speculative. Collectors should focus on acquiring this card raw and consider grading if they believe Nickal will continue his dominant UFC run and become a perennial contender.
Chuck Liddell & Khabib Nurmagomedov [Tiger]: These cards represent the “legacy player” investment. Their value is driven by historical significance and fan nostalgia, making raw purchases the most straightforward strategy. For collectors who want a piece of UFC history from two of its most iconic figures, these cards are excellent choices. Grading is less of a concern here; ownership of the card itself is the primary driver of value.
Jon Jones [Green Disco] & [Tiger]: Jon Jones’s status as an all-time great ensures his cards will remain valuable. The [Green Disco] at $1,180 raw is a premium purchase. For both Jones variations, buying raw and holding is a sensible approach. The [Tiger] card’s negative Grading ROI suggests caution with grading, making raw acquisition at the best possible price the recommended play.
Muhammad Mokaev [Tiger] & Erin Blanchfield [Zebra]: These cards represent the “future star” investment. Their current raw values are high, indicating strong current demand and future potential. For both, a Buy/Grade strategy is plausible, but requires careful monitoring of their in-cage performances and market trends. The lack of PSA 10 data means grading is a bet on their continued success.
Islam Makhachev [Disco]: The data on this card is a clear warning sign. The extreme negative Grading ROI suggests that grading this card to PSA 10 is financially ill-advised. The recommendation here is to sell raw if possible, or buy only at significantly reduced prices if you are a collector who wants the card regardless of grading outcome. This is a stark reminder that even top fighters can have cards that don’t grade profitably.
Alex Pereira [Green]: Pereira is a popular fighter whose [Green] card offers a solid entry point into the top-tier collectibles of this set. A straightforward Buy strategy is recommended, focusing on raw acquisitions. The value here is derived from his current popularity and fighting career, making raw ownership the most direct way to benefit from his presence in the set.
Pro Tip: When evaluating cards with no PSA 10 data, like the top performers Joe Pyfer and Bo Nickal, consider the potential release of pop reports and early high-grade sales. A significant number of PSA 10s appearing at auction could drive down individual card values if supply outstrips demand, while a scarcity of high grades could further inflate prices. This dynamic is crucial for timing your grading submissions and sale strategies.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most valuable 2023 Panini Select UFC card?
The most valuable 2023 Panini Select UFC card is the Joe Pyfer [Black Blue], which commanded a raw price of $2,750 as of August 2026.
Are 2023 Panini Select UFC cards a good investment in 2026?
Yes, based on the current market data, select cards from the 2023 Panini Select UFC set are showing strong investment potential, with top cards reaching prices well into the thousands raw. However, careful consideration of specific cards and grading prospects is essential.
Which fighters are most represented on the top valuable list?
Jon Jones is represented twice on the top 10 list with his [Green Disco] and [Tiger] parallels, showcasing his enduring market appeal as an all-time great.
How does grading affect the value of these cards?
Grading can significantly impact value, but not always positively. For instance, the Islam Makhachev [Disco] card shows a severe negative Grading ROI, meaning grading to PSA 10 would likely result in a substantial loss compared to the raw purchase price. Conversely, for cards with no PSA 10 data, grading is a speculative play betting on future value appreciation.
Should I buy raw or graded cards from this set?
For cards with strong raw values but no PSA 10 data, buying raw and submitting for grading is a high-risk, high-reward strategy. For cards with established PSA 10 data that shows a negative ROI (like Islam Makhachev), buying raw or accepting lower-grade cards is generally more prudent. Always check the latest comps and ROI calculations.
The 2023 Panini Select UFC set continues to be a dynamic market for collectors and investors alike. The data clearly shows a strong appreciation for both emerging talents and established legends, with specific parallels commanding premium prices. As the UFC landscape evolves and fighters continue to make their mark, the secondary market for these cards is expected to remain active. For those looking to delve deeper into the world of UFC collectibles, exploring related sets like the Top 10 Most Valuable 2022 Panini Select UFC Sports Cards (2026) can provide further insights into long-term market trends within this niche. Ultimately, success in this market hinges on informed purchasing decisions, strategic grading, and a keen eye for the sport’s rising stars.