2026-08-13-top-10-most-valuable-2016-panini-unparalleled-cards-2026

title: “Top 10 Most Valuable 2016 Panini Unparalleled Sports Cards (2026)” date: 2026-08-13 description: “Explore the top 10 most valuable 2016 Panini Unparalleled sports cards. Tom Brady’s Burst card leads at $5,000 raw. Get investment insights.” keyword: “most valuable 2016 panini unparalleled sports cards” niche: “Sports Cards” hero_image: “” This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The most valuable 2016 Panini Unparalleled sports cards are led by elite quarterback talent, with Tom Brady’s [Burst] card commanding a raw price of $5,000. Following closely is Brady’s [Triple Memorabilia] card at $1,300, highlighting the significant market demand for his premier issues from this set. These figures represent the current raw market values as of August 2026, informing collectors on high-tier investment potential.

Your LCS has a case full of 2016 Panini Unparalleled cards. The question isn’t what to buy — it’s which one survives the next market correction. In August 2026, the landscape for this particular Panini release remains dominated by a few key players, with Tom Brady taking center stage. His [Burst] card, listed at a robust $5,000 raw, stands as the undisputed king of this set’s market value, outclassing all other entries by a significant margin. Following in his wake, Brady’s [Triple Memorabilia] card secures the second spot with a $1,300 raw valuation, underscoring the enduring appeal of memorabilia inserts featuring top-tier athletes. The list then dips into the hundreds, with Richard Sherman’s [Green] card at $499.99 and another Brady entry, the [Green] variant, at $399.99, demonstrating that while Brady’s presence is dominant, other star players and special variants still hold considerable sway. This data, derived from 90-day eBay sold comps and PriceCharting data, paints a clear picture of where the current investment focus lies within the 2016 Panini Unparalleled collection. Last updated: August 2026.

In This Article

• The Top 10 2016 Panini Unparalleled Market Data

• 1. Tom Brady [Burst] (Card #13)

• 2. Tom Brady [Triple Memorabilia] (Card #99)

• 3. Richard Sherman [Green] (Card #132)

• 4. Tom Brady [Green] (Card #99)

The Top 10 2016 Panini Unparalleled Market Data

Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices. All figures as of August 2026.

1. Tom Brady [Burst] (13)

The undisputed heavyweight champion of the 2016 Panini Unparalleled set, Tom Brady’s [Burst] card, stands alone at the pinnacle of value, boasting a raw price of $5,000 as of August 2026. This commanding figure is a testament to Brady’s unparalleled legacy in the sport and the consistent demand for his high-end collectibles. The “Burst” designation, often indicative of dynamic artwork or a special insert technology, likely contributes to its premium status. While PSA 10 data is not available, the sheer raw value suggests that even at lower grades, this card is a significant investment. For collectors seeking the absolute top tier of this release, this Tom Brady card is the prime target. Its raw valuation sets a high bar, making it a centerpiece for any serious 2016 Panini Unparalleled collection. The lack of grading data means collectors are buying into the raw market perception, which is currently exceptionally strong for this specific card.

Buy Tom Brady [Burst] (13) on eBay (active listings) Check Tom Brady [Burst] (13) sold comps on eBay

2. Tom Brady [Triple Memorabilia] (99)

Securing the second position on our list, Tom Brady’s [Triple Memorabilia] card, Card #99, commands a substantial raw price of $1,300. This valuation highlights the strong market appetite for cards featuring not just the athlete’s likeness but also tangible pieces of game-used memorabilia. The “Triple Memorabilia” designation indicates the presence of three distinct swatches, adding a significant layer of desirability for collectors who appreciate the tactile and historical aspect of sports cards. As with the top-ranked card, PSA 10 data is not provided, meaning the $1,300 figure represents the current going rate for raw, ungraded copies. This card represents a more accessible, yet still highly valuable, entry point into the top echelon of 2016 Panini Unparalleled investments, showcasing the dual appeal of star power and premium insert features.

Buy Tom Brady [Triple Memorabilia] (99) on eBay (active listings) Check Tom Brady [Triple Memorabilia] (99) sold comps on eBay

3. Richard Sherman [Green] (132)

Richard Sherman’s [Green] variant, card number 132, emerges as the third most valuable card in the 2016 Panini Unparalleled set, with a raw price point of $499.99. This positions Sherman as a significant player in the aftermarket for this release, demonstrating that the set’s value isn’t exclusively tied to quarterbacks. The “[Green]” descriptor suggests a color variation or parallel that distinguishes it from the base card, often indicating a more limited print run or a special aesthetic appeal that drives up demand. Without graded population data, the $499.99 raw value reflects the current market’s assessment of its desirability. For collectors looking to diversify their high-value holdings within this set, Sherman’s [Green] card offers a compelling option, representing a strong defensive talent at a notable price point.

Buy Richard Sherman [Green] (132) on eBay (active listings) Check Richard Sherman [Green] (132) sold comps on eBay

4. Tom Brady [Green] (99)

Tom Brady reappears on the list with his [Green] variant card, number 99, holding the fourth spot with a raw price of $399.99. This indicates that even at a different variant level, Brady’s cards from the 2016 Panini Unparalleled set maintain significant market traction. The “[Green]” parallel designation implies a similar rarity or visual distinction as seen with Richard Sherman’s card, suggesting these color variants are a key driver of value within this release. The $399.99 raw price point signifies a strong, albeit lower, demand compared to his top-tier cards, still making it a highly sought-after item. For collectors focused on Brady’s extensive offerings in this set, this [Green] variant presents a more attainable, yet still premium, acquisition.

Buy Tom Brady [Green] (99) on eBay (active listings) Check Tom Brady [Green] (99) sold comps on eBay

5. Derrick Henry [Autograph Jersey Prime Blue] (212)

Derrick Henry’s [Autograph Jersey Prime Blue] card, number 212, enters the top ten at the fifth position with a raw value of $365.00. This card represents a significant entry for a running back, highlighting Henry’s status as a generational talent even during his earlier career stages, as reflected in the 2016 release. The inclusion of an autograph and a “Jersey Prime Blue” designation suggests a premium insert featuring a swatch of his uniform, potentially in a blue color variant, paired with his signature. This combination of autograph and prime memorabilia pieces is a strong driver of value in the sports card market. The $365.00 raw price indicates a robust demand for this particular offering, making it an attractive target for collectors interested in modern stars and autographed rookie cards.

Buy Derrick Henry [Autograph Jersey Prime Blue] (212) on eBay (active listings) Check Derrick Henry [Autograph Jersey Prime Blue] (212) sold comps on eBay

6. Tony Romo [Autograph Red] (51)

Tony Romo’s [Autograph Red] card, number 51, captures the sixth spot with a raw price of $350.00. Romo, a highly popular former NFL quarterback known for his playing career and subsequent broadcasting success, continues to hold significant collector interest. The presence of an autograph on this card, coupled with a “[Red]” designation that likely denotes a specific parallel or insert tier, significantly contributes to its market value. The $350.00 raw valuation suggests that collectors are willing to invest in autographed memorabilia from notable players, even if they are not currently active in the league. This card is a strong contender for collectors who appreciate quarterback legends and the appeal of signed cards from this Panini release.

Buy Tony Romo [Autograph Red] (51) on eBay (active listings) Check Tony Romo [Autograph Red] (51) sold comps on eBay

7. John Elway [Autograph Red] (78)

Legendary quarterback John Elway is represented at number seven with his [Autograph Red] card, card #78, valued at $299.95 raw. Elway, an icon of the game with multiple Super Bowl championships, commands enduring respect and demand within the hobby. The inclusion of his autograph, paired with a “[Red]” parallel, points to a premium, signed collectible. At $299.95 raw, this card offers a significant piece of NFL history from a true legend, appealing to collectors who prioritize iconic players and authenticated signatures. The value reflects the gravitas associated with Elway’s name and career, making this an attractive acquisition for those building a collection around NFL’s greatest quarterbacks or seeking high-end autographs.

Buy John Elway [Autograph Red] (78) on eBay (active listings) Check John Elway [Autograph Red] (78) sold comps on eBay

8. Ben Roethlisberger [Autograph Blue] (41)

Ben Roethlisberger, another prominent NFL quarterback, is featured at number eight with his [Autograph Blue] card, designated as card #41. This card is valued at $279.87 raw. Roethlisberger enjoyed a long and successful career, winning multiple Super Bowls, which solidifies his place as a desirable player for collectors. The “[Autograph Blue]” inscription suggests a signed card with a blue variant or parallel, further enhancing its appeal. The raw price of $279.87 indicates consistent demand for his autographed memorabilia, particularly within the context of this 2016 Panini Unparalleled release. This card is a strong choice for collectors focused on quarterbacking legends and signed rookie or star cards.

Buy Ben Roethlisberger [Autograph Blue] (41) on eBay (active listings) Check Ben Roethlisberger [Autograph Blue] (41) sold comps on eBay

9. Brett Favre [Autograph Red] (66)

Hall of Fame quarterback Brett Favre makes an appearance at number nine with his [Autograph Red] card, number 66, valued at $250.00 raw. Favre’s legendary status, characterized by his remarkable durability and numerous records, ensures his continued popularity among collectors. The “[Autograph Red]” designation suggests a signed card with a red variant or parallel. At $250.00 raw, this card offers a piece of NFL history from one of the game’s most iconic figures, appealing to those who appreciate vintage autographs and legendary player cards from recent releases. Its inclusion demonstrates the lasting appeal of Hall of Fame talent in driving card values.

Buy Brett Favre [Autograph Red] (66) on eBay (active listings) Check Brett Favre [Autograph Red] (66) sold comps on eBay

10. Rob Gronkowski [Triple Memorabilia] (93)

Rounding out the top ten is tight end Rob Gronkowski, with his [Triple Memorabilia] card, number 93, valued at $249.99 raw. Gronkowski, known for his dominant physical play and multiple Super Bowl victories, remains a popular figure in the collecting world. The “[Triple Memorabilia]” component signifies the presence of three game-used swatches, adding a layer of premium appeal. At $249.99 raw, this card offers collectors a chance to own a piece of a legendary offensive weapon from the 2016 Panini Unparalleled set. It appeals to fans of elite tight ends and those who value memorabilia cards of impactful players.

Buy Rob Gronkowski [Triple Memorabilia] (93) on eBay (active listings) Check Rob Gronkowski [Triple Memorabilia] (93) sold comps on eBay

The Grading ROI Play

While this 2016 Panini Unparalleled set doesn’t currently have readily available PSA 10 median prices to calculate specific grading return on investment (ROI) figures, the raw prices themselves offer insight into potential investment strategies. For cards like the Tom Brady [Burst] at $5,000 raw, the inherent value is so high that the primary goal for collectors would be to acquire it in the best possible condition. If a PSA 10 grade for this card were to surface and command a significant multiplier—say, a 1.5x to 2x increase over the raw price, pushing it to $7,500-$10,000—the grading investment would be highly profitable, assuming a pristine example could be found.

Similarly, for cards like Tom Brady’s [Triple Memorabilia] ($1,300 raw) or Richard Sherman’s [Green] ($499.99 raw), the strategy remains focused on preservation. If a grading fee of $20 per card is considered, the break-even point for a PSA 10 sale would need to exceed $1,320 for the Brady memorabilia card and $519.99 for the Sherman. This analysis highlights that while specific ROI percentages are elusive without PSA 10 data, the premium paid for raw cards like these suggests a strong market anticipation for high-grade examples to significantly outperform their raw valuations. Collectors should prioritize cards that are already commanding high raw prices and focus on finding near-perfect specimens to maximize potential grading returns.

Pro Tip: Given the current lack of PSA 10 data for the top cards in the 2016 Panini Unparalleled set, collectors should focus on raw card acquisition with an eye towards future grading potential. Prioritize cards with exceptional centering and clean surfaces, as these factors will be critical in achieving a high grade. The significant raw prices for Tom Brady and other stars indicate strong underlying demand, suggesting that well-graded copies, when they become available and their values are established, could offer substantial returns.

Buying Strategy for 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most valuable 2016 Panini Unparalleled sports card?

As of August 2026, the Tom Brady [Burst] card (Card #13) is the most valuable, with a raw price of $5,000. This card leads the market for the 2016 Panini Unparalleled set due to Brady’s immense popularity and the card’s likely rare or special designation.

Are there PSA 10 prices available for the top 2016 Panini Unparalleled cards?

Currently, verified PSA 10 median prices are not available in the provided data for the top cards in the 2016 Panini Unparalleled set. This means that market values are based on raw card sales, and the true graded market multipliers are yet to be fully established.

Which players dominate the top 10 most valuable 2016 Panini Unparalleled cards?

Tom Brady is the most dominant player, appearing multiple times in the top ranks. Other notable players include Richard Sherman, Derrick Henry, Tony Romo, John Elway, Ben Roethlisberger, Brett Favre, and Rob Gronkowski, indicating a strong focus on star power and accomplished athletes from this release.

Should I buy raw or graded versions of these cards in 2026?

Given the lack of established PSA 10 prices, buying raw cards from the 2016 Panini Unparalleled set offers flexibility. However, collectors should prioritize finding raw cards in near-perfect condition (excellent centering, sharp corners, and clean surfaces) to maximize potential grading returns if they choose to grade them later.

The 2016 Panini Unparalleled set, while perhaps not a flagship release in the same vein as some other annual sports card products, still holds significant value for collectors and investors, primarily driven by top-tier talent and premium insert designs. The dominance of Tom Brady in the top rankings is expected, given his status as arguably the greatest quarterback of all time and his consistent market appeal. However, the presence of other stars like Richard Sherman, Derrick Henry, and iconic legends such as John Elway and Brett Favre, particularly on autographed or memorabilia cards, demonstrates the breadth of appeal within this set. For those looking to invest or complete a collection, focusing on these high-value cards, especially those with autograph or prime memorabilia features, presents a clear path. Understanding the market dynamics, as reflected in these raw sales figures, is crucial for making informed decisions. For further insights into similar investment opportunities in the sports card market, explore our guide on Is 2026 Panini Donruss NASCAR Sports Worth Collecting? 2026 Investment Review.