Image sourced from eBay listings
Top 10 Most Valuable 2019 Topps Total Sports Cards (2026)
This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
The top 10 most valuable 2019 Topps Total sports cards, based on verified eBay sold comps and PriceCharting data as of July 2026, range from $149.95 to $499.99 raw. Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s autograph card leads this list at $499.99 raw, closely followed by Albert Pujols’ autograph also at $499.99 raw, and Juan Soto’s autograph at $399.99 raw, highlighting the significant demand for star player autographs.
Everyone’s hyping the top cards in the 2019 Topps Total release. The smarter play, however, might be the Josh Naylor Gold parallel ranked at #4 on this list, demonstrating that while autographs command the highest prices, select parallels can offer compelling value. As of July 2026, the market for this set continues to be driven by iconic talent and desirable parallels, with a clear stratification between autograph cards, high-tier parallels, and the remaining checklist. Understanding this hierarchy is crucial for collectors looking to capitalize on the set’s investment potential. The raw prices for the top cards paint a vivid picture of current collector demand, with the top three spots entirely occupied by autographed cards. This trend underscores the enduring appeal and premium placed on signed memorabilia from established and emerging stars.
Based on 90-day eBay sold data and PriceCharting comps, the top 10 2019 Topps Total cards range from $149.95 to $499.99 raw. Here’s the investment-grade breakdown, focusing on key autographs and parallels that are commanding attention in 2026. Last updated: July 2026.
In This Article
-
The Top 10 2019 Topps Total Market Data
-
- Vladimir Guerrero Jr. [Autograph] (#103-A)
-
- Albert Pujols [Autograph] (#843-A)
-
- Juan Soto [Autograph] (#102-A)
-
- Josh Naylor [Gold] (#621C)
-
- Mike Trout [Red] (#1A)
The Top 10 2019 Topps Total Market Data
| # | Card | Set | PSA 10 | PSA 9 | Raw | Grading ROI | Trend |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Vladimir Guerrero Jr. [Autograph] | 103-A | — | — | $499.99 | — | — |
| 2 | Albert Pujols [Autograph] | 843-A | — | — | $499.99 | — | — |
| 3 | Juan Soto [Autograph] | 102-A | — | — | $399.99 | — | — |
| 4 | Josh Naylor [Gold] | 621C | — | — | $317.50 | — | — |
| 5 | Mike Trout [Red] | 1A | — | — | $199.99 | — | — |
| 6 | Ronald Acuna Jr. [Autograph] | 2-A | — | — | $169.95 | — | — |
| 7 | Shohei Ohtani [Red] | 701A | — | — | $155.30 | — | — |
| 8 | Corbin Burnes [Black] | 780B | — | — | $149.99 | — | — |
| 9 | Bryce Harper [Red] | 301A | — | — | $149.99 | — | — |
| 10 | Framber Valdez [Gold] | 238C | — | — | $149.95 | — | — |
Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices. All figures as of July 2026.
1. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. [Autograph] (103-A)
Leading the charge for the 2019 Topps Total release is the Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Autograph card, commanding a significant raw price of $499.99 as of July 2026. This valuation reflects Guerrero Jr.’s status as one of baseball’s premier sluggers, a player whose cards consistently draw high demand from collectors eager to secure a piece of his legacy. While no PSA 10 data is available for this specific card in our verified dataset, its high raw price suggests a strong collector base and a belief in its long-term value. For those looking to acquire a top-tier card from this set, the Vladdy Jr. autograph represents the pinnacle of desirability, offering a clear statement piece for any high-end sports card collection. The presence of his signature directly on the card adds a layer of authenticity and personal connection that mass-produced parallels simply cannot replicate. This card is a prime target for collectors seeking to invest in the future Hall of Famer’s cardboard representation.
Buy Vladimir Guerrero Jr. [Autograph] (103-A) on eBay (active listings) Check Vladimir Guerrero Jr. [Autograph] (103-A) sold comps on eBay
2. Albert Pujols [Autograph] (843-A)
Holding its own at the top of the 2019 Topps Total checklist is the Albert Pujols Autograph card, also valued at $499.99 raw as of July 2026. This price point for a legendary figure like Pujols is a testament to his enduring impact on the game of baseball and the sustained collector interest in his career memorabilia. Even late in his illustrious career, Pujols’ cards, especially those bearing his autograph, continue to be highly sought after. The $499.99 raw price indicates that collectors are willing to pay a premium for his signature on a card from this set. Without available PSA 10 data, the raw price serves as the primary indicator of its current market value. This card offers a unique opportunity for collectors to own a piece of modern baseball history signed by one of its greatest ambassadors. It represents a significant investment, akin to collecting artifacts from a revered historical figure.
Buy Albert Pujols [Autograph] (843-A) on eBay (active listings) Check Albert Pujols [Autograph] (843-A) sold comps on eBay
3. Juan Soto [Autograph] (102-A)
Juan Soto’s Autograph card from the 2019 Topps Total set secures the third spot with a raw price of $399.99 as of July 2026. Soto has rapidly ascended to superstardom, and his early autographed cards, like this one, are prime targets for collectors anticipating his continued dominance and eventual Hall of Fame career. The $399.99 raw valuation is a strong indicator of his current market appeal, placing him firmly among the elite names in the hobby. With no PSA 10 data available for this card, the raw price is the key metric for assessing its market position. This autographed gem represents an investment in one of the game’s most exciting young talents. For collectors focused on the future of baseball, this Soto autograph is a compelling addition, potentially offering substantial long-term growth as his career unfolds.
Buy Juan Soto [Autograph] (102-A) on eBay (active listings) Check Juan Soto [Autograph] (102-A) sold comps on eBay
4. Josh Naylor [Gold] (621C)
Breaking into the top tier of valuable 2019 Topps Total cards is the Josh Naylor Gold parallel, listed at a raw price of $317.50 as of July 2026. This card’s impressive valuation, especially among non-autograph cards, highlights the significant collector appreciation for premium parallels within this set. The Gold parallel offers a visually striking aesthetic and a scarcity that appeals to collectors seeking unique and valuable additions. While it lacks an autograph, its strong performance in raw sales data suggests a robust demand, positioning it as a potentially undervalued asset compared to some of the higher-priced autographs if graded highly. The lack of PSA 10 data means its current market value is primarily dictated by raw sales. This card presents a unique investment opportunity for those who understand the power of parallels. It stands as a testament to how color variations and limited print runs can significantly drive collector interest and value, even for players who may not be at the absolute zenith of superstardom.
Buy Josh Naylor [Gold] (621C) on eBay (active listings) Check Josh Naylor [Gold] (621C) sold comps on eBay
5. Mike Trout [Red] (1A)
The Mike Trout Red parallel card from the 2019 Topps Total set is a significant entry at number five, with a raw price of $199.99 as of July 2026. Mike Trout is arguably the greatest player of his generation, and any card featuring him, especially a parallel from a mainstream release, is bound to attract attention. The Red parallel, while not an autograph, carries the weight of Trout’s name and a desirable color variant. Its strong raw price confirms his status as a perennial draw in the sports card market. Similar to other cards on this list, the absence of PSA 10 data means the raw sales figures are the primary indicator of value. This card is a solid buy for collectors who prioritize player pedigree and recognize the consistent appreciation of Mike Trout’s baseball cards. It offers a tangible connection to one of the sport’s most dominant figures, making it a cornerstone for many collections.
Buy Mike Trout [Red] (1A) on eBay (active listings) Check Mike Trout [Red] (1A) sold comps on eBay
6. Ronald Acuna Jr. [Autograph] (2-A)
Ronald Acuna Jr.’s Autograph card from the 2019 Topps Total set ranks sixth, with a raw price of $169.95 as of July 2026. Acuna Jr. is another electrifying talent in Major League Baseball, known for his speed, power, and exciting play. His autographed cards are highly coveted by collectors who see him as a franchise cornerstone and a future star. The $169.95 raw price signifies a strong demand, positioning this card as a valuable addition for anyone looking to capture the essence of modern baseball’s rising stars. Without PSA 10 data in our verified records, the raw price is the primary metric for its current market standing. This card offers collectors a chance to own a signed piece from an MVP-caliber player, making it a potentially rewarding long-term investment. It’s a key piece for fans of dynamic offensive talent.
Buy Ronald Acuna Jr. [Autograph] (2-A) on eBay (active listings) Check Ronald Acuna Jr. [Autograph] (2-A) sold comps on eBay
7. Shohei Ohtani [Red] (701A)
The Shohei Ohtani Red parallel from the 2019 Topps Total set is at number seven, valued at $155.30 raw as of July 2026. Ohtani’s unique ability to excel as both a pitcher and a hitter has made him a global phenomenon and a massive draw in the trading card market. Any card featuring Ohtani, especially a limited parallel like the Red, is of significant interest to collectors worldwide. The $155.30 raw price reflects his unparalleled market demand. As with many cards on this list, the absence of PSA 10 data means the raw sale price is the most accurate gauge of its current value. This card represents a chance to own a piece of baseball history featuring one of the most exciting and talented players ever to play the game. It’s a prime example of how generational talent transcends traditional card collecting metrics.
Buy Shohei Ohtani [Red] (701A) on eBay (active listings) Check Shohei Ohtani [Red] (701A) sold comps on eBay
8. Corbin Burnes [Black] (780B)
Corbin Burnes’ Black parallel card from the 2019 Topps Total set lands at number eight, with a raw price of $149.99 as of July 2026. Burnes has established himself as one of the premier pitchers in baseball, known for his dominant fastball and devastating slider. His cards, particularly parallels from sought-after sets, are gaining traction among collectors who recognize his elite talent. The $149.99 raw price indicates a solid market presence for Burnes, demonstrating that top-tier pitchers can command significant value. With no PSA 10 data available, the raw sales figures are the primary indicator of its current value. This card represents a strong holding for collectors interested in top pitching talent, offering a pathway into collecting elite pitchers. It’s a good example of how current performance translates to collector demand.
Buy Corbin Burnes [Black] (780B) on eBay (active listings) Check Corbin Burnes [Black] (780B) sold comps on eBay
9. Bryce Harper [Red] (301A)
Bryce Harper’s Red parallel card from the 2019 Topps Total set rounds out the top ten, also valued at $149.99 raw as of July 2026. Bryce Harper is a perennial superstar and an icon of the modern game, whose cards are always in demand. The Red parallel offers a touch of rarity and visual appeal, making it an attractive option for collectors. His consistent performance and MVP-caliber talent ensure his cards remain relevant and valuable. The $149.99 raw price reflects his established market status. As with other cards lacking PSA 10 data in our verified records, the raw price is the key metric. This card is a sound investment for collectors who value proven talent and consistent market demand. It’s a tangible piece of a player who has defined an era of baseball.
Buy Bryce Harper [Red] (301A) on eBay (active listings) Check Bryce Harper [Red] (301A) sold comps on eBay
10. Framber Valdez [Gold] (238C)
Concluding the top 10 is Framber Valdez’s Gold parallel card from the 2019 Topps Total set, with a raw price of $149.95 as of July 2026. Valdez has emerged as one of baseball’s most reliable and dominant starting pitchers, known for his sinker and high ground ball rate. His recent success has driven increased collector interest in his cards, especially his parallels. The $149.95 raw price indicates a strong and growing market for Valdez, suggesting that collectors are recognizing his elite pitching capabilities. With no PSA 10 data available, the raw sales figures provide the most accurate snapshot of its current market value. This card is a strategic pickup for collectors focusing on top pitching talent who may still be ascending in the hobby’s valuation hierarchy. It represents a smart buy for those looking for value in the current market.
Buy Framber Valdez [Gold] (238C) on eBay (active listings) Check Framber Valdez [Gold] (238C) sold comps on eBay
The Grading ROI Play
While the 2019 Topps Total set doesn’t have readily available PSA 10 data across the board in our verified dataset, the concept of Grading ROI remains a critical factor for collectors in 2026. For cards with a high raw price and an absence of graded comps, the gamble on grading becomes more pronounced.
Consider the Josh Naylor [Gold] card (#621C), which holds a raw price of $317.50. If a collector were to purchase this card raw and then grade it, the costs would include the card purchase plus grading fees, which can range from $20-$50 depending on the service and turnaround time. To break even on a $317.50 purchase plus a $30 grading fee (totaling $347.50), a PSA 10 grade would need to sell for at least $347.50. The potential profit lies in exceeding this break-even point. If this card were to achieve a PSA 10 grade and sell for, say, $500, the profit before fees would be substantial. The risk, of course, is receiving a lower grade (PSA 9 or below), which would likely result in a loss.
Similarly, the Mike Trout [Red] card (#1A) at $199.99 raw presents a similar scenario. Adding a $30 grading fee brings the total investment to $229.99. To break even, a PSA 10 would need to sell for at least $230. If a PSA 10 grade were to command $300, that’s a healthy return on investment. The key is identifying cards with a strong raw market that also have the potential to achieve a high grade due to factors like centering, surface, and edge condition. Without official PSA 10 medians, collectors are relying on market anticipation and visual inspection to make these educated guesses about grading potential.
Buying Strategy for 2026
| Card | Play | Why | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vladimir Guerrero Jr. [Autograph] | Buy/Hold | Elite prospect and established star. Autographs are the pinnacle of collector desire. High barrier to entry, but strong long-term potential. | High: Price volatility, dependence on career trajectory. |
| Albert Pujols [Autograph] | Buy/Hold | Legendary status ensures sustained demand. A signature piece for any modern baseball collection. | Moderate: Near career-end, value tied to legacy more than future performance. |
| Juan Soto [Autograph] | Buy | Young superstar with MVP potential. Early autographs are prime targets for growth. | Moderate: Upside is high, but less proven than Pujols or Trout historically. |
| Josh Naylor [Gold] | Buy | High-performing parallel. Offers a more accessible entry point to elite value than autographs, with strong visual appeal. | Moderate: Relies on continued player performance and parallel appreciation. |
| Mike Trout [Red] | Buy/Hold | GOAT contender. His cards are always in demand regardless of set. A safe, stable investment. | Low-Moderate: Price is high, but Trout’s market is historically robust. |
| Ronald Acuna Jr. [Autograph] | Buy | Dynamic young star with MVP capabilities. His autographs represent significant upside potential. | Moderate: Similar to Soto, dependent on continued career success. |
| Shohei Ohtani [Red] | Buy/Hold | Unprecedented talent. His unique appeal drives demand for all his cards. A blue-chip asset. | Moderate: Price reflects current hype; long-term impact still unfolding. |
| Corbin Burnes [Black] | Watch/Buy | Elite pitcher. Black parallel offers scarcity. Good for pitching collectors seeking value. | Moderate: Pitcher cards can be more volatile than hitter cards. |
| Bryce Harper [Red] | Buy/Hold | MVP caliber player with a proven track record. His cards are consistently valuable. | Moderate: Already established, value tied to continued strong performance. |
| Framber Valdez [Gold] | Watch | Emerging ace pitcher. Gold parallel offers collectibility. Potential for future growth as his career continues. | Moderate-High: Less proven than Burnes or Harper; speculative play. |
Pro Tip: For the 2019 Topps Total set in 2026, focus on the player’s career trajectory and the specific appeal of the card type. Autographs from generational talents like Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Albert Pujols offer immediate high value due to their established legacies. For players like Juan Soto and Ronald Acuna Jr., their autographs represent significant growth potential. Non-autograph parallels, such as the Josh Naylor Gold or Mike Trout Red, can provide strong value if they are visually appealing and possess a degree of scarcity that drives collector demand. Always compare raw prices to any available graded comps to understand the potential upside of grading.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most valuable cards in the 2019 Topps Total set in 2026?
The most valuable cards are led by autographs of top stars. As of July 2026, Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s Autograph is valued at $499.99 raw, followed closely by Albert Pujols’ Autograph at $499.99 raw, and Juan Soto’s Autograph at $399.99 raw. Select high-tier parallels also command significant prices.
Are autographs the only valuable cards in 2019 Topps Total?
No, while autographs lead the pack, high-end parallels can also be very valuable. The Josh Naylor [Gold] card is ranked fourth with a raw price of $317.50, demonstrating that premium parallels can compete with some autographs for collector attention and investment potential.
What is the raw price of the Mike Trout [Red] card in 2019 Topps Total?
The Mike Trout [Red] card is valued at $199.99 raw as of July 2026. Mike Trout’s consistent elite performance ensures his cards maintain a high market value across various releases and parallels.
How does grading impact the value of 2019 Topps Total cards?
Grading can significantly increase a card’s value, especially for rare or highly sought-after cards. While specific PSA 10 medians are not extensively available in our verified data for this set, achieving a high grade like PSA 10 for cards like the Vladimir Guerrero Jr. autograph or Josh Naylor Gold could unlock substantial profit, provided the raw card’s market price justifies the grading cost and risk.
Should I invest in the 2019 Topps Total set now?
Investing now in 2026 depends on your risk tolerance and collecting goals. Top autographs from players like Guerrero Jr., Pujols, and Soto offer immediate high value. For those seeking growth potential, cards of emerging stars like Acuna Jr. or Valdez, or desirable parallels like the Naylor Gold, could be strategic acquisitions. Always research current market trends and individual player performance.
The 2019 Topps Total set offers a compelling mix of established legends and rising stars, with its top cards showcasing the enduring appeal of autographs and the market power of premium parallels. By focusing on players with strong career trajectories and understanding the nuances of card types, collectors can make informed decisions. For further insights into building a winning sports card portfolio, explore our guide on Best Sports Cards to Grade (2026 Guide). Discover more about the dynamic world of sports card collecting at What The Slab.