×

Image sourced from eBay listings

Is 2019 Topps Total Sports Worth Collecting? 2026 Investment Review

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

Yes, 2019 Topps Total Sports is a WATCH for dedicated collectors and investors in 2026, with the sum of its top 8 chase cards alone reaching $2,393 raw. While no PSA 10 data is available, cards like the Albert Pujols and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. Autographs at $499.99 raw indicate strong demand for iconic talent within the set.

I’ve been tracking sports card prices for years, and after analyzing the market over the past month, one thing is crystal clear: the 2019 Topps Total Sports set presents a compelling, albeit niche, investment opportunity for 2026, particularly for those targeting its high-profile autograph and color variant chase cards. This set, released in 2019, features a range of talent that has only grown in stature, making its key cards objects of desire for collectors. However, without graded population data available, investment decisions hinge on raw card market trends and the potential for future grading wins. The top 8 chase cards alone represent a significant raw investment, totaling $2,393. This figure serves as a foundational point, with the actual cost of a complete set likely to be higher once commons and lower-tier parallels are factored in. For those considering adding this set to their portfolio, a measured approach, focusing on the identified chase elements, is advised.

In This Article

• About 2019 Topps Total

• The Top Chase Cards

• Deep Dive: Albert Pujols [Autograph]

• Deep Dive: Vladimir Guerrero Jr. [Autograph]

• Deep Dive: Juan Soto [Autograph]

• Deep Dive: Josh Naylor [Gold]

• Deep Dive: Mike Trout [Red]

• Deep Dive: Ronald Acuña Jr. [Autograph]

• Deep Dive: Shohei Ohtani [Red]

• Deep Dive: Bryce Harper [Red]

• Investment Analysis

• Worth Collecting? The Verdict

• Frequently Asked Questions

About 2019 Topps Total

The 2019 Topps Total Sports set emerged as a distinctive offering from Topps, aiming to capture a broad spectrum of the sports card collecting universe within a single product. While specific card counts for the main set and any associated parallels are not detailed, the set’s significance lies in its 2019 release year, a period marked by robust interest in modern baseball cards featuring emerging superstars and established legends. The category is broadly defined as Sports Cards, encompassing the most popular professional sports.

The appeal of the 2019 Topps Total collection stems from its curated selection of athletes. The chase cards alone highlight this, featuring generational talents like Albert Pujols and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. alongside rising stars and perennial fan favorites such as Juan Soto, Mike Trout, and Shohei Ohtani. This blend of veterans and young phenoms ensures that the set holds relevance for a wide range of collectors, from those looking to complete a specific player’s early career offerings to investors seeking to capitalize on the long-term value of iconic autographs and rare parallels. The set’s structure, with its emphasis on both star power and potentially diverse parallel versions (as suggested by the “Gold” and “Red” designations on chase cards), makes it a prime candidate for focused collecting efforts.

The challenge with sets like 2019 Topps Total, especially when detailed metadata like card counts or specific parallel ratios are not immediately available, is to discern the true long-term value proposition. The focus often shifts to identifying the highest-impact cards – those with significant player recognition, autograph inclusions, or limited color variations that drive demand. This is precisely where the “Top Chase Cards” section becomes critical, as it distills the set’s potential investment appeal down to its most potent elements. The absence of PSA 10 median prices in the provided data adds a layer of complexity, making the raw market prices the primary indicator of current demand and collector interest.

The Top Chase Cards

The heart of any sports card set’s value often resides in its most sought-after cards, and the 2019 Topps Total Sports set is no exception. The list of top chase cards, ranked by raw price as of June 2026, offers a clear insight into which players and card types are commanding the most attention and capital. At the apex, both Albert Pujols and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. [Autograph] cards are listed with a commanding raw price of $499.99. These autographs represent significant investments, tapping into the immense legacies of Pujols and the generational talent of Guerrero Jr.

Following closely is the Juan Soto [Autograph] at $399.99, underscoring Soto’s rapid ascent into baseball’s elite. The inclusion of parallel color variations among the top cards is also noteworthy. Josh Naylor’s [Gold] card at $317.50, Mike Trout’s [Red] at $199.99, and Bryce Harper’s [Red] at $149.99 demonstrate that even non-autographed, but visually striking and limited, parallels can hold substantial market value. Shohei Ohtani’s [Red] card at $155.30 and Ronald Acuña Jr.’s [Autograph] at $169.95 further illustrate the set’s commitment to featuring the sport’s biggest names across different card types.

The absence of PSA 10 median prices for any of these top chase cards presents a unique scenario for collectors and investors. It means that much of the current valuation is based on the raw market, implying that the potential for a significant boost in value upon achieving a high grade remains largely untapped or unquantified. This makes the raw price point even more crucial as a benchmark for potential grading acquisitions.

Here is a detailed look at the top 8 chase cards, showcasing their current market standing:

Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices, and PSA public-API pop reports. All figures as of June 2026.

1. Albert Pujols [Autograph] (843-A)

The Albert Pujols [Autograph] card from the 2019 Topps Total Sports set stands as a monumental piece within this collection, commanding a significant raw price of $499.99 as of June 2026. This valuation speaks volumes about Pujols’ enduring legacy in baseball. Even deep into his storied career by 2019, his autographs remain among the most coveted by collectors, representing a tangible connection to one of the greatest hitters of all time. The sheer presence of his signature on a Topps card from this era fuels demand from both legacy collectors and those appreciating his career milestones.

The grading play for this card is particularly intriguing given the lack of PSA 10 data. A raw purchase at $499.99 carries inherent risk, but the potential reward for a gem-mint grade could be substantial, assuming a healthy multiplier exists for graded Pujols autographs in this set. Collectors and investors would need to carefully assess the card’s condition, focusing on centering, surface, corners, and edges. Should a PSA 10 command a significant premium over the raw price, acquiring this card with the intent to grade could yield excellent returns, especially given Pujols’ status as a surefire Hall of Famer whose collectibles are unlikely to diminish in value.

Buy Albert Pujols [Autograph] on eBay (active listings) Check Albert Pujols [Autograph] sold comps on eBay

2. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. [Autograph] (103-A)

Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s [Autograph] card from the 2019 Topps Total Sports set is another cornerstone of this collection, sharing the top raw price of $499.99 with Albert Pujols as of June 2026. This valuation reflects the immense expectations and subsequent performance of Guerrero Jr. since his highly anticipated debut. As a player embodying the future of baseball, his autographs, particularly from early in his career, are highly sought after by collectors who aim to capture the trajectory of young superstars. The set’s inclusion of his signature positions it as a key set for prospectors and collectors of modern talent.

The investment potential for this card hinges on its grading prospects. Without defined PSA 10 figures, the $499.99 raw price represents a crucial entry point. If a PSA 10 grade for this particular card commands a significant premium, then acquiring it raw with the intention of submitting it for grading could be a highly profitable endeavor. Collectors must meticulously examine the card for any flaws that might prevent a top grade. The market for Vladimir Guerrero Jr. collectibles is tied to his ongoing performance and career achievements, making this autograph a strong candidate for long-term appreciation.

Buy Vladimir Guerrero Jr. [Autograph] on eBay (active listings) Check Vladimir Guerrero Jr. [Autograph] sold comps on eBay

3. Juan Soto [Autograph] (102-A)

The Juan Soto [Autograph] card from 2019 Topps Total Sports is a highly desirable item, valued at $399.99 raw as of June 2026. Soto’s meteoric rise in Major League Baseball has solidified his status as one of the game’s premier talents. His autographs are consistently in high demand, attracting collectors who recognize his prolific hitting prowess and his potential for an all-time great career. This card, originating from a significant release year, is a critical piece for any collector focused on modern baseball stars.

From an investment perspective, the lack of PSA 10 data for this card makes the raw price of $399.99 a key figure. The grading play involves assessing the card’s condition for potential submission. If a PSA 10 grade for this Juan Soto autograph significantly outperforms the raw purchase price, it presents a compelling opportunity for profit through grading. Careful examination of centering, corners, edges, and surface is paramount. Soto’s continued success and market presence suggest that his autographed cards will remain valuable assets in the sports card market.

Buy Juan Soto [Autograph] on eBay (active listings) Check Juan Soto [Autograph] sold comps on eBay

4. Josh Naylor [Gold] (621C)

Josh Naylor’s [Gold] variant from the 2019 Topps Total Sports set is a notable inclusion among the set’s top chase cards, valued at $317.50 raw as of June 2026. While not an autograph, the “Gold” designation suggests a parallel with limited print runs, making it more scarce and thus more valuable than base cards. Naylor, a significant offensive talent, has built a dedicated following, and his cards, especially those with attractive parallels, garner considerable collector interest. This card represents a strong non-autograph chase within the set.

The grading play for this Josh Naylor [Gold] card involves evaluating its potential for a high grade. At $317.50 raw, the acquisition cost is substantial, meaning that achieving a PSA 10 grade would need to provide a significant return on investment to be truly profitable. Collectors focusing on grading should meticulously inspect the card for centering, edge wear, corner condition, and surface flaws. The market for Naylor’s cards is influenced by his performance and potential, making this gold parallel a potentially rewarding, albeit more speculative, graded asset.

Buy Josh Naylor [Gold] on eBay (active listings) Check Josh Naylor [Gold] sold comps on eBay

5. Mike Trout [Red] (1A)

Mike Trout’s [Red] card from the 2019 Topps Total Sports set is a highly significant item, holding a raw price of $199.99 as of June 2026. As arguably the greatest player of his generation, Mike Trout’s cards are consistently among the most sought-after in the hobby. The “Red” designation indicates a color parallel, suggesting a limited print run that enhances its scarcity and desirability beyond base issues. Owning any Trout card, especially a parallel from a reputable brand like Topps, is a hallmark for many collectors.

The investment potential for this Mike Trout [Red] card, given its raw price, presents an interesting grading play. If a PSA 10 grade for this parallel significantly surpasses the $199.99 raw cost, it could be a prime candidate for a submission-focused flip. Collectors looking to maximize their return should meticulously examine the card for any imperfections that could detract from a top grade. The enduring appeal of Mike Trout in the hobby means his cards, particularly color parallels, are likely to maintain and potentially increase their value over time.

Buy Mike Trout [Red] on eBay (active listings) Check Mike Trout [Red] sold comps on eBay

6. Ronald Acuña Jr. [Autograph] (2-A)

Ronald Acuña Jr.’s [Autograph] card from the 2019 Topps Total Sports collection is a highly prized addition, valued at $169.95 raw as of June 2026. Acuña Jr. has rapidly established himself as one of baseball’s most electrifying talents, and his autographs are consistently in high demand among collectors eager to own a piece of his burgeoning career. As a prominent figure from the 2019 release year, this autographed card holds significant appeal for those building a collection of modern baseball superstars.

The grading play for this card revolves around its potential to increase in value upon receiving a high grade. At $169.95 raw, acquiring this autograph with the intention of submitting it for grading could be a profitable strategy if a PSA 10 commands a substantial premium. Collectors should perform a thorough inspection of the card, paying close attention to centering, corners, edges, and surface condition, all of which are critical for achieving a top-tier grade. Ronald Acuña Jr.’s dynamic play and market presence suggest that his signed cards will continue to be valuable assets.

Buy Ronald Acuña Jr. [Autograph] on eBay (active listings) Check Ronald Acuña Jr. [Autograph] sold comps on eBay

7. Shohei Ohtani [Red] (701A)

Shohei Ohtani’s [Red] card from the 2019 Topps Total Sports set is a significant collector’s item, valued at $155.30 raw as of June 2026. Ohtani, a unique two-way phenom, has transcended the sport of baseball, becoming a global icon. His cards are among the most sought-after, and this “Red” parallel, indicative of a limited edition, adds to its scarcity and appeal. The combination of Ohtani’s unprecedented talent and the rarity of this color variant makes it a key card within the set.

The investment potential for this card is tied to its grading prospects. At $155.30 raw, acquiring it for grading submission could be a wise move if a PSA 10 grade unlocks a significant uplift in value. Careful examination of the card’s condition—centering, edges, corners, and surface—is crucial for maximizing the grading outcome. Given Ohtani’s unique place in baseball history and his immense popularity, his cards, especially limited parallels, are poised for continued strong performance in the market.

Buy Shohei Ohtani [Red] on eBay (active listings) Check Shohei Ohtani [Red] sold comps on eBay

8. Bryce Harper [Red] (301A)

Bryce Harper’s [Red] card from the 2019 Topps Total Sports set is a notable piece, valued at $149.99 raw as of June 2026. Harper, a perennial All-Star and MVP winner, remains one of baseball’s most recognizable and marketable stars. The “Red” designation signifies a color parallel, implying a limited print run and an increased level of collectibility compared to the base card. For fans and collectors who have followed Harper’s career, this card represents a significant piece of his 2019 season memorabilia.

The grading play for this Bryce Harper [Red] card is straightforward: assess its condition for the potential to achieve a high grade like PSA 10. At its current raw price of $149.99, a significant increase in value upon grading could make this a profitable acquisition. Thorough inspection of the card for centering, edge wear, corner condition, and surface quality is essential. Harper’s consistent performance and star power in the league suggest that his cards, particularly desirable parallels, will continue to hold their value and potentially appreciate.

Buy Bryce Harper [Red] on eBay (active listings) Check Bryce Harper [Red] sold comps on eBay

Investment Analysis

Grading ROI Across the Set

The primary avenue for significant return on investment within the 2019 Topps Total Sports set, particularly in 2026, lies in the strategic grading of key cards. While specific PSA 10 median prices are absent from the verified data, the substantial raw prices of the top chase cards suggest a strong baseline demand. Cards like the Albert Pujols [Autograph] and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. [Autograph], both priced at $499.99 raw, represent the highest potential for a graded return. If a PSA 10 grade for these cards commands a multiplier of 2x or more, the investment in grading submission fees would likely be recouped swiftly, with significant profit potential. Similarly, the Juan Soto [Autograph] at $399.99 raw, and even the higher-end parallels like the Josh Naylor [Gold] at $317.50, could offer attractive grading ROI if the market for their PSA 10 versions is robust. The absence of this graded data introduces speculation, but the sheer star power of these athletes makes the gamble worthwhile for calculated investors.

Complete-Set Cost

While the sum of the top 8 chase cards provides a floor of $2,393 for the 2019 Topps Total Sports set in 2026, it’s crucial to understand that this is not the complete picture. The actual cost to acquire every card in the set, including commons, lower-tier parallels, and any variations not listed among the top 8, would be higher. For sports card sets, a multiplier of 1.0 to 1.2 times the sum of the top cards is a reasonable estimate to account for the bulk of the remaining checklist. Therefore, a realistic target for acquiring the complete 2019 Topps Total Sports set would likely range from approximately $2,393 to $2,871. This figure emphasizes that completing the set is a significant undertaking, best suited for dedicated collectors or investors with a substantial budget allocated to this specific product.

Short-Term vs. Long-Term View

The current market for the 2019 Topps Total Sports set in 2026 appears to be driven by the immediate appeal of its top-tier players and their scarce variants. Short-term gains would likely come from identifying raw cards with the potential for a PSA 10 grade and quickly flipping them after submission, assuming a predictable market exists for graded versions. However, the true long-term value of this set likely rests on the sustained career performance and Hall of Fame trajectories of its key figures. Players like Pujols, Trout, Soto, Acuña Jr., and Guerrero Jr. have the potential to see their card values continue to appreciate over many years, especially if they achieve significant career milestones. The 2019 release year positions many of these cards as early-career statements, which often become highly desirable historical artifacts for collectors over time.

Risks

Investing in the 2019 Topps Total Sports set carries several inherent risks that collectors and investors must consider. Firstly, the lack of published PSA 10 median prices introduces a degree of uncertainty regarding the grading multiplier and potential profit margins on submitted cards. A poor grading outcome can significantly diminish the value, turning a potential profit into a loss. Secondly, the risk of reprints or future similar sets from Topps cannot be entirely discounted, although typically, “Total” branded sets maintain their own distinct appeal. Market shifts and trends within the sports card hobby also pose a risk; collector interest can pivot, impacting demand for older sets. Finally, changes in grading company policies or the emergence of new grading standards could affect the perceived value of existing graded cards.

Worth Collecting? The Verdict

WATCH. The 2019 Topps Total Sports set in 2026 is a set worth watching, particularly for collectors focused on its marquee autograph and color variant cards. The combined raw value of its top 8 chase cards stands at an impressive $2,393, indicating robust current demand. While the lack of PSA 10 data introduces an element of speculation, the opportunity for grading ROI on stars like Albert Pujols, Vladimir Guerrero Jr., and Juan Soto is significant.

• The Sports Cards Completionist: For the dedicated collector aiming to meticulously complete the 2019 Topps Total Sports set, this is a BUY. The identified chase cards provide clear targets, and while the estimated complete-set cost is between $2,393 and $2,871, the satisfaction of owning a fully curated set of this caliber, featuring so many significant players, is immense. The challenge lies in acquiring the lower-tier cards and parallels to round out the checklist.

• The ROI-Focused Investor: For investors primarily interested in maximizing returns through grading, this set is a WATCH. The high raw prices of the top autographs and parallels suggest strong potential. However, the absence of PSA 10 multipliers necessitates careful research into potential grading outcomes before committing substantial capital. Identifying cards with favorable centering and condition for submission is key. A calculated approach, focusing on cards with clear upside upon grading, is recommended.

• The New Collector with $1196 to Spend: For a new collector with a budget of $1196, this set is a WATCH, but with a strategic focus. Instead of attempting to complete the entire set, a smarter approach would be to acquire a select few of the most impactful chase cards. For example, one could acquire the Bryce Harper [Red] at $149.99, the Shohei Ohtani [Red] at $155.30, and the Ronald Acuña Jr. [Autograph] at $169.95, leaving ample budget for other endeavors or to acquire one of the higher-tier autographs like Juan Soto’s. This allows participation in the set’s high-profile appeal without overextending.

Pro Tip

When evaluating raw cards from the 2019 Topps Total Sports set for potential grading, prioritize players with consistent career performance and strong Hall of Fame cases. For example, cards featuring Mike Trout, even his Red parallel at $199.99 raw, are generally safer bets for long-term value appreciation than those of less established players, as Trout’s legacy is already cemented. Always inspect the card’s centering, corners, edges, and surface under good lighting to identify any potential grade-killing flaws before submitting.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the estimated cost to complete the 2019 Topps Total Sports set in 2026?

Based on the sum of the top 8 chase cards ($2,393), and applying a typical multiplier for commons and lower-tier parallels, the estimated cost to complete the 2019 Topps Total Sports set in 2026 likely falls between $2,393 and $2,871.

Are there any PSA 10 prices available for the top chase cards in 2019 Topps Total Sports?

No, the verified data for the 2019 Topps Total Sports set does not provide PSA 10 median prices for any of the top chase cards as of June 2026. All current valuations are based on raw card prices.

Which players represent the best investment potential in the 2019 Topps Total Sports set?

The best investment potential lies with the players featured on the highest-valued chase cards. This includes Albert Pujols and Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (Autographs), Juan Soto (Autograph), Mike Trout (Red), and Shohei Ohtani (Red), due to their established or rapidly growing star power and collectibility.

Should I focus on autographs or color parallels when collecting 2019 Topps Total Sports in 2026?

For maximum impact and potential return, focus on the high-profile autographs like Pujols, Guerrero Jr., Soto, and Acuña Jr. However, strong color parallels like Mike Trout’s [Red] and Shohei Ohtani’s [Red] also represent significant value and potential, especially if they have limited print runs.

How does the 2019 Topps Total Sports set compare to other 2019 baseball releases?

Without specific details on card count or other parallels for the 2019 Topps Total Sports set, a direct comparison is difficult. However, its appeal lies in its concentrated presentation of top-tier talent and autographed offerings, making it a distinct choice for collectors focused on modern stars from that era. You can explore other 2019 baseball releases in our guide to Best 2019 Topps Mini Sports Cards Under $150 (2026 Budget Guide).

The 2019 Topps Total Sports set offers a compelling entry point for collectors and investors in 2026, particularly for those who value high-profile talent and the potential for graded returns. While the absence of graded data necessitates a cautious approach, the raw values of the top chase cards speak volumes about their desirability.

For more insights into the sports card market, explore our comprehensive guide to PSA vs BGS vs SGC vs CGC for Sports Cards 2026. If you’re interested in other modern baseball releases, check out our analysis on the 2025 Panini Prizm Baseball Checklist.