Verified comps. Grading math. No guesswork.
most valuable duskmourn house of horror mtg cards

Top 10 Most Valuable Duskmourn House of Horror MTG Cards (2026)

Published 2026-05-28 · Updated 2026-11-05 · by Jason Trogdon
TCG Collectibles 12 min read
RAW $220PSA 10 $282MULTIPLIER 1.3×PRICES AS OF May 28, 2026

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The top 10 most valuable Duskmourn House of Horror Magic: The Gathering cards range from $94.22 to $261.62 in raw condition, with Enduring Vitality leading the pack. For collectors and investors looking to capitalize on the set’s burgeoning market, focusing on these key cards is crucial for maximizing returns in 2026.

In This Article

The Top 10 Duskmourn House of Horror Market Data

# Card Set PSA 10 PSA 9 Raw Grading ROI Trend
1 Enduring Vitality Duskmourn House of Horror — — $261.62 — —
2 Valgavoth, Terror Eater Duskmourn House of Horror $282.04 — $219.99 -14.5% —
3 Overlord of the Balemurk Duskmourn House of Horror — — $209.85 — —
4 Overlord of the Hauntwoods Duskmourn House of Horror — — $186.75 — —
5 Enduring Courage Duskmourn House of Horror — — $180.30 — —
6 Enduring Tenacity Duskmourn House of Horror — — $167.16 — —
7 Enduring Curiosity Duskmourn House of Horror — — $165.56 — —
8 Kaito, Bane of Nightmares Duskmourn House of Horror $101.50 — $107.55 -50.7% —
9 Overlord of the Mistmoors Duskmourn House of Horror $244.00 — $94.22 33.8% —

Grading ROI assumes a PSA 10, graded at PSA’s cheapest open tier for the card’s value (Standard $59.99 up to $1,000; PSA’s Value tiers are paused; fees checked October 12, 2026), sold on eBay (13.25% fee + $0.40) with an estimated $5 shipping. No figure is given above $10,000, where PSA publishes no fee.

Data sources: What The Slab checks eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices.

1. Enduring Vitality (404)

Enduring Vitality #404

Leading the charge in Duskmourn House of Horror’s value metric is Enduring Vitality, commanding an impressive raw price of $261.62. This card’s position at the apex of the market isn’t a surprise when considering its potent ability to provide persistent advantage, a hallmark of sought-after Magic: The Gathering cards. While raw data is robust, there is currently no PSA 10 price available, indicating that graded examples are scarce or have yet to establish a firm market presence. This scarcity, coupled with its high raw value, suggests that the first few PSA 10 copies that emerge could fetch a significant premium, potentially far exceeding its current raw valuation.

Buy Enduring Vitality (404) on TCGPlayer Buy Enduring Vitality (404) on eBay

2. Valgavoth, Terror Eater (407)

Valgavoth, Terror Eater #407

Securing the second spot is Valgavoth, Terror Eater, with a raw price of $219.99 and a PSA 10 price of $282.04. Its Grading Return on Investment (ROI) is -14.5%, an expected loss of $40.71 per card. The gap between the raw price and the PSA 10 price ($62.05) is smaller than PSA’s $59.99 Standard fee plus eBay selling fees and shipping, so a PSA 10 does not pay for itself at current prices.

Buy Valgavoth, Terror Eater (407) on TCGPlayer Buy Valgavoth, Terror Eater (407) on eBay

3. Overlord of the Balemurk (401)

Overlord of the Balemurk #401

The third most valuable card in Duskmourn House of Horror, based on raw price, is the Overlord of the Balemurk at $209.85. Similar to Enduring Vitality, there is currently no PSA 10 price available for this card, highlighting a potential scarcity of high-grade examples or an emerging market. The Overlord’s name and implied power level suggest it’s a significant creature within the set’s lore and gameplay. Its raw value already places it firmly in the upper echelon of Duskmourn House of Horror singles.

Buy Overlord of the Balemurk (401) on TCGPlayer Buy Overlord of the Balemurk (401) on eBay

4. Overlord of the Hauntwoods (405)

Overlord of the Hauntwoods #405

Coming in fourth, the Overlord of the Hauntwoods holds a significant raw price of $186.75. Like its Balemurk counterpart, this card currently lacks a PSA 10 price, pointing towards a nascent graded market and potential scarcity. The substantial raw price indicates established demand, and the absence of graded data means there’s room to influence the market value of PSA 10 specimens.

Buy Overlord of the Hauntwoods (405) on TCGPlayer Buy Overlord of the Hauntwoods (405) on eBay

5. Enduring Courage (402)

Enduring Courage #402

The Enduring Courage card secures the fifth position with a raw price of $180.30. This joins Enduring Vitality and Enduring Tenacity as part of a valuable cycle within the Duskmourn House of Horror set. As with several other high-ranking cards in this list, there is no PSA 10 price data available, suggesting that graded examples are rare or yet to be established in significant numbers. The strategy here is to identify well-centered, low-defect raw copies and submit them for grading, capitalizing on the potential for substantial appreciation if a strong PSA 10 market emerges.

Buy Enduring Courage (402) on TCGPlayer Buy Enduring Courage (402) on eBay

6. Enduring Tenacity (400)

Enduring Tenacity #400

Slotting in at seventh is Enduring Tenacity, valued at $167.16 in raw condition. This card further solidifies the “Enduring” cycle’s prominence, showing consistent demand and value. Once again, there’s a notable lack of PSA 10 price data, reinforcing the theme of an emerging graded market for Duskmourn House of Horror’s top cards. The potential upside from a PSA 10 grade could be significant, especially if the card proves to be a staple in competitive play or highly sought after by Commander enthusiasts.

Buy Enduring Tenacity (400) on TCGPlayer Buy Enduring Tenacity (400) on eBay

7. Enduring Curiosity (398)

Enduring Curiosity #398

The Enduring Curiosity card rounds out the “Enduring” cycle’s strong showing in the top 10, listed at a raw price of $165.56. Consistent with its counterparts, there is no PSA 10 price data available, indicating an immature graded market for this particular card. The sustained high raw values across the “Enduring” series underscore their importance and desirability within the Duskmourn House of Horror set. The potential for significant value appreciation upon achieving a PSA 10 grade is a primary driver for this investment approach. Its position in the top 10 is a testament to its perceived value and collector appeal.

Buy Enduring Curiosity (398) on TCGPlayer Buy Enduring Curiosity (398) on eBay

8. Kaito, Bane of Nightmares (409)

Kaito, Bane of Nightmares #409

Kaito, Bane of Nightmares, enters the list at ninth place with a raw price of $107.55 and a PSA 10 price of $101.50. While its raw price is substantial, the PSA 10 price is actually lower, resulting in a negative Grading ROI of -50.7%, or an expected loss of $84.89 per graded card. This data suggests that, for Kaito, the current market doesn’t fully reward perfect grades over raw copies, or that the graded supply might be outstripping demand at the PSA 10 level for this specific card. However, a raw price point over $100 still signifies significant interest.

Buy Kaito, Bane of Nightmares (409) on TCGPlayer Buy Kaito, Bane of Nightmares (409) on eBay

9. Overlord of the Mistmoors (397)

Overlord of the Mistmoors #397

Concluding the top 10 is the Overlord of the Mistmoors, with a raw price of $94.22 and a PSA 10 price of $244.00. This card demonstrates a remarkable Grading ROI of 33.8%, translating to a profit of $52.06. This is by far the highest ROI in the top 10, making Overlord of the Mistmoors an exceptionally attractive target for the “buy and grade” strategy. The significant disparity between its raw price and its PSA 10 valuation suggests that collectors and investors are heavily valuing high-grade copies of this particular Overlord. Its strategic placement at the bottom of the top 10, yet possessing such a high ROI, highlights the potential for significant profit margins for those who can source quality raw copies and secure a PSA 10 grade.

Buy Overlord of the Mistmoors (397) on TCGPlayer Buy Overlord of the Mistmoors (397) on eBay

The Grading ROI Play

The “buy and grade” strategy is particularly potent for cards where the jump in value from raw to PSA 10 is substantial.

Overlord of the Mistmoors (397) stands out as the prime example, boasting an impressive 33.8% Grading ROI. With a raw price of $94.22, grading it at PSA’s $59.99 Standard tier (PSA’s Value tiers are paused) brings the total cost to $154.21. A PSA 10 sale at the $244.00 price nets $206.27 after eBay’s $32.73 selling fee and an estimated $5 shipping, an expected profit of $52.06 per card, making it the clear grading target in this top 10.

Valgavoth, Terror Eater (407), by contrast, shows a -14.5% ROI. The raw price is $219.99, and the PSA 10 price is $282.04. With PSA’s $59.99 Standard fee, the total cost is $279.98, while a $282.04 PSA 10 sale nets $239.27 after eBay fees and shipping, an expected loss of $40.71 per card. A raw copy would need to cost $179.28 or less to break even, so grading Valgavoth for profit does not work at current prices.

Kaito, Bane of Nightmares (409), however, presents a cautionary tale in the grading ROI department. With a raw price of $107.55 and a PSA 10 price of $101.50, it carries a -50.7% ROI. Even before PSA’s $59.99 Standard fee, the PSA 10 price sits below the raw price. Attempting to grade Kaito for profit in 2026 would be ill-advised.

The key takeaway is that while many Duskmourn House of Horror cards may lack established PSA 10 pricing, the presence of strong positive ROIs on cards like Overlord of the Mistmoors and Valgavoth, Terror Eater, signal clear opportunities for those willing to invest in grading.

Pro Tip: When evaluating raw copies of Duskmourn House of Horror cards for grading, pay exceptionally close attention to the centering and edge wear. The set’s aesthetic and potential for pristine condition are key factors driving the value of PSA 10 grades, especially for cards where the raw market is already robust. Cards with even minor imperfections may not achieve the premium prices associated with top grades, making careful selection paramount for maximizing your Grading ROI.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Duskmourn House of Horror a good set to collect in 2026?

Yes, Duskmourn House of Horror is showing strong potential for collectors in 2026, particularly if focusing on its highest-value cards. The top 10 cards range from $94.22 to $261.62 raw, with Overlord of the Mistmoors (397) showing the clearest grading upside at a 33.8% Grading ROI.

Which Duskmourn House of Horror cards have the highest raw prices?

The highest raw prices in Duskmourn House of Horror are led by Enduring Vitality (404) at $261.62, followed closely by Valgavoth, Terror Eater (407) at $219.99, and Overlord of the Balemurk (401) at $209.85.

Which Duskmourn House of Horror cards offer the best grading potential?

Overlord of the Mistmoors (397) stands out with an exceptional 33.8% Grading ROI, indicating a substantial price increase from its raw value ($94.22) to its PSA 10 price ($244.00). Valgavoth, Terror Eater (407) shows a -14.5% Grading ROI, a loss at current fees. Many other top cards lack PSA 10 data, presenting opportunities for early graders.

Should I buy raw or graded copies of Duskmourn House of Horror cards?

For cards like Overlord of the Mistmoors (397), Valgavoth, Terror Eater (407), and the other high-value “Enduring” and “Overlord” cards, a “buy and grade” strategy is recommended due to strong grading ROI potential. Kaito, Bane of Nightmares (409) has a negative Grading ROI, so grading currently does not add value.

What is the overall market trend for Duskmourn House of Horror cards?

The emergence of graded market data for cards like Valgavoth, Terror Eater (407) and Overlord of the Mistmoors (397) indicates a developing secondary market driven by both raw acquisition and the pursuit of high-grade specimens.

Understanding these key cards and adopting strategic acquisition and grading practices will be crucial for collectors and investors in 2026. For a broader overview of current TCG market trends and investment strategies, be sure to explore our guides at What The Slab.

Data: PriceCharting · eBay sold listings. Analysis: What The Slab. How we get our numbers.

Price data, not financial advice. Past sales don't predict future value. We may earn a commission on eBay, TCGplayer and Amazon links.

J

About Jason

Jason has been collecting cards since 1999 and retro video games since 2008. Based in the Southeast US. What The Slab cites real eBay sold comps, PriceCharting data, and PSA pop reports — no guesswork. Read more → · How we get our numbers