×

Top 10 Most Valuable Modern Horizons 3 MTG Cards (2026)

This post contains affiliate links — we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

The top 10 Modern Horizons 3 cards range from $83 to $1,962 raw in 2026, with the serialized Emrakul leading at PSA 10 $3,019 (32% grading ROI). The serialized Eldrazi trio dominates the top of this list, driven by collector-driven scarcity rather than playability.

90-day sold data shows the top Modern Horizons 3 cards medianing at a significant $1,962 for raw copies, with the serialized Emrakul, The World Anew leading the pack at a 32.3% grading ROI for PSA 10 graded copies. The serialized Eldrazi titans, Emrakul, Ulamog, and Kozilek, occupy the top three spots, showcasing the immense collector demand for these unique variants. Beyond the serialized wonders, premium foils like Ulamog, the Defiler and Ocelot Pride, alongside fetch lands, demonstrate substantial value. This analysis, based on verified eBay sold comps and PriceCharting data, highlights a market where scarcity and unique printings command top dollar. Last updated: April 2026.

In This Article

• The Top 10 Modern Horizons 3 Market Data

• 1. Emrakul, The World Anew [Serialized] (381)
• 1. Ulamog, The Defiler [Serialized] (383)
• 1. Kozilek, The Broken Reality [Serialized] (382)
• 1. Ulamog, the Defiler [Borderless Foil] (383)
• 1. Ocelot Pride [Borderless Foil] (322)

The Top 10 Modern Horizons 3 Market Data

Data sources: Prices cited above reflect eBay sold comps, PriceCharting market prices, and PSA pop reports. All figures as of April 2026.

1. Emrakul, The World Anew [Serialized] (381)

The undisputed king of Modern Horizons 3’s early market is Emrakul, The World Anew in its serialized variant. With a raw price of $1,962 and a PSA 10 median hitting a staggering $3,019, this card represents the pinnacle of collector demand for the set. The impressive 32.3% grading ROI, translating to a profit of $639.97 based on the provided data, makes it a prime target for those looking to capitalize on the graded card market. The serialization inherently limits the supply, creating a scarcity that drives prices far beyond typical card valuations. For collectors seeking the ultimate prize from Modern Horizons 3, this serialized Emrakul is the clear objective. Its astronomical value is a testament to the power of unique printings and limited availability in the Magic: The Gathering secondary market.

Buy Emrakul, The World Anew (381) on TCGPlayer Buy Emrakul, The World Anew (381) on eBay

2. Ulamog, The Defiler [Serialized] (383)

Following closely behind Emrakul is the serialized Ulamog, The Defiler, commanding a substantial raw price of $1,878. While data for its PSA 10 grade is not available, its position in the top ranks indicates immense collector interest. The serialized nature of this card, much like Emrakul, is the primary driver of its high valuation. Players and collectors alike recognize the rarity and prestige associated with these unique print runs. The visual impact of Ulamog, combined with the Eldrazi’s iconic status in Magic’s lore, adds to its desirability. For those who can acquire this card, holding onto it or seeking a high-grade submission could prove to be a lucrative endeavor, assuming a strong PSA 10 market emerges.

Buy Ulamog, The Defiler (383) on TCGPlayer Buy Ulamog, The Defiler (383) on eBay

3. Kozilek, The Broken Reality [Serialized] (382)

Rounding out the top three serialized titans is Kozilek, The Broken Reality, with a raw price of $1,525. Like Ulamog, its PSA 10 median is unavailable, but its placement at rank three underscores its significant market value. The trio of serialized Eldrazi titans represents a unique and highly sought-after segment of the Modern Horizons 3 release. This convergence of iconic characters, serialized exclusivity, and the raw power they represent in gameplay translates directly into market demand. Collectors are willing to invest heavily in these pieces, recognizing their potential for long-term value appreciation. The strategy for this card mirrors that of Ulamog: secure a raw copy and aim for the highest possible grade to maximize its market potential.

Buy Kozilek, The Broken Reality (382) on TCGPlayer Buy Kozilek, The Broken Reality (382) on eBay

4. Ulamog, the Defiler [Borderless Foil] (383)

Moving away from the serialized rarities, Ulamog, the Defiler in its Borderless Foil iteration secures the fourth spot with a raw price of $130.04. This card demonstrates that even non-serialized premium variants can achieve significant value. The borderless art offers a stunning visual appeal, and the foil treatment adds a layer of premium collectibility. For players and collectors who may not have the budget for the serialized versions, this borderless foil provides a highly desirable alternative. Its value is likely driven by its combination of powerful artwork, desirable finish, and its place as one of the set’s iconic Eldrazi. This card is a strong contender for players looking to add a splash of high-end flavor to their decks or display.

Buy Ulamog, the Defiler (383) on TCGPlayer Buy Ulamog, the Defiler (383) on eBay

5. Ocelot Pride [Borderless Foil] (322)

Ocelot Pride, in its Borderless Foil form, lands at number five with a raw price of $118.28. This card’s inclusion in the top ranks suggests a strong collector appeal that transcends pure playability, likely due to its unique art and premium treatment. The “Borderless Foil” designation is a key indicator of desirability, offering an enhanced aesthetic that appeals to collectors seeking visually striking cards. While specific gameplay applications might not be the primary driver of its value, the combination of a popular creature type, eye-catching art, and a premium finish positions it as a valuable commodity within the Modern Horizons 3 set. This card is a prime example of how unique artistic treatments can elevate a card’s market standing.

Buy Ocelot Pride (322) on TCGPlayer Buy Ocelot Pride (322) on eBay

6. Flooded Strand [Foil] (436)

The presence of Flooded Strand in its Foil iteration at rank six, with a raw price of $114.90, highlights the enduring value of staple lands within Magic: The Gathering. Fetch lands, especially those from premium sets, are always in demand due to their utility in various formats and their role in enabling powerful mana bases. The foil treatment further enhances its collectibility, making it a desirable upgrade for players and a potential long-term hold for investors. Even without a PSA 10 median listed, the raw value is substantial, indicating strong market confidence in its evergreen playability and collectible status. This card is a solid choice for anyone looking to invest in foundational Magic: The Gathering staples.

Buy Flooded Strand (436) on TCGPlayer Buy Flooded Strand (436) on eBay

7. Polluted Delta [Foil] (438)

Similar to Flooded Strand, Polluted Delta in its Foil version claims the seventh spot with a raw price of $102.64. This card is another testament to the consistent demand for high-quality land cards in Magic: The Gathering. Polluted Delta, a key fetch land, is essential for many competitive decks across multiple formats, ensuring its consistent market presence. The foil treatment adds an extra layer of appeal for collectors and players alike, distinguishing it from its non-foil counterpart. The raw price indicates strong market traction, making it a reliable investment piece. For those looking to complete land sets or enhance their decks with premium components, Polluted Delta is a compelling option.

Buy Polluted Delta (438) on TCGPlayer Buy Polluted Delta (438) on eBay

8. Wooded Foothills [Foil] (441)

Wooded Foothills, in its Foil variant, secures the eighth position with a raw price of $85.73 and a PSA 10 median of $125.00. This data point reveals a slight negative grading ROI of -1.9%, suggesting that, at this specific moment, selling raw might be marginally more profitable than sending it to PSA for grading and immediate resale. However, the PSA 10 value still represents a premium over the raw price, indicating that graded copies hold their value well. Wooded Foothills is a highly sought-after fetch land, crucial for many archetypes. Its consistent demand, combined with the premium of a foil finish, makes it a solid collectible and a valuable addition to any Magic player’s arsenal.

Buy Wooded Foothills (441) on TCGPlayer Buy Wooded Foothills (441) on eBay

9. Ocelot Pride [Borderless] (322)

Ocelot Pride appears again, this time in its Borderless non-foil version, ranking ninth with a raw price of $84.41. The PSA 10 median for this variant is $72.00, resulting in a significant grading ROI of -44.8%. This starkly negative ROI suggests that grading this particular card at this time is not financially advantageous. The market appears to favor raw copies of Ocelot Pride, or perhaps collectors are less willing to pay a premium for PSA 10 graded versions of the borderless non-foil compared to the raw purchase price. This data points towards a strategy of acquiring raw copies if you’re looking to add it to a collection or trade fodder.

Buy Ocelot Pride (322) on TCGPlayer Buy Ocelot Pride (322) on eBay

10. Kaalia of the Vast [Borderless Foil] (343)

Rounding out the top 10 is Kaalia of the Vast in its Borderless Foil treatment, boasting a raw price of $83.22 and a PSA 10 median of $249.00. This card offers an outstanding grading ROI of 105.0%, translating to a potential profit of $108.41. This high ROI indicates a strong market preference for graded copies, particularly at the PSA 10 tier. Kaalia of the Vast is a historically popular commander, and this premium borderless foil version likely appeals to a dedicated fanbase looking for a high-quality representation of the card. For collectors and investors, this presents a prime opportunity to acquire a card with significant upside potential through grading.

Buy Kaalia of the Vast (343) on TCGPlayer Buy Kaalia of the Vast (343) on eBay

The Grading ROI Play

When looking at the investment potential of Modern Horizons 3 cards, the Grading Return on Investment (ROI) is a critical metric. The data reveals some clear winners for those looking to leverage the grading market.

Kaalia of the Vast [Borderless Foil] (343) stands out with an exceptional 105.0% Grading ROI. This means that if you purchase this card raw for $83.22, and then pay an estimated $20 for grading fees, you would need to sell the PSA 10 copy for approximately $105.31 to break even ($83.22 raw + $20 grading = $103.22 break-even cost). Selling at the PSA 10 median of $249.00 offers a substantial profit of $108.41. This card is a prime candidate for grading, as the market clearly shows a significant demand premium for high-grade copies.

Emrakul, The World Anew [Serialized] (381) also offers a robust 32.3% Grading ROI. With a raw price of $1,962 and a PSA 10 median of $3,019, the break-even point for a graded copy (assuming $20 grading fee) is around $1,982. Selling at the $3,019 median yields a profit of $639.97. While the initial investment is significantly higher, the profit margin is substantial, making it a highly attractive option for collectors with larger budgets. The serialized nature of this card inherently limits supply, bolstering its long-term value retention and appeal to high-end collectors.

Conversely, cards like Ocelot Pride [Borderless] (322) with a -44.8% Grading ROI are currently underperforming in the grading market. The raw price is $84.41, and the PSA 10 median is $72.00. To break even on this card with grading ($84.41 raw + $20 grading = $104.41), you would need to sell the PSA 10 for over $104. Given the current median of $72.00, grading this specific variant appears to be a losing proposition right now. Collectors might find more value in acquiring raw copies or focusing on other variants where grading is more profitable.

Buying Strategy for 2026

The Modern Horizons 3 set presents a diverse market, from ultra-rare serialized titans to highly playable staple lands and premium foil treatments. Developing a strategic approach is key to maximizing your collection’s value and enjoyment.

Buy Strategy Notes:

• Serialized Eldrazi: If budget allows, these are the ultimate prizes of the set. Aim for PSA 10 if possible, or hold raw for potential future grading. Their scarcity is a primary value driver.

• Fetch Lands (Foil): Flooded Strand and Polluted Delta offer stable, long-term value due to their consistent playability. These are safe buys for both players and investors.

• Kaalia of the Vast [Borderless Foil]: This card is a prime candidate for grading. The high ROI suggests a significant market for PSA 10 copies. Acquire raw and submit for grading.

• Ocelot Pride Variants: The Borderless Foil offers strong raw value ($118.28), while the plain Borderless ($84.41 raw, $72.00 PSA 10) shows a negative grading ROI, making raw acquisition the better path for that specific version.

Pro Tip: Focus on the serialized Eldrazi trio and the premium foil lands for reliable long-term value appreciation in the Modern Horizons 3 set. While serialized cards represent the highest ceiling due to extreme scarcity, the foil fetch lands provide a stable foundation for any collection, consistently supported by their evergreen playability across various Magic formats. Always verify current market trends and pop reports before making significant investment decisions, especially when considering the grading of high-value cards.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the most valuable cards in Modern Horizons 3?

The most valuable cards in Modern Horizons 3 are dominated by the serialized Eldrazi titans: Emrakul, The World Anew [Serialized] ($1,962 raw, $3,019 PSA 10), Ulamog, The Defiler [Serialized] ($1,878 raw), and Kozilek, The Broken Reality [Serialized] ($1,525 raw). These cards command premium prices due to their extreme scarcity and iconic status.

Is it worth grading cards from Modern Horizons 3?

Yes, grading can be highly profitable for certain Modern Horizons 3 cards. Kaalia of the Vast [Borderless Foil] shows an impressive 105.0% grading ROI, and Emrakul, The World Anew [Serialized] offers a 32.3% ROI. However, cards like Ocelot Pride [Borderless] have shown negative ROI, meaning raw acquisition is better for those variants.

How do serialized cards impact the market?

Serialized cards, like the Eldrazi titans in Modern Horizons 3, create significant market value through extreme scarcity. Emrakul, The World Anew [Serialized] leads the set with the highest raw and graded prices, demonstrating that limited print runs can drive collector demand far beyond typical card valuations.

Are fetch lands still valuable in Modern Horizons 3?

Absolutely. Foil versions of staple fetch lands such as Flooded Strand [Foil] ($114.90 raw) and Polluted Delta [Foil] ($102.64 raw) remain highly valuable due to their consistent playability and demand across multiple Magic: The Gathering formats. They represent a stable investment for both players and collectors.

What is the difference in value between borderless and regular variants?

Borderless and foil treatments generally command higher prices than their regular counterparts. For example, Ulamog, the Defiler [Borderless Foil] ($130.04 raw) is significantly more valuable than its hypothetical regular version. Similarly, Kaalia of the Vast [Borderless Foil] ($83.22 raw, $249.00 PSA 10) shows immense value in its premium finish, especially when graded.

The secondary market for Modern Horizons 3 is dynamic, with serialized cards and premium foil treatments leading the charge in value. For those looking to invest or collect the best of the set, focusing on the Eldrazi titans, high-demand fetch lands, and cards with strong grading ROI like Kaalia of the Vast presents a clear path forward. Understanding these market trends, as detailed by verified sold comps and PriceCharting data, is crucial for making informed decisions. Explore more strategies for building your collection and maximizing your investments by checking out our MTG Card Investing Guide: Best Strategies for 2026.